Philosophy / Greek and Roman
Presocratic philosophy
The earliest Greek thinkers to give reasoned accounts of nature, the gods and the cosmos
- Began
- c. 600 BCScholars: Tradition links Thales to a solar eclipse in 585 BC, which is the date ancient writers used for his prime. Historians treat this as a traditional date, not a secure one, and place him in the early 6th century BC. "Presocratic" is a modern label, and several of these thinkers were contemporaries of Socrates.
- Where
- Miletus and other Greek cities of Ionia (western Anatolia), then southern Italy, Sicily and Athens
- Key figures
- No single founder. Thales of Miletus is traditionally named as the first.
- Key works
- On Nature (a conventional title given to works attributed to Anaximander, Heraclitus and others, surviving only in fragments); Poem of Parmenides (fragments); Fragments of Heraclitus; Fragments of Empedocles (conventionally titled On Nature and Purifications); Fragments of Anaxagoras
At a glance
Presocratic philosophy is the modern name for the earliest Greek thinkers who asked what the world is made of and how it works. They began around 600 BC in Miletus, a Greek city on the coast of what is now Turkey. They offered explanations of nature based on reasons and observation that others could discuss and criticise.
The thinkers spread to Greek cities in Italy and Sicily, and later to Athens. They disagreed a great deal. Some said everything is one thing in different forms. Others said reality is made of many tiny particles, or that change is an illusion. Most of their writings are lost, and we know them from short quotations and from reports by later writers such as Aristotle.
The name "Presocratic" was made by modern scholars, and it covers many separate thinkers, not one organised school. Some were alive in Socrates' time. They wrote about nature, but also about the gods, the soul and how to live. The tree ends the category around 400 BC, but some ideas, such as atomism and Pythagorean teaching, were taken up and developed by later thinkers.
Key concepts
- Arche
- The first principle or basic stuff from which, many of these thinkers held, all things come and into which they return.
- Physis
- The Greek word for nature, meaning what things are and how they grow and behave on their own.
- Logos
- A word for reason, account or rational order, which Heraclitus used for the pattern underlying all change.
- Apeiron
- Anaximander's term for the boundless or unlimited, the source from which the world arises.
- Atoms and void
- Leucippus and Democritus held that everything is made of tiny indivisible bodies moving in empty space.
- Cosmos
- The world seen as an ordered whole, not a chaos.
Core ideas
- The world can be understood by human reason, and many of these thinkers gave natural explanations for events once told as acts of gods.
- Behind the many changing things we see, there is some underlying nature or principle.
- Different thinkers named that principle differently: water for Thales, the boundless for Anaximander, and air for Anaximenes.
- Heraclitus gave fire a central place, but scholars debate whether it is a basic stuff like water or air, or a symbol of constant change and ordered balance.
- Parmenides argued that what is cannot come to be or pass away, so that change and plurality are not what they seem.
- Empedocles, Anaxagoras and the atomists tried to explain change as the mixing and separating of lasting basic things, while Pythagoreans held that number and proportion lie at the heart of the world's order.
Key arguments
Everything flows
Heraclitus is famous for the saying that you cannot step into the same river twice. This wording is a later paraphrase, and the genuine fragments are somewhat different, but they also speak of rivers with ever-changing waters. He used the image to say that the world is constant change held together by a hidden unity.
Parmenides on what is
Parmenides argued that we cannot think or speak of what is not. From this he concluded that what exists is single, whole and unchanging, and that the senses mislead us about change.
Zeno's paradoxes
Zeno of Elea, a follower of Parmenides, offered arguments such as Achilles and the tortoise. They were meant to show that ordinary ideas of motion and plurality lead to contradictions.
Atoms and the void
The atomists replied to Parmenides by allowing empty space. Then indivisible atoms can move and combine, and the changes we see are rearrangements of them.
Philosophers
- Thales of Miletus c. 624–546 BCTraditionally the first philosopher, said to have held that everything comes from water.
- Anaximander c. 610–546 BCMilesian thinker who taught that the world arises from the boundless and is credited with an early map and cosmology.
- Pythagoras c. 570–495 BCFounder of a community in southern Italy that studied number, music and the soul; his own teachings are hard to separate from those of his followers.
- Heraclitus of Ephesus c. 540–480 BCThinker of change and the logos, known for his short, riddling sayings.
- Parmenides of Elea c. 515–450 BCAuthor of a poem arguing that what exists is one and unchanging.
- Democritus of Abdera c. 460–370 BCDeveloped the atomic theory with Leucippus.
Main criticisms
Philosophy, science or religion?
Some scholars have read these thinkers as early scientists, and others as religious teachers, especially in Pythagorean and Empedoclean teachings about the soul. Many recent scholars say the contrast is too sharp, since one thinker often combined natural explanation with theology, ethics and ritual. Defenders of the early-science reading reply that their natural explanations still marked a new style of inquiry.
Can we know what they taught?
Almost none of their works survive whole, and later writers such as Aristotle described them in terms of his own questions. Critics say this may distort them. Scholars reply that careful study of the surviving fragments and of many different reports allows a reasonable, though cautious, picture.
Parmenides against the senses
Critics, including later Greek thinkers, said that denying change goes against plain experience. Followers of Parmenides replied that argument must be preferred to appearances, which is why Zeno defended the view with paradoxes. The atomists accepted change but changed Parmenides' premises to allow it.
The break with myth
The old story says that Greek thought moved from myth to reason with Thales. Critics note that these thinkers still used religious language and drew on Near Eastern knowledge. Defenders say the real change was the habit of giving arguments that others could criticise.
Sources
- Graham, Daniel W. "Presocratic Philosophy." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of the main thinkers and the problems of evidence.
- Kirk, G. S., and J. E. Raven. The Presocratic Philosophers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1957.First edition of the standard collection of texts with translations and commentary; a second edition with Schofield appeared in 1983.
- Barnes, Jonathan. The Presocratic Philosophers. London: Routledge, 1982.Analytical study of the arguments.
- Warren, James. Presocratics. Stocksfield: Acumen, 2007.Short introduction for newcomers.