Politics / Socialist

Marxism

A theory of history and class struggle that aims at a classless society

Began
1848 (conventional date, from the publication of The Communist Manifesto; Marxism as a named movement came later)Scholars: Marx and Engels's ideas took shape in the early 1840s; Marxism as a named, organised movement grew mainly after Marx's death in 1883
Where
Western Europe. Marx and Engels worked in Germany, France, Belgium and Britain; organised Marxist parties later emerged across Europe
Key figures
Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels
Key works
The Communist Manifesto; Capital; The German Ideology; Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844; Critique of the Gotha Programme

At a glance

Marxism is a body of ideas about society, history and economics. It was developed by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels in the mid-1800s. It holds that history is shaped mainly by conflict between social classes over who owns and controls the means of production, such as land, factories and machines.

The Communist Manifesto of 1848 gave the ideas their best-known form. Marx and Engels wrote in the era of industrial growth in Europe. They argued that under capitalism a small class of owners, the bourgeoisie, lives from the work of a much larger class of wage earners, the proletariat.

Marxists expect the working class to overthrow capitalism and build a society without classes, where the means of production are held in common. In theory the state, which Marxists see as a tool of the ruling class, would then wither away. Many movements have claimed the name, and they disagree sharply about what it requires.

Key concepts

Class struggle
The conflict between social classes with opposed economic interests, which Marxists see as the driving force of history.
Means of production
The land, tools, factories and resources used to make goods, whose ownership shapes the whole of society.
Historical materialism
The approach that studies how a society's productive forces and social relations of production interact with its institutions, laws and ideas, and how that relationship changes over time.
Surplus value
The value workers create beyond what is needed to pay their wages, which Marx argued capitalists appropriate and which is then divided as profit, interest and rent.
Alienation
Marx's term for the separation of workers from the products of their labour, from the work process, from other people and from their own human potential.
Dictatorship of the proletariat
Marx's term for a transitional period in which the working class holds political power before classes disappear.

Core positions

  • History is driven by struggles between classes over the control of production.
  • Capitalism, like earlier systems, creates tensions that will eventually lead to its replacement.
  • Under capitalism, owners profit from the labour of wage workers, which Marxists call exploitation.
  • The state in a class society mainly serves the interests of the ruling class.
  • The working class should organise to take power and bring the means of production under common ownership.
  • The final aim is a classless society in which the state is no longer needed.

Policies and positions

Economy

Marxists call for common or social ownership of major industry and for production meant to meet human needs rather than to make private profit. Marx gave no detailed blueprint, and Marxists disagree about the institutions this would need, including how far to use central planning.

The state

Marx saw the state as an instrument of class rule. He expected a transitional workers' state and then its gradual disappearance. In the twentieth century, states ruled in his name grew very powerful instead.

Internationalism

The Manifesto ends with the call 'Workers of all countries, unite!' Marxism is internationalist in outlook, but Marxists have disagreed widely about nationalism, national liberation and the political role of nations.

Religion and ideas

Marx argued that ideas, including religion, are bound up with the material conditions of a society. Many later Marxist states were officially atheist and restricted religious life.

Branches

  • Marxism–LeninismThe ideology of Soviet-style communism, built on Marx's ideas and Lenin's party

Thinkers and leaders

  • Karl Marx 1818–1883German philosopher and economist who wrote Capital and co-wrote the Communist Manifesto.
  • Friedrich Engels 1820–1895Marx's lifelong collaborator, who funded his work, edited later volumes of Capital and spread the ideas.
  • Rosa Luxemburg 1871–1919Polish-born German revolutionary who stressed mass action and democracy within socialism.
  • Vladimir Lenin 1870–1924Russian revolutionary who developed Marxist theory and practice and led the Bolshevik seizure of power in 1917; his ideas were later incorporated into Marxism–Leninism.
  • Antonio Gramsci 1891–1937Italian Marxist who wrote about cultural hegemony, the way ruling classes shape common beliefs.

Main criticisms

Predictions that did not come true

Critics argue that capitalism adapted, that workers' living standards rose, and that revolutions came in largely agrarian countries rather than industrial ones. Defenders reply that Marx described tendencies rather than fixed timetables, and that later Marxists revised the theory to explain these changes.

The record of Marxist states

Regimes ruled by Marxist parties in the twentieth century left a documented record of repression and mass death. Under Stalin the Soviet Union saw purges, forced labour camps and famine, and China's Great Leap Forward was followed by a famine that killed tens of millions by most estimates. Some critics argue that this concentration of power followed from Marxist ideas about the party and the state. Defenders reply that these regimes departed from Marx's stress on human freedom, and that the conditions of their revolutions shaped what followed.

Is the labour theory of value sound?

Many economists reject Marx's labour theory of value, which ties the value of goods to the socially necessary labour needed to produce them, and point to prices set by supply and demand. Defenders say that Marx distinguished value from market price, and that his account of exploitation does not depend on a simple price theory.

Reform or revolution

Social democrats, who grew out of Marxist movements, argue that working people can gain power and security through elections and reform. Revolutionary Marxists reply that the ruling class will block deep change, so a break with the existing order is needed.

Sources

  1. Wolff, Jonathan. "Karl Marx." In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of Marx's thought and its political side.
  2. Marx, Karl, and Friedrich Engels. The Communist Manifesto. London: 1848.A foundational political text of the Marxist tradition.
  3. Kołakowski, Leszek. Main Currents of Marxism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1978.A major history of Marxist thought, critical in outlook.
  4. Singer, Peter. Marx: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1980.A short, clear introduction to Marx's ideas.