Philosophy / Greek and Roman
Pyrrhonism
The ancient Greek practice of suspending judgement, followed by calm
- Began
- Traditionally traced to Pyrrho of Elis, who was active c. 320 BC. The organised school is later.Scholars: Pyrrho's own views are debated. The school as an organised movement is usually dated to Aenesidemus in the 1st century BC, and its main surviving writings to Sextus Empiricus, in the late 2nd or early 3rd century AD.
- Where
- The Greek-speaking world. Pyrrho came from Elis. Later figures such as Aenesidemus and Sextus are linked with places such as Alexandria and Rome, though the evidence is uneven.
- Key figures
- Pyrrho of Elis, who wrote nothing, is the traditional inspiration. Later figures such as Timon of Phlius and Aenesidemus shaped the school.
- Key works
- Outlines of Pyrrhonism (Sextus Empiricus); Against the Professors (Sextus Empiricus); Lives of the Eminent Philosophers, Book 9 (Diogenes Laertius)
At a glance
Pyrrhonism was a school of ancient Greek philosophy. Its followers called themselves sceptics, from a Greek word meaning inquirers. In the later, best-documented form of the school, they suspended judgement on how things really are and kept inquiring.
The school is named after Pyrrho of Elis, who is said in ancient sources to have travelled with Alexander the Great's army and to have met Indian thinkers. Scholars debate how far these reports can be trusted. He left no writings. Ancient accounts describe him as calm and unconcerned, but what he actually taught is debated. The school took organised form in the 1st century BC under Aenesidemus, who came from the sceptical Academy, the school founded by Plato. How far Academic scepticism and Pyrrhonism influenced each other is debated.
What made it distinctive was its aim. Pyrrhonists did not just say that knowledge is impossible. They set opposing arguments against each other until they felt unable to choose. They then found, they said, that peace of mind (ataraxia) followed, like a shadow. The school disappears from the surviving record after the time of Sextus Empiricus, in the late 2nd or early 3rd century AD, and no clear end date is known. Its texts were rediscovered in Europe in the 16th century and influenced later thinkers.
Key concepts
- Epoché
- Suspension of judgement, the state of neither accepting nor rejecting a claim about how things really are.
- Ataraxia
- Freedom from worry and disturbance, the calm that Pyrrhonists said came after suspending judgement.
- Isostheneia
- The equal strength of opposing arguments, which leaves the sceptic unable to decide between them.
- Appearances (phainomena)
- What appears to be the case, which Pyrrhonists were willing to report and follow without asserting that it reveals the underlying nature of things.
- Modes (tropoi)
- Standard patterns of argument, such as the Ten Modes traditionally linked to Aenesidemus, used to bring about suspension of judgement.
- Zetetic
- Inquiring, a name for the sceptic who keeps investigating and does not claim to have found or ruled out the truth.
Core ideas
- Sceptics keep inquiring and do not claim that the truth has been found or that it cannot be found.
- For any claim, an opposing claim of equal strength can be set against it.
- Seeing this leads to suspension of judgement on questions about how things really are.
- Peace of mind follows from suspending judgement, and is not pursued directly.
- Pyrrhonists live by appearances, following nature, bodily needs, local customs and the arts they were taught.
- Their own arguments were treated as tools, like a ladder or a purge that removes itself along with what it clears.
Key arguments
The Ten Modes
Traditionally attributed to Aenesidemus, these ten ways show that the same thing appears differently, depending on the animal, the person, the sense used or the custom. Since appearances conflict, the sceptic cannot say which shows the thing as it is.
The Five Modes of Agrippa
These are disagreement, infinite regress, relativity, hypothesis and circularity. Any proof seems to need another proof without end, to rest on an assumption, or to go in a circle.
Acting without dogmatic belief
Critics asked how someone could act without firm beliefs. Sextus replied that sceptics withhold assent about non-evident matters, but still follow appearances, feelings, customs and skills. How far this counts as having beliefs is debated.
The sceptic's own claims
Sextus said that sayings such as 'nothing is more this than that' report the sceptic's present state and are not firm doctrines. They are used loosely and may undo themselves.
Philosophers
- Pyrrho of Elis c. 360–270 BCThe traditional inspiration of the school, who wrote nothing and was remembered for his calm, unworried way of life.
- Timon of Phlius c. 320–230 BCPyrrho's follower, who wrote verse that spread his teacher's ideas.
- Aenesidemus 1st century BCRevived Pyrrhonism as a school and is traditionally credited with the Ten Modes, though the evidence for this is indirect.
- Agrippa date uncertainNamed in later ancient sources as the author of the Five Modes.
- Sextus Empiricus active late 2nd or early 3rd century ADPhysician and writer whose surviving works are the fullest account of Pyrrhonism.
Main criticisms
Can anyone live without beliefs?
Critics, including ancient Stoics, argued that action needs belief, so a sceptic must hold some. Pyrrhonists replied that they act on how things appear and on custom, without claiming these are true. Scholars still debate how far this answer works.
Does scepticism refute itself?
Opponents said that doubting everything is itself a claim, or that the arguments rely on assumptions they should doubt. Pyrrhonists answered that they only report what seems persuasive to them now, and that their arguments may cancel themselves like a remedy that leaves with the illness.
Is calm worth the cost?
Some critics said that giving up the search for truth gives up something valuable. Pyrrhonists replied that they did not give up inquiry, only the claim to have settled it, and that the calm which followed was a welcome result.
Was it really a doctrine?
Scholars debate whether Pyrrho taught scepticism about knowledge or something about reality itself, and whether the later school kept his ideas. The evidence is thin, so reconstructions differ.
Sources
- Bett, Richard. "Pyrrho." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Covers Pyrrho's life and the debates over his views.
- Sextus Empiricus. Outlines of Scepticism. Translated by Julia Annas and Jonathan Barnes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.The main surviving account of Pyrrhonism by one of its practitioners.
- Bett, Richard. Pyrrho, His Antecedents, and His Legacy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000.A scholarly study of Pyrrho and the early school.
- Annas, Julia, and Jonathan Barnes. The Modes of Scepticism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985.Explains the Ten Modes and the arguments of Agrippa.