Philosophy / Greek and Roman
Neoplatonism
The Greek and Roman Platonic tradition that traced all things back to a single, ultimate One
- Began
- 3rd century AD, with Plotinus teaching in RomeScholars: The name "Neoplatonism" is modern, coined in the 18th and 19th centuries. Its members saw themselves simply as Platonists. Historians treat the tradition as a family of related thinkers who differed on many points.
- Where
- The Roman Empire. Main centres included Rome, Apamea in Syria, Athens and Alexandria, with teaching in several of them at overlapping times.
- Key figures
- Plotinus is usually seen as the founder. Ammonius Saccas is traditionally named as his teacher.
- Key works
- Enneads (Plotinus); Elements of Theology (Proclus); On the Mysteries (Iamblichus); Platonic Theology (Proclus); Life of Plotinus (Porphyry), a biography and introduction to the Enneads
At a glance
Neoplatonism is the name now given to a tradition of Platonic philosophy that began in the 200s AD. It grew out of the work of Plato, who had lived about six centuries earlier. Its thinkers believed they were explaining what Plato really meant.
In the outline given by Plotinus, everything depends on one ultimate source, called the One. Intellect, then Soul, then the physical world depend on it in order of reality, not in order of time. Human beings can turn inward and upward toward this source.
Neoplatonists combined careful argument with spiritual practice, but they did not agree on everything. Iamblichus gave ritual (theurgy) a central role, and Proclus built a very detailed system of divine levels. Their ideas reached Christian, Jewish and Islamic thinkers, often indirectly and in varied ways.
Key concepts
- The One
- The ultimate source of everything, beyond all description, even beyond being and thought.
- Nous
- Intellect, which in Plotinus comes directly from the One and contains the eternal patterns (Forms) of all things.
- Soul
- The level of reality that gives life and order to the physical world, and to which human souls are related.
- Emanation
- The way lower levels are said to flow out from higher ones, like light from a sun, as a relation of dependence and not an event in time.
- Matter
- For Plotinus, the lowest limit of reality, described as a lack or near-nothingness; later thinkers explained it in different ways.
- Henosis
- Union with the One, the goal of the soul's ascent; thinkers differed on how far such union is possible and what it means.
- Theurgy
- Ritual practice, central for Iamblichus, in which the gods themselves are held to act to restore and elevate the soul.
Core ideas
- All reality depends on a single source, the One, which is simple and without parts.
- In Plotinus, reality is ordered in levels: the One, Intellect, Soul and then the physical world. Later thinkers worked out more elaborate orders.
- The human soul is held to be related to the higher realm and able to return toward it.
- The physical world is seen as a reflection of higher things, and matter as its faintest edge.
- The ascent is pursued through thought and moral discipline. For Plotinus this is mainly contemplation, while Iamblichus and some successors added theurgy.
- Neoplatonists generally tried to read Plato together with Aristotle and, to varying degrees, the Stoics, aiming to show a deeper agreement between them.
Key arguments
The One must come first
Plotinus argued that anything made of parts depends on those parts. So, on his view, the source of all things must be perfectly simple, and this is the One. Because it has no parts, words and concepts cannot truly describe it.
The sun and its light
Plotinus compared the One to a sun that gives off light without being reduced. In the same way, the One gives rise to Intellect without change or effort. Each level is a weaker image of the one above.
Sculpting yourself
Plotinus told his readers to be like a sculptor who chips away a statue until it shines. The soul becomes beautiful by removing what hides its true nature. This is a call for inner discipline.
Turning inward
Plotinus held that part of the soul always remains in the intelligible realm, so the divine can be found by looking within. The ascent is therefore a return home. Other Neoplatonists, such as Iamblichus, stressed more the soul's need for divine help.
Philosophers
- Plotinus c. 204/5–270 ADFounder of the tradition, whose lecture notes were gathered into the Enneads.
- Porphyry c. 234–c. 305 ADPlotinus's student, who edited the Enneads and wrote his teacher's biography.
- Iamblichus c. 245–c. 325 ADPhilosopher from Syria who gave ritual practice (theurgy) a central place.
- Proclus 412–485 ADHead of the Platonic school in Athens and the great systematiser of the tradition.
- Hypatia c. 350–415 ADPhilosopher and mathematician in Alexandria who taught Platonic philosophy.
Main criticisms
Is it faithful to Plato?
Some modern scholars argue that Neoplatonists read a mystical system into Plato that he did not write. Defenders reply that the Neoplatonists drew on real hints in his dialogues, such as the Good in the Republic and the One in the Parmenides.
How can the One produce anything?
Critics ask how a perfectly simple One can give rise to a varied world without changing itself. Neoplatonists answer that the One's overflow is natural and needs no change in it, as heat flows from fire.
Relations with Christian teaching
Christian writers responded in different ways, from Augustine's careful borrowing to outright rejection. Objections to emanation included worries that the world might follow necessarily from God and not from a free act, and about divine transcendence. Some Christian thinkers replied by identifying God with the One while treating creation as free.
What can ritual do for the soul?
Porphyry criticised some theurgic practices, though he allowed that ritual might have limited purifying uses, and he held that philosophy was the real path. Iamblichus replied that the embodied soul cannot save itself by thought alone, and that the gods themselves must act through the rites.
Sources
- Gerson, Lloyd P. "Plotinus." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of Plotinus's life and thought.
- Remes, Pauliina. Neoplatonism. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2008.A clear scholarly guide to the main thinkers and ideas.
- Gerson, Lloyd P., ed. The Cambridge Companion to Plotinus. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996.Essays on Plotinus and his legacy.
- Plotinus. The Enneads. Translated by Stephen MacKenna. London: Penguin, 1991.The main work of Plotinus in a standard English translation.