Politics / Conservative
Neoconservatism
A US movement known for an active, values-driven foreign policy and support for markets at home
- Began
- 1960sScholars: Debated. Some scholars trace its roots to the anti-Stalinist left of the 1930s and 1940s in New York. Others date the movement itself to the 1960s and 1970s, including the circle around the journal The Public Interest, founded in 1965. The label came into wide use in the 1970s.
- Where
- United States, especially New York and Washington, D.C.
- Key figures
- No single founder. Early figures include Irving Kristol, Norman Podhoretz, Nathan Glazer and Daniel Patrick Moynihan.
- Key works
- The Public Interest (journal, 1965 onward); Commentary (magazine); Neoconservatism: The Autobiography of an Idea by Irving Kristol; Breaking Ranks by Norman Podhoretz; The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism by Daniel Bell (an associated work; Bell himself rejected the neoconservative label)
At a glance
Neoconservatism is a school of American political thought. It is best known for its foreign policy, which holds that the United States should actively defend its allies and promote free institutions abroad. At home, neoconservatives have generally favoured markets, while often accepting a mixed economy and a substantial welfare state.
It emerged in the 1960s and 1970s. Many early figures were intellectuals who had begun on the left, some as anti-Stalinist socialists or liberals. Explanations given for their shift include disillusion with some Great Society programs, hostility to the counterculture, and concern about policy towards the Soviet Union. These fit some figures more than others. Irving Kristol joked that a neoconservative was a liberal who had been 'mugged by reality'.
What sets it apart from other conservatism is its focus on foreign policy and its willingness to use state power. The term is also used by critics, and some people described with it have rejected the name.
Key concepts
- Unintended consequences
- The idea that well-meant government programs often produce results their designers did not expect or want.
- Anti-communism
- Opposition to Marxism–Leninism and to the Soviet Union, a founding concern of the movement.
- Democratic realism
- A phrase the columnist Charles Krauthammer used for a foreign policy that supports democracy where it is strategically vital, one of several competing neoconservative positions.
- Moral clarity
- The belief that leaders should openly distinguish between free and unfree regimes rather than treat all states as morally alike.
- Regime character
- The view, common among neoconservative writers, that how a state is governed at home shapes how it behaves abroad.
- Realism
- A rival school that says states should pursue national interest and balance power; many neoconservatives argue against it.
Core positions
- Market economies are generally favoured, though views on taxes, regulation and the welfare state have varied, and many accept a limited safety net.
- Social policy should be judged by its actual results, and ambitious government schemes often fail.
- Culture, family, religion and public morals matter to a healthy society, a theme stressed by Irving Kristol and some others.
- American power can be used to defend liberal democracy and to oppose tyranny.
- Many neoconservatives, though not all, support promoting democracy abroad, and some have argued for changing hostile regimes.
- A strong military is needed to deter rivals and support allies.
Policies and positions
Economy
Neoconservatives generally favour market economies and are wary of heavy regulation. Many, such as Irving Kristol, supported growth-oriented policies like tax cuts, while accepting a basic welfare state.
Social policy
They question programs that they say weaken families or work incentives. They often defend traditional institutions and support school standards and public order.
Foreign affairs
They generally favour a strong defence and firm opposition to adversaries. During the Cold War this meant hostility to Soviet expansion. An influential strand, especially after 2001, argued for intervention to change hostile regimes. Many prominent neoconservatives also supported Israel.
International institutions
Views range from scepticism about particular institutions, such as the United Nations, to support for alliances and selective multilateral action.
Thinkers and leaders
- Irving Kristol 1920–2009Editor and essayist often called the godfather of neoconservatism, who co-founded The Public Interest.
- Norman Podhoretz 1930–2025Longtime editor of Commentary, who moved it from liberalism to neoconservatism.
- Daniel Patrick Moynihan 1927–2003Sociologist and Democratic senator, associated with the early movement's critique of social policy.
- Jeane Kirkpatrick 1926–2006Political scientist and US ambassador to the UN, known for her essay 'Dictatorships and Double Standards'.
- Nathan Glazer 1923–2019Sociologist and co-editor of The Public Interest, who wrote on race, cities and social policy.
Main criticisms
Intervention and its costs
Critics argue that using force to promote democracy can lead to long, costly wars and unintended results. Defenders reply that inaction also has costs, and that failures show errors in execution, not in the principle.
Realist objection
Realists say that states should pursue limited national interests, and that crusading for values overreaches American power. Neoconservatives answer that regimes' internal nature shapes their conduct, so that values and security are closely linked.
Is it really conservative?
Some traditional conservatives say that remaking other societies is a radical project, at odds with caution and humility. Neoconservatives reply that conservatism includes defending a free order, which sometimes requires action.
The label itself
Critics sometimes use the word as a broad accusation, and some scholars say it covers very different people. Several of those described as neoconservatives say the term is vague or no longer fits.
Sources
- Kristol, Irving. Neoconservatism: The Autobiography of an Idea. New York: Free Press, 1995.Essays by a central figure in his own words.
- Steinfels, Peter. The Neoconservatives: The Men Who Are Changing America's Politics. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1979.An early critical study of the movement's origins.
- Halper, Stefan, and Jonathan Clarke. America Alone: The Neo-Conservatives and the Global Order. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004.A critical account of neoconservative foreign policy thought.
- Podhoretz, Norman. Breaking Ranks: A Political Memoir. New York: Harper and Row, 1979.A memoir of the move from left to right.