Philosophy / Islamic and medieval European

Averroism

The Aristotelian philosophy of Ibn Rushd and the Latin thinkers who followed his commentaries

Began
12th century (Ibn Rushd); Latin Averroism, 13th centuryScholars: Historians use "Latin Averroism" for a group of Paris arts masters active from about the 1260s. Whether they formed a coherent school is debated.
Where
Almohad Spain and North Africa (Córdoba, Seville, Marrakesh), then the University of Paris and other Latin universities
Key figures
Ibn Rushd (Averroes) of Córdoba. Averroism is mainly a later label for the reception of his work. Siger of Brabant is a prominent Paris master associated with it.
Key works
Ibn Rushd, The Decisive Treatise (Fasl al-maqal); Ibn Rushd, The Incoherence of the Incoherence (Tahafut al-Tahafut); Ibn Rushd, Long Commentary on Aristotle's De Anima; Ibn Rushd, Long Commentary on Aristotle's Metaphysics; Ibn Rushd, Exposition of Plato's Republic (Commentary on the Republic)

At a glance

Averroism is the name for the ideas of Ibn Rushd, called Averroes in Latin, and for the philosophers who later drew on his work. Ibn Rushd was a judge, doctor and philosopher in Muslim Spain. He wrote detailed commentaries on nearly all of Aristotle's works.

He belongs to falsafa, the tradition of philosophy in Arabic, though his influence there varied across periods and communities. He argued that philosophy and revealed religion do not truly conflict. In his view both lead to truth, in different ways.

His books were translated into Latin in the early 13th century. Scholars in Paris and elsewhere used them to understand Aristotle. Some, called Latin Averroists, took up disputed ideas such as the unity of the intellect. The bishop of Paris condemned lists of propositions in 1270 and 1277. Some of the condemned ideas were linked to Averroist readings, but the 1277 list was much broader.

Key concepts

Commentary
A written study of an Aristotelian text, in which Ibn Rushd explained Aristotle and tried to recover his true meaning, in short, middle or long form.
Unity of the intellect
The view, linked to Ibn Rushd and debated by later readers, that the intellect which grasps universal ideas is one for all humans rather than separate in each person.
Demonstration (burhan)
Strict logical proof from sure premises, which Ibn Rushd thought was the highest way to reach truth.
Falsafa
The Arabic word for philosophy, used for the tradition of thinkers who built on Greek philosophy in the Islamic world.
Double truth
A label, usually from critics, for the claim that something could be true in philosophy and false in religion. Ibn Rushd did not hold it, and whether any Latin Averroist did is debated.
Allegorical interpretation (ta'wil)
For Ibn Rushd, a non-literal reading of a scriptural passage, justified by demonstrative proof and properly carried out only by those trained to do so.

Core ideas

  • Ibn Rushd held that philosophy and revelation both aim at truth, so they cannot truly contradict each other.
  • Ibn Rushd saw Aristotle as the best guide to nature and reasoning, best understood through careful commentary.
  • Ibn Rushd held that where scripture seems to clash with demonstrated proof, the passage may be read figuratively, but only by those qualified to do so.
  • Ibn Rushd taught that people differ in ability, so scripture speaks in rhetoric and images for most people while philosophers may seek proof.
  • Ibn Rushd criticised al-Ghazali's attack on the philosophers and defended the use of causes in nature.
  • Some Latin masters, often called Averroists, drew on his Aristotle commentaries, and some defended the relative independence of philosophy in the arts faculty. They did not all share one set of views.

Key arguments

Three levels of argument

Ibn Rushd said people are persuaded in three ways: by rhetoric, by dialectic and by demonstration. He held that scripture addresses different audiences in different modes, while philosophers pursue demonstration.

Defence of causation

Al-Ghazali denied that there are necessary connections between natural events and stressed that God creates them. Ibn Rushd argued that denying that things act through their natures undermines knowledge, since science explains by those natures.

Philosophy as a duty

In the Decisive Treatise he argued that the Quran urges reflection on the world, so those able to do philosophy are encouraged by religious law to do it.

The intellect

In his Long Commentary on De Anima, Ibn Rushd distinguishes different kinds or functions of intellect. Many readers, ancient and modern, take him to say that the material intellect is single and shared by all humans. This reading is debated. Thomas Aquinas wrote a work against it.

Philosophers

  • Ibn Rushd (Averroes) 1126–1198Judge, physician and philosopher of Córdoba whose commentaries on Aristotle were widely read in Arabic, Hebrew and Latin.
  • Michael Scot c. 1175–c. 1235Scholar who translated several of Ibn Rushd's commentaries into Latin, helping introduce them to Europe.
  • Siger of Brabant c. 1240–c. 1284Paris arts master often named as a Latin Averroist and linked to the 1277 condemnations, though both the label and the attribution of specific condemned views are disputed by historians.
  • Boethius of Dacia 13th centuryParis arts master who argued for the independence of philosophical reasoning within its own field.
  • Thomas Aquinas c. 1225–1274Theologian who used Ibn Rushd's commentaries yet argued against his reading of the intellect.
  • John of Jandun c. 1285–1328Later Paris master who followed Ibn Rushd on Aristotle and carried the tradition into the 14th century.

Main criticisms

Does reason override scripture?

Critics feared that putting philosophical proof above literal readings weakened faith. Al-Ghazali also argued that the philosophers failed to demonstrate some of their key doctrines and that some of those doctrines were unbelief. Ibn Rushd replied that truth cannot contradict truth, and that figurative reading is an accepted tool of interpretation.

Was there a doctrine of double truth?

In 1277 the bishop of Paris condemned propositions that seemed to say something could be true in philosophy and false in faith. Some historians doubt that Averroes or the Paris masters held this, and see a separation of the methods of the disciplines. Others read some masters differently, and the question remains debated.

Is the intellect one for all humans?

Aquinas and others argued that if there is one intellect, individual persons cannot truly think or be morally responsible. Defenders of the Averroist reading said the question was one of interpreting Aristotle, and that the text seemed to require it. How Ibn Rushd himself meant it is still debated.

Did Ibn Rushd answer al-Ghazali fairly?

Al-Ghazali argued that philosophers could not prove certain claims, such as the eternity of the world, and that some of their views were unbelief. Ibn Rushd replied that al-Ghazali misdescribed the philosophers' arguments and that he himself used weaker forms of reasoning. Scholars still discuss how each reconstructed and assessed the philosophers' arguments.

Sources

  1. Adamson, Peter, and Taneli Kukkonen. "Averroes." Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Overview of Ibn Rushd's life and thought.
  2. Encyclopaedia Britannica. "Averroism."Short account of Averroism in the Islamic and Latin worlds.
  3. Leaman, Oliver. Averroes and His Philosophy. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1988.Introduction to Ibn Rushd's thought.
  4. Ibn Rushd. The Decisive Treatise and Epistle Dedicatory. Translated by Charles E. Butterworth. Provo: Brigham Young University Press, 2001.His main work on philosophy and religious law.