Philosophy / Islamic and medieval European
Kalam
A broad tradition of Islamic theology that explains and defends belief through reasoned argument
- Began
- Early debates date to the 7th century; Kalam took shape as a discipline from the 8th centuryScholars: Debates on God, free will and sin began in the 7th century. Most historians see Kalam as a distinct discipline from the 8th and 9th centuries, with the main schools taking shape in the 9th and 10th.
- Where
- Early Islamic world, especially Basra and Baghdad in Iraq, later across the Middle East, Central Asia and North Africa
- Key figures
- No single founder. Early figures include Wasil ibn Ata, Abu al-Hudhayl al-Allaf, Al-Ashari and Al-Maturidi.
- Key works
- The Book of Doctrine (Kitab al-Luma, also known as Proofs for the Fundamentals of Belief) by Al-Ashari; The Book of Monotheism (Kitab al-Tawhid) by Al-Maturidi; The Guide to Conclusive Proofs (Kitab al-Irshad) by Al-Juwayni; Sharh al-Maqasid, a major later theological work by Al-Taftazani; The Incoherence of the Philosophers by Al-Ghazali (a related work that criticises falsafa)
At a glance
Kalam is the Islamic tradition of rational theology. It is not one school but a broad discipline with many schools and thinkers. Its name is Arabic for "speech" or "discourse". Its thinkers use argument to explain what Muslims believe about God, the world and human action, and to defend those beliefs against critics.
Kalam grew out of early disputes among Muslims. They asked whether people are free, whether a major sinner is still a believer, and whether the Quran was created. It also answered challenges from Christians, Zoroastrians and others. Major schools include the Mutazila, the Ashariyya and the Maturidiyya. Other currents, including Traditionalist scholars who distrusted the method, also took part in the debates.
Kalam developed before the mature falsafa tradition, the Islamic philosophy that drew on Greek and other sources. The two overlapped and differed. Kalam thinkers began from the teachings of revelation but used extensive argument. Later Kalam, such as Al-Ghazali's Incoherence of the Philosophers, criticised some falsafa views, and thinkers such as Al-Razi drew the two traditions closer.
Key concepts
- Tawhid
- The oneness of God, the central teaching that Kalam seeks to explain and defend.
- Adl
- Divine justice, a key principle for the Mutazila, who held that God acts justly and humans are responsible for their deeds.
- Kasb
- "Acquisition", a technical Ashari idea that God creates human acts while humans are still held responsible for them, whose exact meaning was debated.
- Jawhar and arad
- Terms for substance (often an atom) and accident (a quality), used in the atomist accounts of the world held by many, but not all, Kalam thinkers.
- Hudūth
- The world's coming into being in time, used in arguments that it needs a creator.
- Sifat
- The attributes of God, such as knowledge, power and speech, and the question of how they relate to his unity.
Core ideas
- God is one, eternal and the creator of everything else.
- Reason can support the claims of revelation and answer objections to them.
- The world is created, and arguments from its beginning point to a creator.
- God has attributes such as knowledge, will and power, and schools differ on how to understand them.
- Humans are morally responsible, though schools differ on how this fits with God's power over all things.
- Prophecy and the Quran give knowledge that reason alone cannot fully supply.
Key arguments
Arguments from the world's beginning
Many Kalam thinkers argued that bodies are always subject to change, and that an endless chain of past events is impossible, so the world began and needs a creator. Versions varied between thinkers. The modern name "kalam cosmological argument" was applied later.
Atomism and renewal
Many Kalam thinkers, including most Mutazila and Ashari theologians, held that bodies consist of tiny indivisible parts, though details differed. Ashari thinkers in particular held that accidents are renewed at each moment, which made God's continuing action central to nature.
Justice and free will
The Mutazila argued that a just God would not punish people for acts he created in them. So humans must create their own acts. Ashari thinkers replied that God's power is unlimited, and used kasb to keep human responsibility.
Reason and revelation
The Mutazila held that reason can know good and evil and basic obligations without scripture. Ashari thinkers held that obligation is known through revelation. Maturidi thinkers also gave reason a real role in knowing good and evil, but differed on obligation and other details.
Philosophers
- Wasil ibn Ata c. 700–748Early figure associated with the founding of the Mutazila in Basra.
- Abu al-Hudhayl al-Allaf c. 750–840Leading Mutazili thinker who developed atomism and systematic argument.
- Al-Ashari c. 874–936Theologian of Basra and Baghdad who left the Mutazila and founded the Ashari school.
- Al-Maturidi c. 853–944Theologian of Samarkand whose work shaped the Maturidi school.
- Al-Ghazali 1058–1111Ashari theologian and jurist who criticised the falsafa thinkers and shaped later Kalam.
- Fakhr al-Din al-Razi c. 1149–1209Ashari scholar who brought Kalam and philosophy closer together in his works.
Main criticisms
Is this method sound for faith?
Many Traditionalists, such as Ahmad ibn Hanbal and many of his followers, rejected Kalam's speculative method and its technical vocabulary, preferring to rely on the Quran and Prophetic reports. Their later views varied, and some accepted reasoning of other kinds. Kalam thinkers replied that argument was needed to answer opponents and to clarify belief.
The philosophers' criticism
Falsafa thinkers criticised aspects of theologians' reasoning. Ibn Sina disagreed with some of their arguments about God and creation, and Ibn Rushd argued that theologians used arguments unsuited to ordinary believers and often not demonstrative. Kalam defenders replied that some philosophical doctrines, such as the eternity of the world, conflicted with revelation and lacked proof.
Does it limit human freedom?
Critics, including Mutazili thinkers, said Ashari ideas such as kasb made human responsibility unclear. Ashari defenders replied that kasb preserves both God's total power and human accountability.
Is atomism necessary?
Critics said that atomism and the arguments built on it rest on contested views of nature. Defenders said the framework gave a clear way to show that the world depends wholly on God.
Sources
- Schmidtke, Sabine, ed. The Oxford Handbook of Islamic Theology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016.Broad scholarly survey of Kalam and its schools.
- Winter, Tim, ed. The Cambridge Companion to Classical Islamic Theology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008.Essays on Mutazili, Ashari and Maturidi thought.
- Watt, W. Montgomery. Islamic Philosophy and Theology: An Extended Survey. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1962.Classic short introduction to early Islamic thought.
- Al-Ghazali. The Incoherence of the Philosophers. Translated by Michael E. Marmura. Provo: Brigham Young University Press, 1997.Al-Ghazali's critique of falsafa.