Politics / Socialist

Marxism–Leninism

The ideology of Soviet-style communism, built on Marx's ideas and Lenin's party

Began
1917 (the Bolshevik seizure of power, from which the Leninist model dates). The name "Marxism–Leninism" itself came later, in the 1920s and 1930s.Scholars: Historians generally place the coining and spread of the label "Marxism–Leninism" in the later 1920s, after Lenin's death in 1924, and its formal codification as official Soviet doctrine in the 1930s under Stalin. The exact dating is debated.
Where
Russia, later the Soviet Union and many other countries
Key figures
Vladimir Lenin built on the work of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. Joseph Stalin shaped it into a fixed official doctrine.
Key works
The Communist Manifesto; What Is to Be Done?; Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism; The State and Revolution; Foundations of Leninism

At a glance

Marxism–Leninism is a political ideology based on the ideas of Karl Marx, as developed by Vladimir Lenin. It holds that capitalism divides society into classes with opposed interests, and that workers should overthrow it and build socialism, and in time a classless society called communism. Its supporters see it as a scientific way to understand history and change it.

It took shape around the Russian Revolution of 1917, when the Bolshevik party under Lenin took power. After Lenin died in 1924, the name came into use for the official teaching of the Soviet Union. Later, ruling parties in Eastern Europe, China, Cuba, Vietnam and elsewhere declared themselves Marxist–Leninist, as did communist parties around the world. Their versions differed, and some later changed or dropped the label. North Korea, for example, officially put its own doctrine of Juche first.

Its distinctive features, in the Soviet-derived model, are the vanguard party and the one-party state. A small, disciplined party claims to lead the working class, and it directs a planned economy in which the state owns the main industries. States that followed the doctrine varied a good deal in how they did this, and some, such as China and Vietnam, later introduced market reforms. Trotskyism and Maoism both began as challenges to, or variations on, this model.

Key concepts

Vanguard party
A disciplined party of committed members that claims to lead the working class and guide it toward revolution.
Dictatorship of the proletariat
Marx's phrase for a transitional period of rule in the name of the working class, which Leninists understood as rule by the party-led state.
Democratic centralism
A party principle under which members elect leaders and debate policy, then act together once a decision is made, though in practice power usually flowed from the top down.
Planned economy
An economy in which the state sets production goals and directs resources; in the Soviet-type model this went with state ownership of the main industries, though other states mixed in markets or private activity.
Imperialism
In Lenin's account, the stage of capitalism in which big firms and powerful states divide up the world, creating rivalry and war.
Historical materialism
The Marxist theory that history changes as society's productive forces and relations of production develop, with class conflict and shifting social institutions seen as central to that change.

Core positions

  • History is shaped by class struggle, and capitalism will be replaced by socialism.
  • A revolution led by a disciplined vanguard party is needed, because workers alone are thought likely to settle for modest reforms.
  • After the revolution, the party-led state holds power to defend the revolution and build socialism.
  • In the characteristic Soviet-style model, the state owns the main means of production and the economy is run by central plans, though states applied this differently.
  • Religion, private capital and rival parties are seen as supports of the old class order, and were restricted in many states ruled this way.
  • Socialism is meant to be a stage on the way to communism, a society without classes or a state.

Policies and positions

Economy

In the Soviet model, industry was nationalised and farmland was collectivised, meaning that peasants were pulled into large state or collective farms. Five-year plans set targets for heavy industry and other sectors. Land policy and ownership differed between countries and changed over time.

The state and politics

In the Soviet model one party held a legal monopoly of power, and its leadership controlled the government, army, press and courts. Some states, such as East Germany and China, kept allied or satellite parties, but in practice these did not challenge the ruling party. Elections generally offered no real choice of government.

Rights

Advocates stressed social and economic rights, such as work, education and health care. Individual political freedoms were subordinated to the party's view of the interests of the working class.

Foreign affairs

Marxist–Leninist states backed what they called anti-imperialist and revolutionary movements. During the Cold War the Soviet Union led a bloc of allied states opposed to the United States and its allies.

Branches

  • TrotskyismRevolutionary Marxism built on permanent, worldwide revolution and opposition to Stalin's bureaucracy
  • MaoismA Chinese form of Marxism–Leninism built on peasant revolution and mass mobilisation led by the party

Thinkers and leaders

  • Karl Marx 1818–1883German thinker whose analysis of capitalism and class is the foundation of the tradition.
  • Friedrich Engels 1820–1895Marx's collaborator, who co-wrote The Communist Manifesto and helped spread Marxist ideas.
  • Vladimir Lenin 1870–1924Leader of the Bolsheviks and first head of the Soviet government, who developed the theory of the vanguard party.
  • Joseph Stalin 1878–1953Soviet leader who made Marxism–Leninism the fixed state doctrine and ruled through a centralised, repressive system.
  • Leon Trotsky 1879–1940Revolutionary leader who opposed Stalin and whose ideas gave rise to Trotskyism.
  • Mao Zedong 1893–1976Chinese communist leader who adapted the doctrine to a peasant society, giving rise to Maoism.

Main criticisms

Concentrated power and political repression

Critics argue that a one-party state without independent courts, a free press or competing parties led to mass repression, including in peacetime. Documented cases include the Soviet Great Terror of 1937 to 1938, the Gulag camp system, and imprisonments and killings in other states. Defenders say some of this was distortion, such as Stalin's personality cult, which Khrushchev denounced in 1956, and that emergency measures during civil war and invasion explain part of the early violence. Critics reply that such explanations cannot account for the large-scale, state-directed repression carried out in peacetime, and some hold that the system itself made it possible.

Famine and forced economic change

Historians document that forced collectivisation, grain requisitioning and unrealistic central targets were followed by severe famines, including the Soviet famine of 1932 to 1933, which killed millions in Ukraine, Kazakhstan and elsewhere, and China's Great Leap Forward famine of about 1959 to 1961. Estimates of deaths vary and are debated, and policy and administrative decisions are central to most accounts. Defenders point to rapid industrialisation, rising literacy and wider access to health care and education. Some also argue that poor harvests and external pressures contributed, though historians debate how much.

Planning versus markets

Critics, including many economists, argue that central planning lacks the price signals needed to allocate resources well, leading to shortages and waste. Defenders reply that planning can direct resources to national goals and avoid unemployment and boom-and-bust cycles. They add that Soviet-type economies grew quickly for some decades and were under pressure from war and hostile powers.

Does the vanguard betray the goal?

Other socialists, including democratic socialists and anarchists, argue that rule by a party elite cannot lead to a stateless, free society and tends to make a new ruling class. Marxist–Leninists answer that a revolution must defend itself against its enemies and that the state would wither away once classes disappeared. Trotsky and many later Trotskyists agree with part of the criticism, holding that the Soviet state degenerated into a bureaucratic caste, though Trotskyist groups differ in their terms and interpretations.

Sources

  1. Encyclopaedia Britannica. "Marxism-Leninism." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.Short overview of the doctrine and its history.
  2. Service, Robert. Lenin: A Biography. London: Macmillan, 2000.Detailed life of Lenin and the early Bolshevik state.
  3. Kolakowski, Leszek. Main Currents of Marxism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1978.Critical history of Marxist thought, including Leninism and Stalinism.
  4. Lenin, V. I. What Is to Be Done? Burning Questions of Our Movement. 1902. Many English editions.
  5. Fitzpatrick, Sheila. The Russian Revolution. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1982.Concise account of 1917 and its aftermath.