Politics / Socialist
Trotskyism
Revolutionary Marxism built on permanent, worldwide revolution and opposition to Stalin's bureaucracy
- Began
- 1920s–1930s (the Left Opposition from 1923; the Fourth International in 1938)
- Where
- Soviet Union at first, then in exile and in small groups across Europe, the Americas and Asia
- Key figures
- Leon Trotsky and the Left Opposition in the Soviet Communist Party
- Key works
- The Revolution Betrayed; The Permanent Revolution; Results and Prospects; The Transitional Program; History of the Russian Revolution
At a glance
Trotskyism is a current of Marxism that follows the ideas of Leon Trotsky. Trotskyists see themselves as upholding Marxism and Leninism, but they reject the Stalinist meaning often given to the label Marxism–Leninism. Trotsky was a leader of the Russian Revolution of 1917 and the main organiser of the Red Army during the civil war. Followers believe in working-class revolution, workers' control of society and a socialism that spreads across the world.
It began in the 1920s as the Left Opposition inside the Soviet Communist Party, which took shape from about 1923. Trotsky and his allies criticised the growing power of party and state officials and the policies of Joseph Stalin. Trotsky was expelled from the party in 1927 and exiled in 1929. He was murdered in Mexico in 1940 by a Soviet agent, Ramón Mercader.
Trotskyists are distinctive in three ways. They hold that socialism cannot be completed in one country alone. They see the Soviet Union under Stalin as a workers' state distorted by a privileged bureaucracy. They also call for workers to overthrow that bureaucracy by political revolution. The Fourth International, a rival to the Stalin-led Communist International, was set up by a conference of delegates in 1938, with Trotsky as its main inspiration. Trotskyist groups have mostly stayed small and divided.
Key concepts
- Permanent revolution
- The idea that in countries with a weak capitalist class, the working class must carry out both the democratic and the socialist revolution, and that this revolution must then spread abroad.
- Socialism in one country
- The doctrine, formulated in 1924–26 by Stalin and Nikolai Bukharin among others, that the USSR could build socialism alone; Trotskyists rejected it.
- Bureaucracy
- In Trotsky's analysis, a privileged layer of officials that took political control of the Soviet state from the workers.
- Degenerated workers' state
- Trotsky's description of the USSR: property was nationalised, but a bureaucracy ruled in its own interest.
- Political revolution
- A rising by workers to remove the bureaucracy while keeping nationalised property.
- Transitional demands
- Demands, such as workers' control of industry, that start from everyday struggles and point towards revolution.
Core positions
- Capitalism is a worldwide system, so socialism must be won internationally.
- The working class is the main force for revolutionary change.
- Workers should run society through democratic councils, called soviets in Russian.
- In the Trotskyist analysis, the Soviet bureaucracy under Stalin betrayed the aims of the 1917 revolution.
- Revolutionaries need an independent party and an international organisation.
- Socialists should oppose both capitalism and Stalinism.
Policies and positions
Economy
Trotskyists favour public ownership of major industry and banks under democratic workers' control and a planned economy. Trotsky argued that planning needed open debate and free soviets to work well.
The state
They hold that the capitalist state must be overthrown, not simply taken over. They support democracy within working-class bodies and oppose one-party bureaucratic rule.
Foreign affairs
They stress internationalism and opposition to imperialism and nationalism. Trotsky urged defence of the USSR against foreign attack while calling for the overthrow of Stalin. This was debated within the anti-Stalinist left, and he died in 1940, before the German invasion of 1941.
Tactics
Some Trotskyist groups practise entryism, working inside trade unions and wider left parties. Others rejected it and built independent parties.
Thinkers and leaders
- Leon Trotsky 1879–1940Leader of the 1917 Petrograd Soviet and the Red Army, and the main theorist of the movement.
- Christian Rakovsky 1873–1941Soviet diplomat and Left Opposition leader who was sentenced in the 1938 Moscow Trial and shot in 1941 in the Oryol massacre of prisoners.
- James P. Cannon 1890–1974Founder of American Trotskyism and a leader of the Socialist Workers Party.
- C. L. R. James 1901–1989Caribbean historian and writer who was a Trotskyist in the 1930s before breaking away.
- Ernest Mandel 1923–1995Belgian economist and leading figure of the Fourth International.
Main criticisms
Was Trotsky an alternative to Stalin?
Critics, including anarchists and many historians, note that Trotsky helped build the one-party state, banned party factions in 1921 and backed the suppression of the Kronstadt rising. Defenders reply that these were emergency measures in civil war and that he later argued for soviet democracy.
Can socialism succeed in one country?
Critics say the expectation that revolutions would spread abroad was not borne out, since the USSR lasted for decades without them. Defenders reply that permanent revolution concerns the international conditions for completing socialism, not mere survival. Some Trotskyists interpret isolation as feeding bureaucratic rule and see the Soviet collapse in 1991 as support for Trotsky's view.
The vanguard party and democracy
Critics argue that a disciplined revolutionary party tends to rule over workers rather than for them. Defenders say Trotskyism calls for democratic debate and workers' councils, and that discipline is needed only in action.
Is the 'degenerated workers' state' idea correct?
Some on the left argued that the USSR was a new class society or state capitalism, and Trotskyists themselves split over this. Defenders of Trotsky's view point to nationalised property and planning as signs of a different economic basis.
Sources
- Trotsky, Leon. The Revolution Betrayed. Translated by Max Eastman. New York: Doubleday, Doran, 1937.Trotsky's analysis of the Stalinist USSR.
- Deutscher, Isaac. The Prophet Armed: Trotsky 1879–1921. London: Oxford University Press, 1954.First volume of the classic biography; later volumes cover his exile.
- Service, Robert. Trotsky: A Biography. London: Macmillan, 2009.A critical modern biography.
- Knei-Paz, Baruch. The Social and Political Thought of Leon Trotsky. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1978.A study of Trotsky's ideas, including permanent revolution.
- Encyclopaedia Britannica. "Trotskyism." Chicago: Encyclopaedia Britannica.Short overview of the doctrine and movement.