Philosophy / Greek and Roman
Platonism
The philosophy of Plato and the tradition that followed him, centred on Forms and the pursuit of the Good
- Began
- The Academy, c. 387 BC
- Where
- Athens, Greece, later spreading across the Greek and Roman world
- Key figures
- Plato, who founded the Academy. His teacher Socrates was a major influence and is the chief speaker in many of the dialogues.
- Key works
- Republic; Phaedo; Symposium; Timaeus; Meno
At a glance
Platonism is the tradition of philosophy that grew from the writings and teaching of Plato, an Athenian who lived from about 428 to 348 BC. Plato wrote dialogues, which are conversations in which Socrates and others question what justice, knowledge, beauty and goodness really are. Later thinkers read and developed these works in different ways, so Platonism is a long tradition with real disagreements inside it, not a single fixed doctrine.
Plato was shaped by Socrates, and also by earlier thinkers such as Parmenides, Heraclitus and the Pythagoreans. Around 387 BC he founded the Academy, a school near Athens. Historians debate how continuous its institution was and how to divide its phases, but it was a centre of Platonic study for a long time. Under Arcesilaus, in the third century BC, the Academy turned sceptical. He urged suspending judgement and denied that there is a secure test for telling true impressions from false ones.
Many Platonists hold that behind the changing things we see there are stable, non-physical realities, usually called Forms, and that knowing them is the highest aim of the mind. Later thinkers revived and reshaped this view as Neoplatonism. Aristotle, who studied at the Academy, went on to found a separate tradition.
Key concepts
- Forms
- The unchanging, non-physical patterns, such as Beauty or Justice, that make particular things beautiful or just.
- The Good
- In the Republic, the source that makes other things knowable and gives them value, compared there to the sun; the text also says it is beyond being, and scholars debate how it relates to the other Forms.
- Recollection (anamnesis)
- The idea, found in dialogues such as the Meno and Phaedo, that learning is partly remembering truths the soul already knew.
- The soul
- In several dialogues, the part of a person that is alive, knows and is moved to act, which Plato argues is distinct from the body and survives death, using different arguments in different works.
- Dialectic
- The method of careful question and answer used to test ideas and move towards understanding.
- The tripartite soul
- The view in the Republic that the soul has reason, spirit and appetite, and is healthy when reason leads.
Core ideas
- Real knowledge is different from opinion, because it concerns what is stable and unchanging.
- The Forms are more real than the changing objects the senses show us.
- In many dialogues the soul is distinct from the body, and caring for it matters most.
- Plato's dialogues link virtue closely to knowledge, a view strongest in Socratic arguments and treated in more qualified ways in later works. A good life means a well-ordered soul.
- In the Republic, Plato proposes that a just city would be ruled by those who understand the Good.
- Philosophy is a training of the mind to turn from appearances towards truth.
Key arguments
The Allegory of the Cave
In the Republic, prisoners chained in a cave take shadows on a wall for reality. One is freed and slowly sees the world outside and then the sun. Plato uses this to describe education as a turning of the soul towards the Good.
The Divided Line
Plato pictures understanding as a line with stages. The lower stages are imagining and belief about visible things. The higher stages are mathematical reasoning, which uses diagrams and assumptions, and dialectical understanding of the Forms, which aims at the Good.
Recollection in the Meno
Socrates guides an uneducated slave boy to solve a geometry problem by questions alone. Plato takes this to show that the boy already had the knowledge within him and was recalling it.
The Ladder of Love
In the Symposium, love of one beautiful body can lead step by step to love of beautiful souls, laws and knowledge, and finally to Beauty itself.
Branches
- NeoplatonismThe Greek and Roman Platonic tradition that traced all things back to a single, ultimate One
Philosophers
- Plato c. 428–348 BCAthenian philosopher who wrote the dialogues and founded the Academy.
- Socrates 469–399 BCPlato's teacher, who questioned people about virtue and appears as the main speaker in most dialogues.
- Aristotle 384–322 BCStudied at the Academy for about twenty years, then developed his own philosophy, which became Aristotelianism.
- Arcesilaus c. 316–241 BCHead of the Academy who led it towards scepticism.
- Plotinus c. 204–270 ADFounder of Neoplatonism, who reworked Plato's ideas around the One.
Main criticisms
The Third Man objection
Critics, including Aristotle, argued that if a Form explains what things share, a further Form would be needed to explain what the Form and the things share, and so on without end. Defenders reply that Forms may not be things of the same kind as their examples, and Plato himself raises the problem in the Parmenides.
Where are the Forms?
Aristotle rejected Forms that exist separately from the things that have them, holding that universal features exist in particular things. Some Platonists reply that unchanging truths, such as those of mathematics, need a stable basis that physical things cannot give, though Platonists have answered in different ways.
The ideal city
Some later thinkers, notably Karl Popper in the twentieth century, read the Republic as favouring rigid, authoritarian rule. Many scholars reply that it is a thought experiment about justice in the soul as much as in the state, and that Plato's intentions are debated.
Scepticism from within
Arcesilaus and later Academics argued that there is no secure criterion of truth, and claimed Socrates' questioning supported suspending judgement. Other Platonists held that the dialogues point to real knowledge of the Forms.
Sources
- Kraut, Richard. "Plato." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of Plato's life, method and main doctrines.
- Britannica Editors. "Platonism." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.Short account of Platonism and its later history.
- Annas, Julia. Plato: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003.Clear introduction for general readers.
- Plato. Republic. Translated by G. M. A. Grube, revised by C. D. C. Reeve. Indianapolis: Hackett, 1992.Source of the Cave, the Divided Line and the Good.