Philosophy / Early modern European

German idealism

A movement of post-Kantian thinkers, from Fichte to Hegel, centred on mind, knowledge and freedom

Began
1790sScholars: Usually dated from the 1780s and 1790s, after Kant's Critique of Pure Reason (1781), to Hegel's death in 1831 or Schelling's late lectures in the 1840s
Where
German-speaking Europe, especially the university towns of Jena, Berlin and Tübingen
Key figures
No single founder. Key figures were Johann Gottlieb Fichte, Friedrich Schelling and Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, who each transformed the philosophy of Immanuel Kant
Key works
Science of Knowledge (Fichte); System of Transcendental Idealism (Schelling); Phenomenology of Spirit (Hegel); Science of Logic (Hegel); Elements of the Philosophy of Right (Hegel)

At a glance

German idealism was a movement in philosophy that flourished in Germany from the 1790s to the 1830s. It was not one fixed school. Its main thinkers disagreed sharply, but many shared an interest in how mind, knowledge, freedom and reality fit together.

It began as a critical reply to Immanuel Kant. Kant had argued that we know things only as they appear to us, not as they are in themselves. Fichte, Schelling and Hegel asked whether that split could be overcome, and each offered a different and bolder system.

What marked the movement was its ambition. These thinkers tried to explain knowledge, nature, history, art, law and religion in a systematic way. Hegel in particular presented history as a process in which reason comes to understand itself, though others in the movement did not all agree. The original movement faded as a leading force after Hegel died in 1831, and the tree ends it around 1840. Idealist ideas have kept being studied and reworked since, including in later idealist movements.

Key concepts

Idealism
The view that mind, thought or reason is basic to reality, or that what we know depends on the activity of mind; the German idealists understood this in different ways.
The I (das Ich)
Fichte's name for the free, self-aware activity that he took to be the starting point of philosophy.
The Absolute
The whole of reality seen as one unity, which Schelling and Hegel each tried to describe in their own way.
Dialectic
In Hegel, a way of reasoning in which a concept's own tensions and limits push thought to a fuller concept; the formula of thesis, antithesis and synthesis is a later simplification and is not Hegel's own.
Spirit (Geist)
Hegel's term for mind as it appears in shared human life, culture and history.
Freedom
Self-rule by reason, which Kant and the idealists after him treated as central to human life and society.

Core ideas

  • Many of the idealists held that knowledge is not a passive copy of the world, because the mind plays an active part in shaping what it knows.
  • Most of them aimed at a connected system of philosophy, rather than a set of separate questions.
  • Freedom, understood as self-determination by reason, was a central value.
  • Schelling and Hegel, in different ways, sought to understand divisions such as subject and object, or mind and nature, within a larger unity.
  • Hegel read history as intelligible, as a growth of freedom and self-understanding.
  • Hegel held that art, religion and philosophy are different ways in which spirit comes to know itself.

Key arguments

Fichte's starting point

Fichte began from the self-positing I, a free activity that is aware of itself in acting. From it he tried to work out the conditions that make experience and moral action possible.

Schelling's identity of nature and mind

In his early work Schelling held that nature and mind are two expressions of one underlying reality. Nature is mind in an unconscious form, and mind is nature becoming aware of itself. His views changed considerably later.

Hegel's dialectic

In the Phenomenology of Spirit, Hegel traced forms of consciousness that each reveal a limit and so give way to a richer form. The path ends in absolute knowing, where spirit understands its own development.

Recognition

Hegel argued that self-consciousness depends on being recognised by another self. In the master and bondsman episode, the relation fails to give mutual recognition, but the bondsman's work leads to a fuller self-consciousness later on.

Philosophers

  • Immanuel Kant 1724–1804Königsberg philosopher whose critical philosophy was the starting point for the idealists.
  • Johann Gottlieb Fichte 1762–1814Developed the Science of Knowledge, which grounded philosophy in the free activity of the self.
  • Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schelling 1775–1854Developed a philosophy of nature and of identity, and later turned to freedom, myth and revelation.
  • Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel 1770–1831Built the most comprehensive system of the movement, covering logic, nature, history, law, art and religion.
  • Friedrich Hölderlin 1770–1843Poet and thinker who took part in early debates about unity and self-consciousness.

Main criticisms

Is the system too grand?

Critics, including Kierkegaard, said that a complete system cannot capture individual existence and choice. Defenders reply that Hegel meant to include the individual and the historical within his account, not to erase them.

Does it overreach beyond Kant's limits?

Kant held that reason cannot know things as they are in themselves. Critics said the idealists ignored this limit. They answered that the limit itself was an unstable notion, and that thought can grasp reality because the two are not wholly separate.

Is it too focused on ideas to explain the real world?

Marx criticised Hegel for treating ideas as the driver of history when material and economic life matter more. He transformed Hegel's dialectic in a materialist direction while keeping some of its methods. Hegelians reply that Hegel gave great weight to institutions, work and history.

Was it rejected by analytic philosophy?

Russell and Moore broke mainly with British Idealism, a later movement influenced by Hegel, so the link to German idealism is indirect. They argued against its claims about the unreality of separate things and against its view of relations. Defenders of idealism reply that these targets simplify the originals, and later scholars have restated German idealist arguments in plainer terms.

Sources

  1. Gardner, Sebastian, and Matthew Grist. "German Idealism." In Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward Craig, 1998.Overview of the movement and its main figures.
  2. "Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel." In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Detailed entry on Hegel's life and thought.
  3. Beiser, Frederick C. German Idealism: The Struggle against Subjectivism, 1781–1801. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2002.Scholarly history of the early phase of the movement.
  4. Pinkard, Terry. German Philosophy 1760–1860: The Legacy of Idealism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002.Survey from Kant to the later idealists.
  5. Hegel, G. W. F. Phenomenology of Spirit. Translated by A. V. Miller. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1977.Hegel's major early work, first published in 1807.