Philosophy / Islamic and medieval European
Thomism
The philosophy and theology of Thomas Aquinas and the schools that followed him
- Began
- Aquinas wrote his major works between the 1250s and 1274; Thomism as a school grew after his death
- Where
- Aquinas taught in Paris and several Italian cities; later Thomism spread across Catholic Europe and beyond
- Key figures
- Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274)
- Key works
- Summa Theologiae; Summa Contra Gentiles; On Being and Essence; Disputed Questions on Truth; Commentary on Aristotle's Metaphysics
At a glance
Thomism is the thought of Thomas Aquinas, a Dominican friar and teacher of the 13th century, together with the later schools that follow and interpret him. Aquinas's own writings and the work of later Thomists are not always the same thing. It is a branch of Scholasticism, the method of teaching used in medieval universities, and it tries to show how reason and Christian faith fit together.
Aquinas drew heavily on Aristotle, whose works became available in Latin in his time after passing through Greek, Arabic and Latin channels over several centuries. He also used ideas from Islamic, Jewish and earlier Christian writers. He developed his distinction between what a thing is (its essence) and the fact that it is (its existence) in dialogue with Avicenna. Scholars still discuss how much he took from Avicenna and how much was his own.
Thomists hold that human reason can know many truths about the world, about morality and about God, and that faith adds truths reason cannot reach alone. Thomism grew into several schools after Aquinas's death. The Catholic Church has given Aquinas special honour, especially since Pope Leo XIII's encyclical Aeterni Patris in 1879. There have been several revivals since, and it is still taught and developed today.
Key concepts
- Essence and existence
- Essence is what a thing is, and existence is that it is; in created things Aquinas treats these as distinct, while in God they are the same, though interpreters differ on the details.
- Act and potency
- Following Aristotle, things are understood as what they actually are (act) and what they could become (potency).
- Analogy
- Words such as good or wise apply to God and to humans neither in exactly the same sense nor in wholly different senses, but in related ones.
- Natural law
- The moral order that human reason can discover by asking what is good for beings of our kind.
- Hylomorphism
- Every physical thing is a union of matter and form, and the human soul is the form of the living body.
- Virtue
- A stable good habit of character, such as courage or justice, which Thomists see as central to a good life, along with the Christian virtues of faith, hope and charity.
Core ideas
- Faith and reason both come from God, so they cannot truly contradict each other.
- Knowledge begins with the senses, and the mind draws general understanding from experience.
- Aquinas holds that God's existence can be demonstrated by reasoning from features of the world, such as motion and causation, though not all philosophers accept this.
- Human good is linked to human nature, and the final human happiness is the beatific vision, the direct vision of God's essence in the life to come.
- Moral rules rest on natural law, which reason can grasp, while divine law is revealed guidance, needed because humans have a supernatural end and are morally weak and uncertain.
- Human beings are unified wholes of body and soul, not souls merely housed in bodies.
Key arguments
The Five Ways
In the Summa Theologiae Aquinas gives five short arguments for God's existence, starting from motion, causation, contingency, degrees of goodness and the order of nature. Each reaches its own conclusion, such as a first unmoved mover or a supreme being, and Aquinas then says that this is what people call God.
Essence and existence
We can understand what a phoenix or a human is without knowing whether one exists. Aquinas concludes that existence is something received by creatures, and that only a being whose nature is simply to exist could be the source of all else.
The natural law argument
Because humans have a shared nature, certain things fulfil it and others damage it. Reason can therefore identify basic goods such as life, knowledge and living in society, and form moral principles from them.
Analogical speech about God
If words about God meant exactly what they mean for creatures, God would be reduced to a creature. If they meant something wholly different, they would say nothing. Aquinas says they apply by analogy, with a real but limited likeness.
Philosophers
- Thomas Aquinas 1225–1274Dominican friar and teacher whose writings are the foundation of Thomism.
- Albert the Great c. 1200–1280Aquinas's teacher, a Dominican who wrote extensively on Aristotle and the natural world.
- John Capreolus c. 1380–1444Dominican nicknamed the Prince of Thomists for defending Aquinas's teaching.
- Thomas Cajetan 1469–1534Dominican cardinal who wrote an influential commentary on the Summa Theologiae.
- Jacques Maritain 1882–1973French philosopher who applied Thomist ideas to art, politics and human rights.
- Étienne Gilson 1884–1978French historian of philosophy who stressed the central place of existence in Aquinas.
Main criticisms
Do the arguments for God work?
Hume questioned whether reasoning from experience can establish a cause of the world as a whole, and Kant argued that reason cannot reach beyond possible experience, so that such arguments fail. Thomists reply that Aquinas's arguments ask why anything exists at all, not about a first event in time, though they differ among themselves on how far Kant's objections apply.
Is Aristotle's nature a good basis for ethics?
Critics say that modern science does not support purposes in nature of the Aristotelian kind, so natural law lacks a foundation. Defenders reply that talk of what is good for a kind of living thing remains meaningful, that natural law need not depend on Aristotelian biology, and that some modern philosophers have revived the approach.
Is faith really joined to reason?
Some Christian thinkers, such as Luther and later Barth, worried that the approach gives too much weight to human reason. Thomists reply that Aquinas holds reason to be limited and that key doctrines, such as the Trinity, are known only by revelation.
Is it an accurate reading of Aquinas?
Scholars disagree over what Aquinas himself taught compared with later Thomist schools, and over how far he was influenced by Avicenna, Averroes and Neoplatonism. Thomists respond that the many commentators, while differing, share a recognisable core drawn from his texts.
Sources
- McInerny, Ralph, and John O'Callaghan. "Saint Thomas Aquinas." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of Aquinas's life and philosophy.
- "Thomism." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.Short account of Thomism and its history.
- Davies, Brian. The Thought of Thomas Aquinas. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1992.Clear introduction to Aquinas's main ideas.
- Kenny, Anthony. Aquinas. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1980.Brief overview for beginners, in the Past Masters series.
- Aquinas, Thomas. Summa Theologiae. Translated by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province. London: Burns Oates and Washbourne, 1920–1925.Aquinas's major work, written from about 1265 to 1273.