Philosophy / 19th century to today

Marxism

A philosophy of history and society built on material life, class and the aim of changing the world

Began
Took shape in the 1840s
Where
Western Europe, mainly Germany, France and England
Key figures
Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels
Key works
The Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844; The German Ideology; The Communist Manifesto; Capital; Theses on Feuerbach

At a glance

Marxism is a school of philosophy that tries to explain history and society by looking closely at how people produce what they need to live. It holds that the way a society organises work, land, tools and wealth plays a central part in shaping its laws, politics and ideas. It also treats human beings and their abilities as formed by history and society, not fixed in advance.

Its ideas took shape in the 1840s in the work of the German thinkers Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. They drew on German idealism, especially Hegel's idea that history develops through conflict and change, and Marx's relationship to Hegel was one of both debt and criticism. They were also shaped by the materialism of Ludwig Feuerbach, by French socialist thinkers and by British political economy. The name Marxism came into use later, as followers built an organised tradition.

Marxism is distinctive because it joins explanation and action. Marx wrote that philosophers had only interpreted the world, and the point was to change it. Marxism also has a page in the politics section, and this page focuses on its philosophical ideas.

Key concepts

Historical materialism
The approach that gives production and the social relations around it a central place in explaining history, though Marxists disagree about how directly they determine politics and ideas.
Dialectic
A way of understanding change as driven by tensions and contradictions that are worked out in new forms.
Mode of production
The combination of tools, skills and resources with the social relations, such as master and servant or employer and wage worker, under which a society produces goods.
Class
A group defined by its relation to the means of production, for example those who own factories and land and those who must work for wages.
Alienation
The social condition under wage labour in which workers do not control their work or its products, which separates them from their own activity and from other people, and which may also be felt as a sense of estrangement.
Ideology
In many Marxist accounts, a set of ideas that presents the interests of a ruling group as natural or universal, though Marxist writers use the word in varying ways.

Core ideas

  • Material life is basic: how people produce and reproduce their lives strongly shapes their ideas, while ideas and political action can also act back on material conditions.
  • Marx traced how different modes of production arise and change, though later Marxists dispute whether history follows one fixed sequence of stages.
  • Conflict between classes is a central force of historical change in societies divided by ownership.
  • Under capitalism, workers sell their labour and may experience alienation from their work and its products.
  • Dominant ideas in a society tend to reflect the interests of its ruling class.
  • Theory and practice belong together, so understanding society is linked to the aim of changing it.

Key arguments

Base and superstructure

Marx once pictured society as having an economic base of production and a superstructure of law, politics, religion and culture rising above it. This image became the standard summary of his view, but it is a metaphor, and Marxists disagree about how strongly the base shapes the rest and whether influence runs both ways.

The critique of idealism

In The German Ideology, Marx and Engels criticised thinkers, especially the Young Hegelians, who treated changing ideas as the way to change the world. They argued that ideas arise from real people living in definite conditions. Consciousness is bound up with life, and people in turn change their conditions through activity.

Alienated labour

In the 1844 Manuscripts, Marx argued that under wage labour the product belongs to someone else and work becomes a means of survival rather than self-expression. For Marx, free creative work is central to being human. Alienation is the loss of that.

The Theses on Feuerbach

Marx criticised older materialism for treating people as passive products of circumstances. He argued that people also change circumstances through practical, sensuous activity. Later Marxists developed this theme into the concept of praxis.

Philosophers

  • Karl Marx 1818–1883German philosopher and economist who developed historical materialism and the critique of capitalism.
  • Friedrich Engels 1820–1895Marx's lifelong collaborator, who helped shape and spread the system of ideas later called Marxism.
  • Georg Lukács 1885–1971Hungarian philosopher whose History and Class Consciousness helped begin Western Marxism.
  • Antonio Gramsci 1891–1937Italian thinker who developed the idea of hegemony, the way ruling groups hold power through a mix of consent, leadership, institutions and force.
  • Louis Althusser 1918–1990French philosopher who offered a structuralist reading of Marx and reworked the theory of ideology.

Main criticisms

Is it economically deterministic?

Critics say that treating the economy as the base of society reduces politics, culture and individual choice to by-products. Many Marxists, including Engels in later letters, replied that the economy is decisive only in the long run and that other factors interact with it.

Can its claims be tested?

Critics such as Karl Popper argued that Marxist theories of history were too flexible to be disproved, or that predictions such as the fall of capitalism had not come true. Defenders reply that Marxism offers a method of analysis rather than a fixed timetable, and that many of its claims about economic crises and inequality can be examined.

Does it neglect the individual and morality?

Some critics say that focusing on classes leaves little room for personal responsibility or universal moral rights. Defenders point to Marx's concern with human freedom and flourishing, though scholars debate whether Marx held a moral theory at all.

The link to twentieth-century states

Critics argue that regimes claiming to be Marxist, such as the Soviet Union under Stalin and China under Mao, produced mass repression and famines that are well documented. Defenders and many Marxists reply that these states departed from Marx's ideas or were shaped by particular conditions, while others in the tradition debate how far the ideas contributed.

Sources

  1. Wolff, Jonathan. "Karl Marx." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of Marx's philosophy, including alienation and historical materialism.
  2. Singer, Peter. Marx: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1980.Short introduction to Marx's thought, first published in 1980.
  3. Kolakowski, Leszek. Main Currents of Marxism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1978.Large history of Marxist thought, written by a critic.
  4. Marx, Karl, and Friedrich Engels. The Communist Manifesto. 1848. Various translations.Short statement of the materialist view of history and class conflict.