Philosophy / Islamic and medieval European

Avicennism

The tradition built on Ibn Sina's philosophy, which reasoned about God, being and the soul within an Islamic setting

Began
Early 11th century, with the major works of Ibn Sina (Avicenna); the later school grew over the following centuries
Where
Persia and Central Asia, later across the Islamic world and Latin Europe
Key figures
Ibn Sina (Avicenna, c. 980–1037), developed by later students, commentators and critics
Key works
The Book of Healing (Kitab al-Shifa); The Book of Salvation (al-Najat); Pointers and Reminders (al-Isharat wa-l-Tanbihat); The Book of Knowledge (Danesh-name-ye Ala'i)

At a glance

Avicennism is the tradition of philosophy that grew from the works of Ibn Sina, known in Latin as Avicenna. The term is used both for his own philosophy and, more often, for the way later thinkers read, taught, revised and argued with it. Ibn Sina wrote in Arabic and Persian in the early 11th century. His system covered logic, natural science, psychology and metaphysics, the study of what exists and why.

It grew out of falsafa, the Islamic tradition of philosophy that drew on Aristotle and later Greek writers. Ibn Sina reworked those ideas into a complete and carefully argued system, and offered philosophical accounts of themes such as God, the soul and prophecy. Avicennian philosophy became highly influential in several regions and periods. It existed alongside other traditions, such as kalam (theology), law and illuminationist philosophy, and it was often contested.

Its best-known features are the distinction between essence and existence, the argument for a Necessary Existent, and the thought experiment of the Floating Man. Its Latin translations in the 12th and 13th centuries shaped medieval European thought, including Thomas Aquinas.

Key concepts

Essence (mahiyya)
What a thing is, its nature, which can be thought about separately from whether it exists.
Existence (wujud)
The fact that a thing is, which Avicenna held is not part of what a thing is in itself; the exact status of this distinction has been debated since.
Necessary Existent (wajib al-wujud)
A being that cannot fail to exist and does not depend on anything else for its existence, identified by Avicenna with God, though it is still open to explanation and argument.
Possible existent (mumkin al-wujud)
A thing that might exist or not, and so needs a cause to exist.
Emanation (fayd)
The idea that the world follows from God through a series of intellects, celestial spheres and souls, not through a choice at one moment in time.
Active Intellect
A non-human intellect that, in Avicenna's account, works together with the human mind's own abstraction to bring its knowledge of universal ideas from potential to actual.

Core ideas

  • Essence and existence are distinct in thought, so no created thing explains its own existence by what it is.
  • Beings that are only possible depend on a cause, and Avicenna argued that the whole set of such beings cannot be explained by possible causes alone, so it depends on a Necessary Existent.
  • God is one, simple and without parts. Avicenna held that God knows particular things through knowing their universal causes, not as changing individual events in time, which is a technical position that others disputed.
  • The human soul is a non-physical substance, created with the body but able to exist without it.
  • Human knowledge involves the mind abstracting universal forms from experience, with the Active Intellect playing a causal role.
  • In Avicenna's account, prophecy has intellectual, imaginative and political sides, and philosophy and revelation can be reconciled.

Key arguments

The Floating Man

Imagine a person created fully formed, suspended in air, with no sensation of the body or the world. Avicenna argued that this person would still be aware that they exist. So the self, he said, is not the same as the body. Scholars debate how far this is a claim about self-awareness in the modern sense.

Necessary and possible

Anything whose existence is only possible needs something to bring it into being. Avicenna argued that a collection of such things cannot explain itself, so something must exist necessarily through itself. This is the Necessary Existent.

Essence and existence

We can understand what a triangle or a phoenix is without knowing whether one exists. So existence is not part of what a thing is. For created things, existence must come from outside.

Degrees of knowing

Avicenna described how the mind moves from sense experience to abstract ideas. He also proposed that some people grasp truths quickly by intuition. He held that prophets do so to the highest degree and also express truths through images and found laws for communities.

Philosophers

  • Ibn Sina (Avicenna) c. 980–1037Physician and philosopher whose works, including the philosophical Book of Healing, began the tradition; his Canon of Medicine is a medical work.
  • Bahmanyar ibn al-Marzuban died 1066Student of Ibn Sina who helped to spread and organise his teaching.
  • Fakhr al-Din al-Razi 1149–1209Theologian who wrote a major commentary on the Pointers and Reminders and also a substantial critique of parts of Avicenna's philosophy.
  • Nasir al-Din al-Tusi 1201–1274Scholar who wrote a commentary defending the Pointers and Reminders against al-Razi, while also reshaping and selecting from Avicenna's ideas.
  • Thomas Aquinas 1225–1274Christian theologian who drew on Avicenna's essence and existence distinction in his own work.

Main criticisms

Al-Ghazali's charges

Al-Ghazali (died 1111) argued, as a theologian, that Avicenna's views on the eternity of the world, God's knowledge of particulars and bodily resurrection amounted to unbelief. Some later philosophers answered that Avicenna's views could be read in harmony with scripture, or that al-Ghazali had misunderstood them. Many later thinkers took over much of Avicenna's logic and metaphysics while rejecting some of these doctrines.

Does God know particulars?

Critics said that if God knows particulars only through universal causes, God does not know individual events as individuals. Defenders said that this view protects God's unchanging nature, since knowing changing things as they change would introduce change in God. Critics considered this inadequate.

Emanation and divine freedom

Some theologians held that creation by emanation makes the world follow necessarily from God, leaving God no freedom to create otherwise or not to create. Avicennian thinkers replied that God's act flows from God's own nature and is not compelled by anything external, and that this is what divine freedom means for a perfect being.

Is existence a real addition?

Averroes (Ibn Rushd) and others argued that existence is not an extra feature added to essence. Followers of Avicenna answered that the distinction is needed to explain why created things depend on a cause. Later discussions in Islamic and Latin thought distinguished several senses of existence and of reality, and the question remained open.

Sources

  1. McGinnis, Jon. "Avicenna [Ibn Sina]." In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Overview of his life, logic, metaphysics and psychology.
  2. Gutas, Dimitri. Avicenna and the Aristotelian Tradition. Leiden: Brill, 1988.Study of Avicenna's sources and the transmission of his works.
  3. Adamson, Peter. Philosophy in the Islamic World. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016.Accessible history that includes Avicenna and his successors.
  4. Goodman, Lenn Evan. Avicenna. London: Routledge, 1992.Introduction to his thought.