Philosophy / Greek and Roman

Aristotelianism

The school founded by Aristotle, which studies nature, living things, ethics and reasoning through careful inquiry

Began
335 BC, when Aristotle established his school, the Lyceum, in Athens; the wider tradition continued in later centuries
Where
Athens, Greece, later spreading across the Mediterranean and the Near East
Key figures
Aristotle (384–322 BC); his associate Theophrastus led the school after him
Key works
Organon (collected logical works); Physics; Metaphysics; Nicomachean Ethics; Politics

At a glance

Aristotelianism is the tradition of thought that follows Aristotle, a Greek philosopher who studied in Plato's Academy. He established his own school, the Lyceum, in Athens in 335 BC. Its members were also called Peripatetics. The name may come from the peripatos, a covered walkway, or from the habit of walking while teaching, but its origin is uncertain.

Aristotle's thought developed within the Academy and in response to Platonism, and it became a separate tradition. He admired Plato but disagreed with him on a key point. He held that the forms, the patterns that make things what they are, are found in individual things and not in a separate realm. His own account of form and universals is complex, and scholars still discuss it.

The school studied almost everything: logic, physics, biology, ethics, politics, poetry and the first causes of things. Its method began with sense experience and with what people commonly say, and then looked for explanations. Later it shaped Arabic-language philosophy (falsafa) and medieval Latin Scholasticism.

Key concepts

Substance (ousia)
The individual thing, such as a particular horse or person, which is the basic kind of being on which other features depend.
Four causes
Four ways of answering why something is as it is: its matter, its form, what brought it about, and its purpose.
Telos
The end or purpose toward which things in nature, and human activities, are directed.
Eudaimonia
Flourishing, the full and good life that Aristotle took to be the aim of human action.
Virtue (arete)
An excellence of character or mind, developed by habit and often found between two extremes.
Syllogism
A form of argument in which a conclusion follows necessarily from two premises.

Core ideas

  • Knowledge begins with sense experience, and inquiry starts from observed facts and commonly held opinions.
  • Every natural thing can be understood through its matter, form, source of change and purpose.
  • Form and matter are not separate; forms exist in individual things.
  • Humans flourish by exercising reason and by developing virtues of character through habit.
  • Humans are by nature social, and the political community exists to enable the good life.
  • Valid reasoning can be studied systematically, and Aristotle laid the foundations of formal logic.

Key arguments

The four causes

To explain a bronze statue, one names the bronze, the shape it was given, the sculptor who made it, and the purpose it serves. Aristotle argued that a full explanation needs all four.

The doctrine of the mean

Courage lies between cowardice and recklessness. The right amount is not fixed by a formula but is found by a person of practical wisdom judging the situation.

The function argument

A good flute player is one who plays well, so the good for a human should lie in doing well what is distinctive of humans. Aristotle concluded that human flourishing is activity of the soul in accordance with virtue, above all the virtue of reason.

The unmoved mover

Aristotle held that the cosmos is eternal and that its everlasting motion needs an explanation. He argued for an unmoved mover that causes motion as an object of desire and love, as a final cause, and described it as pure thought thinking itself. He also discussed several such movers for the heavenly spheres.

Philosophers

  • Aristotle 384–322 BCBorn in Stagira, he studied with Plato, tutored Alexander the Great and founded the Lyceum.
  • Theophrastus c. 371–287 BCAristotle's successor as head of the Lyceum, known for his works on plants and on character types.
  • Alexander of Aphrodisias fl. c. AD 200An important ancient commentator on Aristotle's works.
  • Ibn Sina (Avicenna) c. 980–1037Persian philosopher who built a major system in the Aristotelian tradition.
  • Ibn Rushd (Averroes) 1126–1198Andalusian thinker famous for his detailed commentaries on Aristotle.
  • Thomas Aquinas c. 1225–1274Christian theologian who combined Aristotle's philosophy with Christian teaching.

Main criticisms

Purpose in nature

Early modern scientists such as Galileo and Bacon argued that explaining nature by purposes was unhelpful and that physics should use mechanical causes. Defenders say that purpose-based explanation remains natural for living things, and that some modern thinkers have revived it for biology.

Do his physics and astronomy hold up?

Critics note that his theories of motion and of the heavens were gradually replaced in the 16th and 17th centuries, through the work of Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo, Newton and others. Defenders reply that he was working with the evidence available and that his method of observation and classification was productive, especially in biology.

Is virtue ethics too vague?

Critics say that telling people to do what the wise person would do gives little concrete guidance. Defenders reply that ethics is not an exact science and that moral judgement depends on situations that rules cannot fully cover.

Views on slavery and women

Aristotle defended natural slavery and held that women were naturally subordinate in the household, views many thinkers have rejected. Some defenders argue that these claims conflict with his own principles, and others treat them as separable from the rest of his philosophy.

Sources

  1. Shields, Christopher. "Aristotle." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of his life, works and main doctrines.
  2. Barnes, Jonathan. Aristotle. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1982.Short, clear introduction to his thought, in the Past Masters series, later reissued as a Very Short Introduction.
  3. Lear, Jonathan. Aristotle: The Desire to Understand. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988.Study of his overall philosophical system.
  4. Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics. Translated by Terence Irwin. 3rd ed. Indianapolis: Hackett, 2019.His main work on virtue and the good life.