Philosophy / 19th century to today

Analytic philosophy

A way of doing philosophy that stresses clear language, logic and careful argument

Began
c. 1900, with the work of Gottlob Frege, Bertrand Russell and G. E. MooreScholars: Historians often place its roots in Frege's logic of 1879 and the Russell and Moore break with British Idealism of the late 1890s. Some trace it further back, and the question of where it truly begins is debated.
Where
Germany and Britain at first, then Austria through the Vienna Circle and Wittgenstein, and later the English-speaking world, Scandinavia and many other countries
Key figures
No single founder. Key early figures were Gottlob Frege, Bertrand Russell and G. E. Moore, with Ludwig Wittgenstein soon after.
Key works
Frege, Foundations of Arithmetic; Russell and Whitehead, Principia Mathematica; Moore, Principia Ethica; Wittgenstein, Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus; Wittgenstein, Philosophical Investigations

At a glance

Analytic philosophy is a style of philosophy more than a single set of beliefs. Its followers try to state problems clearly, break big questions into smaller parts, and support their views with explicit arguments. Many of them also draw on logic and take the natural sciences seriously.

It took shape around 1900. Frege developed a new, powerful logic. Russell and Moore turned away from the British Idealism then common in Britain, an absolute or organic idealism which held, in various forms, that reality is a unified whole shaped by mind. Russell saw himself as continuing the work of the British empiricists, who held that knowledge comes from experience.

Early analytic philosophers often thought that studying language and logic could clear up old puzzles. This idea is sometimes called the linguistic turn. Later analytic philosophers work on almost every topic, including ethics, mind, politics and metaphysics. The school has several branches, including logical positivism and ordinary language philosophy.

Key concepts

Analysis
The method of breaking a complex idea or statement into simpler parts so that its meaning and logic become clear.
Formal logic
A precise symbolic system for stating arguments and checking whether conclusions follow from premises.
Linguistic turn
The shift in the early twentieth century toward treating many philosophical problems as questions about language and meaning.
Theory of descriptions
Russell's account of how phrases such as "the present King of France" work in a sentence, which he used to show how a sentence can be meaningful without naming anything real.
Common sense
Moore's habit of treating everyday certainties, such as that he has hands, as more secure than philosophical arguments that conflict with them.
Conceptual clarity
The aim of defining terms carefully so that disagreements are real and not just confusion over words.

Core ideas

  • Philosophy should aim at clarity, precision and rigorous argument.
  • Logic is a main tool for testing and sharpening reasoning.
  • Hard problems are best approached by splitting them into smaller questions that can be tackled one at a time.
  • Careful attention to language and meaning can resolve or dissolve many philosophical puzzles.
  • Philosophy should respect the findings of science and the evidence of common experience.
  • There is no fixed creed, and members of the school disagree widely on ethics, religion, mind and reality.

Key arguments

Russell's theory of descriptions

Russell argued that, when said as a plain claim about the world, "The present King of France is bald" says that there is exactly one King of France and that he is bald. On this view the sentence is meaningful and simply false, so no strange non-existent king is needed.

Moore's proof of an external world

Moore held up his hands and said, "Here is one hand." He argued that he was more certain of this than of any premise in a sceptical argument, so the sceptic's conclusion must be rejected.

The open question argument

In Principia Ethica, Moore argued that for any natural property, such as pleasure, we can still sensibly ask whether it is good. He took this to show that goodness cannot be defined as that property.

Wittgenstein's private language argument

In Philosophical Investigations, Wittgenstein is often read as arguing that words need public rules of use, so that a language only one person could ever understand is doubtful. What the argument shows, and even how to read it, is much discussed among scholars.

Branches

  • Logical positivismThe Vienna Circle's view that factual claims must be testable by experience, apart from truths of logic
  • Ordinary language philosophyPhilosophers who looked to everyday speech to dissolve and solve philosophical puzzles

Philosophers

  • Gottlob Frege 1848–1925German logician who created modern formal logic and studied how sense and reference work in language.
  • Bertrand Russell 1872–1970British philosopher and logician who co-wrote Principia Mathematica and developed the theory of descriptions.
  • G. E. Moore 1873–1958British philosopher who defended common sense and wrote Principia Ethica, a key work of modern ethics.
  • Ludwig Wittgenstein 1889–1951Austrian-born philosopher whose early Tractatus was an important influence on the Vienna Circle and whose later work was influential in ordinary language philosophy, though his ties to each are debated.
  • W. V. O. Quine 1908–2000American philosopher and logician who criticised the sharp split between truths of meaning and truths of fact.
  • Elizabeth Anscombe 1919–2001British philosopher who wrote influentially on action, intention and ethics.

Main criticisms

Too narrow and too technical

Some critics, including various writers outside the analytic tradition, say it can focus on small puzzles and neglect history, culture and the meaning of life. Defenders reply that careful work on small problems builds real progress, and that analytic philosophers do write on history and on ethical and political questions.

Can analysis settle philosophical problems?

Quine and others argued that there is no clean line between truths of meaning and truths of fact, which weakened the hope that analysis alone could resolve philosophical questions. Some defenders responded by developing naturalism, which treats philosophy as continuous with science, while others kept a role for conceptual analysis.

Is it really a single school?

Some historians say the term "analytic" covers such varied people and methods that it names a loose family, or a style, rather than a unified movement. Defenders reply that shared habits of argument, clarity and attention to logic still make the label useful, even if it has blurry edges.

Sources

  1. Beaney, Michael. "Analysis." In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.On the history and methods of analysis in philosophy.
  2. Glock, Hans-Johann. What Is Analytic Philosophy? Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008.A study of how to define the tradition and its history.
  3. Russell, Bertrand. The Problems of Philosophy. London: Williams and Norgate, 1912.First published in 1912; library records list later editions under other dates. A short primary text showing the early analytic approach.
  4. Moore, G. E. Principia Ethica. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1903.Primary text containing the open question argument.