Philosophy / Islamic and medieval European
Scholasticism
The medieval method of reasoned argument in the schools and universities of Latin Christendom
- Began
- c. 1100Scholars: Historians often trace its roots to the schools of the 11th century, and some to the Carolingian revival of learning in the 9th century. It reached its fullest form in the universities of the 13th century.
- Where
- Western Europe, especially the cathedral schools and universities of Paris, Oxford, Bologna and Cologne
- Key figures
- No single founder. Early figures include Anselm of Canterbury and Peter Abelard.
- Key works
- Proslogion (Anselm); Sic et Non (Abelard); Four Books of Sentences (Peter Lombard); Summa Theologiae (Thomas Aquinas); Ordinatio (John Duns Scotus)
At a glance
Scholasticism was a way of teaching and thinking used in medieval European schools and universities. Its thinkers were mostly Christian, and many were friars or priests. They used careful reasoning to understand religious faith and the natural world.
It grew in the cathedral schools of the 11th and 12th centuries. Over the 12th and 13th centuries, works of Aristotle reached Latin readers in several waves, through translations from Greek and from Arabic, along with Arabic commentaries such as those of Ibn Rushd (Averroes). Scholars used these texts in different ways. Averroist readings of Aristotle were contested, and some were condemned in Paris in 1277.
It is known as much for its method as for its conclusions. Scholars posed a question, set out arguments on both sides, gave an answer and replied to objections. Many scholastics saw faith and reason as working together, though they disagreed about how far each could go. The tradition included several schools, among them Thomism, Scotism and Augustinian currents. Nominalism is a broader position on universals that was also developed within it, notably in the 14th century.
Key concepts
- Disputation
- A formal debate in which a question is argued from both sides under rules, and then settled by a master.
- Summa
- A large, ordered survey of a whole field of knowledge, built from many questions and answers.
- Universals
- General terms or kinds such as redness or humanity, whose status was much debated: realists held they have some real existence, while others treated them as concepts or terms.
- Substance and accident
- An Aristotelian pair: a substance is a being that is a subject in its own right, and accidents are features that exist only in a substance, such as its colour or size.
- Natural theology
- The attempt to know about God by reasoning from the world, without relying only on revelation.
- Quaestio
- A structured question with arguments for and against and a reply, an important genre of scholastic teaching and writing alongside commentaries and sermons.
Core ideas
- Many scholastics held that faith and reason both come from God, so they should not finally contradict each other.
- Truth can be approached by clear definitions, careful distinctions and logical argument.
- Authorities such as the Bible, the Church Fathers and Aristotle were respected, and scholars interpreted, compared and reconciled them, though they disagreed about which authorities and principles should prevail.
- In the Latin universities theology was often ranked as the highest science, and thinkers differed on how it related to philosophy and how independent philosophy was.
- Arguments should be set out in public, with the strongest objections stated and answered.
- The world has an order that human reason can partly grasp.
Key arguments
The five ways
Thomas Aquinas offered five lines of argument from features of the world, such as motion and cause, towards the existence of God. He presented them briefly in the Summa Theologiae, and later readers have debated how they should be interpreted and how demonstrative they are.
The ontological argument
In the Proslogion Anselm reasoned from the idea of God as that than which nothing greater can be thought, and argued that such a being must exist in reality and not only in the mind. Interpreters still debate what exactly his argument is and whether it succeeds.
The problem of universals
Do general kinds exist apart from individual things? Realists said they do in some way. Nominalists generally denied that universals exist as separate things and held that only individuals exist, with some treating universals as concepts and others as signs in language.
Sic et non
Abelard collected apparently conflicting statements from authorities. He argued that careful questioning and attention to meaning could help resolve them.
Branches
- ThomismThe philosophy and theology of Thomas Aquinas and the schools that followed him
- NominalismA family of medieval views that deny that universals exist as things apart from individuals and the mind
Philosophers
- Anselm of Canterbury c. 1033–1109Benedictine archbishop who sought to understand faith by reason and formulated the ontological argument.
- Peter Abelard 1079–1142Logician and teacher in Paris who promoted the method of questioning conflicting authorities.
- Thomas Aquinas c. 1225–1274Dominican friar who joined Aristotelian philosophy with Christian theology, the source of Thomism.
- John Duns Scotus c. 1266–1308Franciscan thinker known for subtle arguments on being, will and the individual.
- William of Ockham c. 1287–1347Franciscan philosopher associated with nominalism and with economy in explanation.
Main criticisms
Is it too bound by authority?
Early modern critics such as Descartes said the schools relied on inherited authority and Aristotle's framework instead of starting from new foundations. Defenders reply that scholastics argued openly, distinguished and sometimes rejected authorities, and that the method trained rigorous thought.
Is the style too technical?
Critics have found its fine distinctions and specialised vocabulary obscure and remote from ordinary problems. Defenders say the precision was needed for exact argument and that its terms can be learned like those of any science.
Can faith and reason be joined?
Some critics hold that mixing reasoning with revealed doctrine harms both. Scholastics usually distinguished truths that reason can demonstrate from mysteries known only by revelation, such as the Trinity. They disagreed among themselves about how far demonstration could reach, and defenders say reason could clarify and defend faith without replacing it.
Did it hinder natural science?
Some early modern thinkers argued that scholastic physics blocked new discoveries. Historians today are divided, and defenders point to medieval work on logic, motion and optics that later science drew on.
Sources
- Pasnau, Robert. "Medieval Philosophy." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of medieval philosophy and its Latin schools.
- Marenbon, John. Medieval Philosophy: An Historical and Philosophical Introduction. London: Routledge, 2006.Survey of the period from late antiquity to the 14th century.
- Pieper, Josef. Scholasticism: Personalities and Problems of Medieval Philosophy. New York: Pantheon, 1960.Short introduction by a sympathetic Thomist author.
- Aquinas, Thomas. Summa Theologiae. Translated by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province. London: Burns, Oates and Washbourne, 1920–1925.