Philosophy / 19th century to today
Pragmatism
The view that ideas are to be understood and tested by their practical effects
- Began
- 1870sScholars: Charles Sanders Peirce set out the core idea in essays of 1877 and 1878. Its name and wider fame came in the 1890s and 1900s, largely through William James.
- Where
- United States, first in Cambridge, Massachusetts
- Key figures
- Charles Sanders Peirce and William James, who were central to the early Cambridge circle. John Dewey became a leading later developer.
- Key works
- How to Make Our Ideas Clear (Peirce, 1878); Pragmatism: A New Name for Some Old Ways of Thinking (James, 1907); The Meaning of Truth (James, 1909); Experience and Nature (Dewey, 1925); The Quest for Certainty (Dewey, 1929)
At a glance
Pragmatism is a school of philosophy that began in the United States. It says that we understand an idea best by asking what difference it makes in practice. Pragmatists tend to see beliefs as guides for action, and they reject the picture of the mind as a simple mirror of the world. They do not all deny that reality or truth exist.
It grew out of discussions among a small group of thinkers in Cambridge, Massachusetts, in the 1870s. Charles Sanders Peirce stated the central method. William James made it widely known in lectures and books, and John Dewey later applied it to education, democracy and science.
Pragmatists share the empiricist habit of tying knowledge to experience. They are wary of fixed certainties and see inquiry as an ongoing process of testing ideas and correcting mistakes. James described the school as a new name for some old ways of thinking.
Key concepts
- Pragmatic maxim
- Peirce's rule that the meaning of an idea lies in the practical effects we can expect if it is true.
- Inquiry
- The process of moving from doubt to settled belief by testing ideas against experience.
- Fallibilism
- The view that any of our beliefs, even well-supported ones, might turn out to be mistaken and be revised.
- Pragmatist theories of truth
- Accounts, differing between Peirce, James and Dewey, that link truth to testing in experience; James said true beliefs are those that can be verified and prove their worth, which is not the same as whatever is convenient.
- Instrumentalism
- Dewey's view that ideas and theories are tools for dealing with problems.
- Radical empiricism
- James's view that philosophy should treat relations between things, as well as the things themselves, as part of experience.
Core ideas
- The meaning of an idea is found in its practical consequences.
- In Peirce's account, beliefs are habits of action, and doubt is what pushes us to inquire.
- No belief is beyond all possible revision.
- Knowledge grows through testing ideas in experience, much as scientists test hypotheses.
- Philosophy should deal with real human problems, not only abstract puzzles.
- Thought and action are closely linked, and values can be examined through inquiry as well.
Key arguments
The pragmatic maxim
Peirce argued that to clear up an idea, we should ask what effects it could conceivably have in practice. If two ideas lead to no different effects, then they do not really differ in meaning.
Doubt and belief
Peirce held that we do not start from universal doubt, as Descartes proposed. Merely verbal or pretended doubt is not real doubt. Genuine doubt is an irritation that disturbs our settled habits, and inquiry is how we settle it.
The will to believe
James argued that when a choice is live, important and cannot be settled by evidence, it is reasonable to let our wider needs guide us. He used this to defend religious belief in some cases.
Learning by doing
Dewey argued that education should draw on children's experience and involve active inquiry and problem-solving. This view shaped progressive education.
Philosophers
- Charles Sanders Peirce 1839–1914Logician and scientist who stated the pragmatic maxim and is usually seen as the founder.
- William James 1842–1910Psychologist and philosopher who popularised pragmatism and applied it to truth and religion.
- John Dewey 1859–1952Philosopher and educator who developed pragmatism in logic, ethics, politics and schooling.
- George Herbert Mead 1863–1931Philosopher in the American pragmatist circle, associated with Dewey, whose social theory of the self drew on pragmatist ideas.
- Richard Rorty 1931–2007Philosopher who revived pragmatism in the late twentieth century in a more sceptical form.
Main criticisms
Does it confuse truth with usefulness?
Critics, including Bertrand Russell, argued that a belief can be useful yet false, so truth cannot simply be what works. Defenders reply in different ways. James stressed verification in experience, not comfort, while Peirce tied truth to what inquiry would finally settle on.
Is the pragmatic maxim too narrow?
Some say that tying meaning to practical effects leaves out ideas that matter but have no clear testable results. Defenders answer that the maxim is a method of clarifying ideas, and that it has been read more or less broadly by different pragmatists.
Is it just a version of relativism?
Critics worry that if truth depends on experience and usefulness, then different groups might each have their own truths. Peirce and Dewey replied that inquiry is public and self-correcting, so it is checked by shared experience. Rorty's later view is more contested on this point.
Sources
- Hookway, Christopher. "Pragmatism." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of the history and main themes.
- James, William. Pragmatism: A New Name for Some Old Ways of Thinking. New York: Longmans, Green, 1907.James's lectures setting out the school for general readers.
- Menand, Louis. The Metaphysical Club. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2001.A history of the people and ideas behind American pragmatism.
- Misak, Cheryl. The American Pragmatists. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013.Scholarly account from Peirce to the mid-twentieth century.