Philosophy / Early modern European

Rationalism

The view that reason, more than sense experience, is a main source of knowledge

Began
No agreed starting date. The tree marks Descartes's Discourse on the Method, published in 1637.Scholars: 1637 is the publication date of one influential work, not a founding. Rationalist ideas appear much earlier, for example in Plato. Historians use the label "rationalism" for a group of 17th-century thinkers, and the grouping was made later.
Where
Western Europe, mainly France, the Dutch Republic and the German lands
Key figures
No single founder. René Descartes is often named as a starting point, with Spinoza and Leibniz as the other leading figures.
Key works
Discourse on the Method; Meditations on First Philosophy; Ethics; Monadology; Principles of Philosophy

At a glance

Rationalism is a view about how we know things. Its supporters say that reason, meaning careful thinking and proof, can give us knowledge that the senses cannot. Mathematics is a favourite example. In Euclid's geometry, we can prove from its starting assumptions that the angles of a triangle add up to two right angles, without measuring every triangle.

It grew in the 1600s, when new science was overturning old beliefs. Descartes was educated in the medieval schools, known as Scholasticism, and kept some of their concepts. But he criticised their Aristotelian approach and wanted to rebuild knowledge on foundations he could check for himself.

Rationalists disagreed with one another on many points. What they shared was a strong trust in reason as a source of knowledge. Empiricists such as Locke, working partly at the same time, held that knowledge comes from experience and denied innate ideas. Kant later criticised and reshaped both views in his own system.

Key concepts

Reason
The power of the mind to think logically and see what must be true, without relying only on the senses.
Innate ideas
Ideas or knowledge that some rationalists say the mind has from the start, rather than gaining from experience. Descartes treated ideas such as that of God as innate, while Leibniz described innate knowledge more as built-in tendencies.
A priori knowledge
Knowledge justified independently of sense experience, such as a mathematical proof. The word does not mean we learn it before having any experience.
Substance
What exists in its own right. Descartes held that there are two created kinds, mind and body, and also God as an infinite substance. Spinoza argued there is only one substance.
Methodical doubt
Descartes' method of setting aside everything that can be doubted, to see what is left that is certain.
Principle of sufficient reason
Leibniz's idea that everything that is true or that exists has a reason why it is so.

Core ideas

  • Some knowledge comes from reason, not from the senses alone.
  • The senses can mislead us, so many rationalists say they cannot be the only foundation of knowledge.
  • Mathematics is often treated as a model of certain knowledge, and other fields are urged to match its clarity.
  • Many rationalists hold that the mind has innate ideas or built-in ways of understanding, though they differ on what these are.
  • A recurring rationalist commitment is that the world is intelligible, so that reason can understand it, though thinkers differed on how far.
  • Descartes sought to build knowledge step by step from certain first principles. Spinoza and Leibniz used different methods and reached different theories.

Key arguments

The cogito

Descartes doubted everything he could, even the existence of the world. He saw that the act of doubting proved he was thinking, and so that he existed. He put it as "I think, therefore I am."

The dreaming argument

Dreams can feel completely real. So, Descartes argued, we cannot be sure from the senses alone that we are awake. This shows why he looked for a firmer foundation in reason.

The wax example

Descartes noted that a piece of wax changes shape, smell and hardness when melted, yet we still say it is the same wax. He argued that it is the mind, not the senses, that grasps what stays the same.

Leibniz and necessary truths

Leibniz argued that experience shows only what happens, never what must happen. Truths such as those of arithmetic are necessary, so he held they must come from the mind's own structure.

Philosophers

  • René Descartes 1596–1650French thinker who began from methodical doubt and argued that the mind is known more certainly than the body.
  • Baruch Spinoza 1632–1677Dutch philosopher who set out his Ethics in the style of geometry and argued for a single substance.
  • Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz 1646–1716German philosopher and mathematician who developed the idea of monads and the principle of sufficient reason.
  • Nicolas Malebranche 1638–1715French priest and philosopher who developed Descartes' ideas in a religious direction.
  • Christian Wolff 1679–1754German thinker who organised Leibniz's ideas into a system that shaped German universities.

Main criticisms

Is all knowledge from experience?

Empiricists such as Locke said the mind starts blank and there are no innate ideas. Rationalists replied that experience alone cannot explain necessary truths such as those of mathematics, and that the mind must bring something of its own.

The circle problem

Critics said Descartes proved God's existence by clear ideas and then used God to guarantee that clear ideas are reliable, which seems circular. Defenders offer readings in which clear perception is certain while we attend to it, so no circle arises. How to read Descartes here is still disputed among scholars.

How do mind and body interact?

Descartes said mind and matter are different kinds of thing. Critics asked how something non-physical could move a physical body. Rationalists answered in different ways. Spinoza dropped the division, and Leibniz said the two run in harmony without acting on each other.

Can reason reach beyond experience?

Kant argued that pure reason, when used without experience, falls into contradictions about God, the world and the soul. Defenders say reason can still be trusted to grasp basic truths, and some later rationalists accepted limits on its reach.

Sources

  1. Lennon, Thomas M., and Dutton, Blake. "Rationalism vs. Empiricism." In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Overview of the rationalist and empiricist positions.
  2. Descartes, René. Meditations on First Philosophy. Translated by John Cottingham. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996.Descartes' main work, first published in 1641.
  3. Rutherford, Donald, ed. The Cambridge Companion to Early Modern Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.Essays on the period of Descartes, Spinoza and Leibniz.
  4. Scruton, Roger. Spinoza: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002.Short account of one major rationalist.