Philosophy / Early modern European

Utilitarianism

The view that the right action is the one that produces the greatest overall well-being for all affected

Began
Usually dated to 1789, when Jeremy Bentham published An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and LegislationScholars: Utilitarian ideas appear earlier, for example in Francis Hutcheson, David Hume, Cesare Beccaria and Claude-Adrien Helvétius in the 1700s. Bentham's book is usually treated as the first full systematic statement of the school, so 1789 is a conventional landmark, not a sharp beginning.
Where
England, mainly London
Key figures
No single founder. Jeremy Bentham is the principal figure in its modern systematic form, and later thinkers such as John Stuart Mill, Henry Sidgwick and Harriet Taylor Mill developed it.
Key works
An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation; Utilitarianism; The Methods of Ethics; Practical Ethics

At a glance

Utilitarianism is a theory about right and wrong. It says an action is right when it brings about the best results. In its classical form, the best results are those that produce the most well-being, or happiness, and the least suffering, counting everyone affected.

The school took shape in Britain in the late 1700s and 1800s. Jeremy Bentham wanted a clear, practical test for judging laws and customs. He drew on empiricism, which holds that knowledge comes from experience, and on Enlightenment thinkers such as Hume, Beccaria and Helvétius, who linked morality to human feelings and usefulness.

What makes it distinctive is that it judges actions, and ultimately also rules, motives and institutions, by their consequences. Duties and rules can matter as practical tools, but their final justification is the good they do. It also gives everyone's well-being equal consideration. Utilitarians have often used this idea to argue for legal and social reform.

Key concepts

Utility
The good that an action produces, understood in classical utilitarianism as pleasure, happiness or well-being.
Principle of utility
The rule that actions are right in proportion as they promote happiness and wrong as they produce the opposite.
Consequentialism
The family of theories that say the rightness of actions, and of things like rules and motives, depends on the goodness of their consequences.
Hedonic calculus
Bentham's proposed way of weighing pleasures and pains by factors such as intensity, duration and certainty.
Higher and lower pleasures
Mill's idea that pleasures of the mind differ in quality from bodily pleasures, not just in amount.
Act and rule utilitarianism
Act utilitarians judge each action by its results, while rule utilitarians judge actions by whether they follow rules that tend to produce the best results.

Core ideas

  • The right action is the one that produces the greatest overall well-being.
  • In classical utilitarianism, happiness and the absence of suffering are what finally matter. Other versions, such as preference utilitarianism, name different ultimate goods, like the satisfaction of preferences.
  • Each person's well-being deserves equal consideration, and no one's interests count for more simply because of who they are.
  • Laws, institutions and customs should be tested by how they affect people's lives.
  • Many utilitarian views treat moral rules as useful guides, justified by the good they do. Act utilitarians use them only as rules of thumb.
  • Suffering matters wherever it occurs, which has led many utilitarians to include animals.

Key arguments

Bentham on animals

Bentham argued that the question is not whether animals can reason or talk, but whether they can suffer. If they can, their suffering counts.

Mill's proof

Mill argued that the only evidence a thing is desirable is that people desire it. Each person desires their own happiness, so the general happiness is good for the whole group.

Socrates dissatisfied

Mill wrote that it is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied. He meant that higher pleasures are worth more than simple ones.

The trolley case

Act utilitarians often say that diverting a runaway trolley to kill one person instead of five is right, because it saves more lives. Other versions of the theory may weigh rules, rights or side effects differently.

Philosophers

  • Jeremy Bentham 1748–1832English philosopher and legal reformer who set out the principle of utility.
  • John Stuart Mill 1806–1873English philosopher who refined utilitarianism and defended individual liberty.
  • Henry Sidgwick 1838–1900English philosopher who gave utilitarianism a rigorous form in The Methods of Ethics.
  • Harriet Taylor Mill 1807–1858Writer and campaigner for women's rights who worked closely with John Stuart Mill.
  • Peter Singer born 1946Australian philosopher who applied utilitarian reasoning to animals and global poverty.

Main criticisms

Justice and individual rights

Critics say utilitarianism could allow harming an innocent person if that helped many others. Defenders reply that respecting rights usually produces the best results over time, and Mill grounded rights in utility.

Demandingness

Critics say that counting everyone equally asks too much, because it seems to require constant sacrifice for strangers. Some utilitarians accept this, while others say a moral code must allow room for personal life.

Measuring happiness

Critics doubt that pleasures and pains can be measured and compared between people. Defenders reply that we make such rough comparisons in everyday life and in public policy.

Integrity and motives

Critics, such as Bernard Williams, say utilitarianism ignores personal commitments and the moral weight of one's own actions. Defenders reply that good character and close relationships generally promote well-being, so they have a place in the theory.

Sources

  1. Sinnott-Armstrong, Walter. "Consequentialism." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Covers utilitarianism within the wider family of consequentialist theories.
  2. Bentham, Jeremy. An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. London: T. Payne, 1789.A foundational and often-cited early systematic statement of the principle of utility.
  3. Mill, John Stuart. Utilitarianism. London: Parker, Son, and Bourn, 1863.The best-known defence of the theory.
  4. Scarre, Geoffrey. Utilitarianism. London: Routledge, 1995.A clear introduction to the history and arguments.
  5. Driver, Julia. Ethics: The Fundamentals. Oxford: Blackwell, 2006.Introduces utilitarianism alongside other moral theories.