Philosophy / Islamic and medieval European

Falsafa

The Arabic-language philosophy of the medieval Islamic world, built on Greek thought

Began
9th century, with al-Kindi in Baghdad
Where
Baghdad and the wider Islamic world, later Muslim Spain (al-Andalus) and Persia
Key figures
No single founder; al-Kindi is usually called the first major philosopher in Arabic
Key works
The Book of Healing (Avicenna); The Opinions of the Citizens of the Virtuous City (al-Farabi); The Decisive Treatise (Averroes); Hayy ibn Yaqzan (Ibn Tufayl); On First Philosophy (al-Kindi)

At a glance

Falsafa is the Arabic word for philosophy. It names the tradition of thinkers who wrote in Arabic between the 9th and 12th centuries, and in some regions later. Most were Muslim, and some were Christian or Jewish. They asked about God, the universe, the soul and knowledge, using reason and argument.

It grew out of the Arabic translation movement. From the 8th and 9th centuries, scholars in Baghdad and elsewhere translated Greek works on philosophy, medicine and science into Arabic. Aristotle became so central that Arabic philosophers honoured him as the First Teacher. Some texts that reached them were Neoplatonic works wrongly credited to Aristotle, so Aristotelian and Neoplatonic ideas were blended, in different ways by different thinkers.

Many falsafa thinkers held that philosophy and revelation could agree, though they differed on how, and on who may interpret scripture. Their writings also shaped medieval Jewish and Latin Christian thought after being translated into Hebrew and Latin. Later traditions of reading and developing their work are called Avicennism and Averroism. Other Muslim scholars, such as al-Ghazali, criticised some of its teachings.

Key concepts

Falsafa
The Arabic term, borrowed from Greek, for philosophy and for the tradition of Greek-inspired thought in Arabic.
The First Teacher
The honorific given to Aristotle, whose works were the basis of study in logic, physics and metaphysics.
Necessary Existent
In Avicenna's system, God is the one being whose existence is necessary in itself, while everything else is merely possible in itself and needs a cause to exist.
Active Intellect
A non-physical intelligence in the systems of thinkers such as al-Farabi and Avicenna, understood differently by each, which plays a part in how human minds come to know universal truths.
Emanation
A Neoplatonic-influenced cosmology, found in al-Farabi and Avicenna, in which the world flows from God in ordered stages.
Prophecy
A subject of much discussion; al-Farabi and Avicenna explained it partly through a prophet's exceptional intellect and imagination, while other thinkers and religious scholars understood revelation differently.

Core ideas

  • Reason, trained by logic, is a proper path to knowledge of God and the world.
  • Many falsafa thinkers held that sound philosophy and revealed religion do not truly conflict, though they explained the relation in different ways.
  • In the Avicennian and Farabian systems, God is the first cause and source of all existence, and is one and without parts.
  • Many falsafa thinkers held that nature is ordered by causes that can be studied and understood.
  • Many held that the human soul can know universal truths, and that its perfection lies in that knowledge.
  • Averroes held that scripture speaks to everyone in images, while qualified interpreters may seek deeper meanings through demonstration.

Key arguments

The Floating Man

Avicenna asked us to imagine a person created fully formed, floating in the air and unable to sense anything, even their own body. He argued that this person would still be aware of existing. Many readers take this to suggest that the self is distinct from the body, though how far the argument shows this is interpreted differently.

Necessary and possible existence

Avicenna distinguished things whose existence is necessary, possible or impossible. Things that are only possible need a cause for their existence. He argued that such causes cannot go back forever, so there must be a being whose existence is necessary in itself, which he identified with God.

Harmony of reason and revelation

In the Decisive Treatise, Averroes argued that the Quran itself encourages reflection on the world. So, he held, philosophy is permitted and even required for those capable of it.

The Virtuous City

Al-Farabi described an ideal state led by a ruler who combines philosophical wisdom with the gift of prophecy. Its people live in a way that leads them toward happiness.

Branches

  • AvicennismThe tradition built on Ibn Sina's philosophy, which reasoned about God, being and the soul within an Islamic setting
  • AverroismThe Aristotelian philosophy of Ibn Rushd and the Latin thinkers who followed his commentaries

Philosophers

  • Al-Kindi c. 801–c. 873Worked in Baghdad and is regarded as the first major philosopher writing in Arabic.
  • Al-Farabi c. 870–950Wrote on logic and political philosophy and was known as the Second Teacher after Aristotle.
  • Avicenna (Ibn Sina) c. 980–1037Built a full philosophical system that became hugely influential in the East and the Latin West.
  • Ibn Tufayl c. 1105–1185Andalusian writer of Hayy ibn Yaqzan, a tale of a man who gains knowledge through observation and reasoning, and then meets revealed religion.
  • Averroes (Ibn Rushd) 1126–1198Andalusian judge and commentator on Aristotle, whose commentaries were widely read in Latin Europe.

Main criticisms

Does philosophy contradict Islam?

Al-Ghazali, in The Incoherence of the Philosophers, argued that on some points, such as the eternity of the world, God's knowledge of particulars and bodily resurrection, the philosophers contradicted faith. Averroes replied in The Incoherence of the Incoherence that Ghazali misrepresented them. He held that when demonstrative proof conflicts with the apparent meaning of a text, qualified interpreters may read it figuratively, but not everyone may do so.

Does strict causation limit God?

Ash'ari theologians, a major school within Kalam, held that God acts directly in every event, and criticised the philosophers' natural causes as limiting God's freedom. Kalam was not uniform, and some theologians defended forms of causation. Defenders of falsafa answered that a stable order of causes is itself God's way of acting and makes knowledge of nature possible.

Is it too Greek?

Some critics saw falsafa as a foreign import resting on Greek authorities. Its defenders said that truth is welcome from any source, as al-Kindi argued, and that the thinkers reworked Greek ideas on their own terms and in response to Islamic questions.

Sources

  1. Adamson, Peter. Philosophy in the Islamic World. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016.A narrative history of falsafa and its context.
  2. Gutas, Dimitri. Greek Thought, Arabic Culture. London: Routledge, 1998.On the translation movement in Baghdad.
  3. Leaman, Oliver. An Introduction to Classical Islamic Philosophy. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001.A clear introduction to the major thinkers and themes.