Philosophy / 19th century to today
Critical theory
A tradition that studies society in order to expose domination and help bring about freedom
- Began
- 1930s, with the Institute for Social Research in Frankfurt, GermanyScholars: The Institute was founded in 1923, and the term "critical theory" was set out in Max Horkheimer's 1937 essay "Traditional and Critical Theory". Some later writers use the term more broadly for any theory that aims to criticise and change society.
- Where
- Frankfurt, Germany. After 1933 the Institute moved to Geneva and then to New York, while its members followed different paths of exile, some to the United States (New York and California). The Institute was re-established in Frankfurt in 1951.
- Key figures
- The Institute was set up with the support of Felix Weil, and Carl Grünberg was its first director. Max Horkheimer became director in 1930 and set out the programme of critical theory. Theodor Adorno, Herbert Marcuse and Erich Fromm joined at different times. Walter Benjamin was associated with the Institute but was not a founder or regular member.
- Key works
- Traditional and Critical Theory; Dialectic of Enlightenment; One-Dimensional Man; Negative Dialectics; The Theory of Communicative Action
At a glance
Critical theory is a way of studying society that aims to do more than describe it. Its supporters say a good theory should reveal how power and inequality work, so that people can free themselves from them. It is called "critical" because it questions the society it studies. Its thinkers differ a great deal about what freedom and domination mean and about what counts as critique.
It began with a group of thinkers at the Institute for Social Research in Frankfurt, later called the Frankfurt School. They drew on Karl Marx, and many of them were disappointed that the revolutions hoped for after the First World War had failed or turned out badly. They asked why many people accepted systems that harmed them, and how fascism and Nazism came to power in Germany. Members of the group gave different answers to these questions.
To answer, they combined economics with philosophy, sociology, psychology and the study of culture. Later thinkers, such as Jürgen Habermas, changed the approach. The term is now also used more widely for work in many fields that studies power, such as in relation to class, gender or race.
Key concepts
- Critique
- Careful questioning of society and its ideas, to show their hidden assumptions and limits.
- Ideology
- A set of ideas that makes an unequal social order seem natural or fair.
- Emancipation
- Freedom from domination, which critical theory sees as the goal of its work.
- Culture industry
- Adorno and Horkheimer's name for mass-produced entertainment, which they described as standardised, with a false show of individuality; they argued this weakens independent thought.
- Instrumental reason
- Thinking that only asks which means best reach a given goal, and does not ask whether the goal is worthwhile.
- Communicative action
- Habermas's term for action aimed at reaching shared understanding through language; his ideal is communication free from pressure and distortion.
Core ideas
- Theory is shaped by the society in which thinkers live, so critical theorists reject the claim that social inquiry can be wholly free of values.
- A good theory should aim to reduce domination and suffering.
- Social problems must be studied by joining many fields, including economics, psychology, philosophy and culture.
- Ideas and culture can keep unfair arrangements in place by making them seem natural.
- When reason and knowledge are reduced to technical control, they can produce new forms of unfreedom.
- Society should be judged by whether it allows people real freedom, and not only by its wealth or order.
Key arguments
Traditional versus critical theory
Horkheimer argued that traditional theory treats society as an object to be described from outside. Critical theory instead sees itself as part of society and aims to change it for the better.
The dialectic of enlightenment
Adorno and Horkheimer argued, writing during the Second World War, that the effort to master nature through reason can turn into the mastery of people. In their view, the hope of freeing humans by knowledge carries a risk of new domination.
The culture industry
They claimed that films, radio and popular music are made like factory goods. In their view this gives people comfort and distraction while weakening independent thought.
Communicative reason
Habermas argued that everyday speech carries claims that can be questioned: that what we say is true, that it is right, and that we mean it sincerely. Critique can therefore rest on the ideal of open discussion where the better argument wins. He later developed from this a separate theory of ethics, called discourse ethics.
Philosophers
- Max Horkheimer 1895–1973Director of the Institute for Social Research from 1930 who set out the programme of critical theory in 1937.
- Theodor W. Adorno 1903–1969Philosopher, sociologist and music critic known for his work on mass culture and negative dialectics.
- Herbert Marcuse 1898–1979Philosopher who criticised modern consumer society and was widely read by student movements in the 1960s.
- Walter Benjamin 1892–1940Critic associated with the Institute who wrote on art, history and technology.
- Erich Fromm 1900–1980Psychoanalyst who helped bring psychology into the Frankfurt School's studies of authority.
- Jürgen Habermas born 1929Leading thinker of the second generation who developed a theory based on communication and public debate.
Main criticisms
Is it too pessimistic?
Critics say the early Frankfurt School saw mass society as so controlling that it left little room for resistance or for real pleasure in popular culture. Defenders reply that it was written in response to fascism and war, and that later thinkers such as Habermas found more hope in democratic debate.
Can it justify its own standards?
Some philosophers ask how critical theory can call a society unfree without a neutral standard of what freedom is. Defenders reply that its standards come from within society, from ideals such as freedom and equality that societies already claim to hold.
Is it too abstract and elitist?
Critics, including some empirical social scientists, say its writing is hard to follow and its claims are hard to test. Defenders say that difficult ideas are needed to challenge common assumptions, and that many later studies in the tradition have used empirical research.
Is it still Marxist enough?
Some Marxists argued the school turned away from working-class politics toward culture and theory. Defenders reply that the failed revolutions and the rise of fascism made it necessary to rethink Marx rather than repeat him.
Sources
- Celikates, Robin, and Jeffrey Flynn. "Critical Theory (Frankfurt School)." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of the history and ideas of critical theory.
- Jeffries, Stuart. Grand Hotel Abyss: The Lives of the Frankfurt School. London: Verso, 2016.A group biography of the Frankfurt School thinkers.
- Jay, Martin. The Dialectical Imagination: A History of the Frankfurt School and the Institute of Social Research, 1923–1950. Boston: Little, Brown, 1973.A classic history of the Institute and its members.
- Horkheimer, Max, and Theodor W. Adorno. Dialectic of Enlightenment. Translated by Edmund Jephcott. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2002.A founding text of the Frankfurt School, first published in 1944.