Philosophy / Early modern European
Empiricism
The view that knowledge comes mainly from experience, not from ideas we are born with
- Began
- Conventionally dated to Locke's Essay Concerning Human Understanding, 1690, for early modern British empiricism. Empiricist ideas are much older.Scholars: Historians treat 1690 as a convenient marker, not a beginning. Precursors include Aristotle, medieval thinkers and Francis Bacon. The group called the 'British empiricists' (Locke, Berkeley, Hume) is a later grouping, and historians debate how well it fits the thinkers' own views.
- Where
- Britain and Ireland, with links to wider European debates
- Key figures
- No single founder. Key early modern figures are John Locke, George Berkeley and David Hume.
- Key works
- An Essay Concerning Human Understanding; A Treatise of Human Nature; An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding; A Treatise Concerning the Principles of Human Knowledge; Novum Organum
At a glance
Empiricism is the view that our knowledge comes mainly from experience. Experience includes what we see, hear, touch, taste and smell. Locke also counted reflection, which means noticing the workings of our own minds. Empiricists say the mind does not begin with ready-made ideas, though they differ on what experience supplies and how much the mind itself contributes.
The best-known early modern empiricists were John Locke, George Berkeley and David Hume. Locke's Essay of 1690 is the usual landmark. Later writers often set them against rationalists such as Descartes and Leibniz, who gave reason a larger role. This contrast is a handy summary, but the two groups were not tidy camps, and Locke was answering many opponents, including defenders of innate principles.
What marks empiricism out is its test for ideas. Where does an idea come from, and what experience supports it? Empiricists use that question to examine claims about the world, the self, God and morals.
Key concepts
- Experience
- What we learn through the senses, and through noticing our own mental states, such as feeling pain or remembering.
- Innate ideas
- Ideas supposedly present in the mind from birth, which empiricists such as Locke denied.
- Tabula rasa
- A Latin phrase for 'blank slate', often used to describe Locke's picture of the mind before experience.
- Impressions and ideas
- Hume's terms: impressions are our vivid present experiences, including sensations and feelings, and ideas are the fainter copies of them that we keep in thought.
- A posteriori
- Knowledge that depends on experience, as opposed to a priori knowledge, which is independent of experience.
- Induction
- Reasoning from past observations to general claims or predictions, such as expecting the sun to rise tomorrow.
Core ideas
- All or most of our ideas come from experience, not from innate ideas.
- Claims about the world must be tested against observation.
- The mind builds complex ideas by combining simpler ones taken from experience.
- Knowledge has limits, and we should not claim more than our evidence supports.
- Careful observation and experiment are the model for reliable inquiry.
Key arguments
Against innate ideas
Locke argued that there are no principles or ideas everyone is born knowing. He pointed out that children and many adults do not seem to hold supposedly universal principles. He did not deny that we are born with mental capacities, such as the ability to reason and to learn.
Hume's fork
Hume divided claims into relations of ideas, such as mathematics, and matters of fact, which depend on experience. A claim that fits neither, he said, deserves suspicion.
The problem of induction
Hume asked what justifies our belief that the future will resemble the past. He argued that this belief rests on habit, not on proof.
To be is to be perceived
Berkeley argued that we know only ideas, and denied that there is any material substance existing apart from minds. For him, ordinary objects are collections of ideas, and their steady existence is secured by God perceiving them.
Philosophers
- John Locke 1632–1704English philosopher whose Essay argued that ideas come from experience.
- George Berkeley 1685–1753Irish bishop and philosopher who pushed empiricism toward idealism.
- David Hume 1711–1776Scottish philosopher who applied the empiricist method to causation, the self and morals.
- Francis Bacon 1561–1626English writer who urged knowledge built from observation and experiment, an important forerunner.
- John Stuart Mill 1806–1873British thinker who defended empiricism even for logic and mathematics.
Main criticisms
Can experience explain everything we know?
Rationalists and Kant argued that some knowledge, such as mathematics, cannot come from experience alone. Kant held that causality is an a priori condition of experience, while rationalists gave differing accounts of mathematics and causes. Empiricists reply that such knowledge is either about the relations of our ideas or is built up from experience, and Mill took the second path.
The problem of induction
Critics note that, by Hume's own argument, empiricism cannot justify science's predictions. Defenders reply that induction is a basic and practical part of reasoning, or that science needs only a sound method, not a final proof.
Does it lead to scepticism?
Some say that if we know only our own experiences, we cannot know that an outside world or a lasting self exists. Empiricists answer in different ways: Locke accepted a reasonable probability, and Hume thought nature leads us to such beliefs anyway.
Is the principle itself empirical?
Critics ask whether the claim that all knowledge comes from experience can itself be shown by experience. Defenders say it is a working principle supported by how inquiry has succeeded, not a dogma.
Sources
- Markie, Peter, and M. Folescu. "Rationalism vs. Empiricism." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of the debate between the two traditions.
- Locke, John. An Essay Concerning Human Understanding. London: Thomas Basset, 1690.A major early modern text and conventional landmark of British empiricism.
- Hume, David. An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding. London: A. Millar, 1748.Hume's short statement of his empiricism.
- Woolhouse, Roger. The Empiricists. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988.Introduction to Locke, Berkeley and Hume.