Philosophy / Indian

Vedanta

Schools of thought built on the Upanishads, asking what ultimate reality is and how the self relates to it

Began
The Brahma Sutras, the school's foundational text, c. 200 BC–AD 200; the Upanishads it draws on are older, and the main Vedanta schools took shape in later centuriesScholars: Tradition holds that the sage Badarayana, whom tradition identifies with Vyasa, composed the Brahma Sutras in ancient times. Most historians date the text in its present form to between about 200 BC and AD 200, and the date is debated. The major schools and their commentaries came much later.
Where
Indian subcontinent
Key figures
No single founder. Tradition credits Badarayana with the Brahma Sutras. Later teachers such as Shankara, Ramanuja and Madhva developed and systematised established lines of thought into the main branches.
Key works
The Upanishads; The Brahma Sutras; The Bhagavad Gita; Shankara's commentary on the Brahma Sutras; Ramanuja's Sri Bhashya

At a glance

Vedanta is a family of Indian philosophical schools. The name means 'the end of the Veda'. It refers to the Upanishads, the last part of the Vedic texts, which are later than the earlier hymns and ritual layers. Vedanta thinkers explain what these texts teach about reality, the self and liberation.

Its base is three texts, known in tradition as the 'triple foundation'. They are the Upanishads, the Brahma Sutras and the Bhagavad Gita. The Brahma Sutras are very short, compressed sayings called sutras that summarise the Upanishads' teaching. They are hard to follow alone, so teachers wrote commentaries on them. The schools drew on these commentaries, but also on older Upanishadic and Gita traditions and on long debates with other schools.

Vedanta is known for its focus on Brahman, the ultimate reality, and on Atman, the self. All schools ask how the two are related. Advaita Vedanta says they are one. Vishishtadvaita says the self is distinct yet belongs to Brahman, as a body belongs to a person. Dvaita says they are always distinct. Vedanta is one of the six classical schools of Indian philosophy.

Key concepts

Brahman
The ultimate reality, which Vedanta schools describe in different ways.
Atman
The inner self of a living being, discussed in the Upanishads.
Moksha
Liberation from the cycle of rebirth, which schools describe differently, for example as freedom from ignorance of one's true nature, or as a life in the presence of God through grace and devotion.
Maya
A much debated term, used above all in Advaita, for the power or principle behind the appearance of a world of many things, linked to ignorance, and understood differently across Vedanta.
Jnana
Knowledge, especially insight into Brahman and the self, which Advaita sees as the means to liberation and other schools see as one part of a path that also needs devotion.
Shruti
'What is heard', the revealed Vedic scriptures as a whole, of which Vedanta gives special importance to the Upanishads.

Core ideas

  • Vedanta traditionally rests on the Upanishads, the Brahma Sutras and the Gita, though schools differ on how scripture, reasoning and commentary work together.
  • Brahman is the ultimate reality, and schools differ on how it relates to the world, for example whether it is the material cause of the world or only its maker.
  • The Atman is closely tied to Brahman, though schools disagree on exactly how.
  • Bondage to rebirth is overcome through liberation, moksha, the highest human aim.
  • Schools differ on the means to liberation, which include knowledge, meditation, ethical living, devotion and divine grace.
  • Careful study, reasoning and reflection on the texts are the proper method.

Key arguments

Reading the Upanishads as one teaching

Vedanta commentators hold that the many Upanishads, though varied, teach one coherent message about Brahman. The Brahma Sutras are traditionally read as setting out to show this by dealing with apparent conflicts between passages. Historians do not all share this view of the texts.

Brahman as cause of the world

Many commentators read the Brahma Sutras as saying that Brahman is both the maker and the stuff of the world, as a spider spins a web from itself. Details differ by commentator, and Dvaita does not accept Brahman as the material cause. The Sutras also reject the view of rival schools that the world comes from an unconscious principle alone.

The great sayings

Upanishadic statements such as tat tvam asi, 'That thou art', are central. Advaita reads them as stating identity of self and Brahman. Vishishtadvaita reads them as saying the self has Brahman as its inner ruler and is, like a body, dependent on and inseparable from it. Dvaita reads them in ways that keep self and God distinct.

Three ways to liberation

Many Vedanta writers discuss paths of knowledge, action and devotion, drawing on the Gita. Schools differ on which is chief. Advaita stresses knowledge, while Vishishtadvaita and Dvaita give devotion and divine grace a central place.

Branches

  • Advaita VedantaThe Indian school teaching that the true self and ultimate reality are one
  • VishishtadvaitaThe Vedanta of qualified non-duality, taught by Ramanuja, with souls and matter as dependent modes of God
  • DvaitaThe Vedanta school of Madhva, teaching that God, souls and matter are eternally distinct

Philosophers

  • Badarayana dates uncertainTraditionally named as the author of the Brahma Sutras.
  • Gaudapada c. 6th–7th century ADEarly Advaita teacher, author of a verse commentary on the Mandukya Upanishad.
  • Shankara c. 8th century ADThe most influential systematiser of Advaita, who wrote commentaries on the Upanishads, the Gita and the Brahma Sutras.
  • Ramanuja traditionally 1017–1137Key thinker of Vishishtadvaita, who built on an earlier devotional tradition and taught that selves and the world are real and relate to Brahman as a body does to its inner self.
  • Madhva traditionally c. 1238–1317Founder of Dvaita, who taught a lasting difference between God and individual selves.
  • Swami Vivekananda 1863–1902Teacher who presented a modern, reformulated and universalist Vedanta, often called Neo-Vedanta, to audiences in India and the West.

Main criticisms

Is there one Vedanta?

Critics note that the schools reach very different conclusions from the same texts, so the texts may not teach one doctrine. Defenders reply that the disagreement is about interpretation and shows an active tradition of debate over shared texts.

Reliance on scripture

Some rival Indian schools and modern critics say that Vedanta's reliance on scripture limits free inquiry. Vedanta thinkers answer that reasoning is necessary but works under scriptural testimony on matters beyond the senses, and that they use argument heavily to defend and interpret the texts.

Is the world real?

Critics of Advaita say that calling the world ultimately unreal makes everyday life and ethics hard to explain. Advaitins reply that the world is real at the ordinary, conventional level and is seen differently only from the viewpoint of final knowledge. Vishishtadvaita and Dvaita reject this view and hold the world to be real.

Sources

  1. Encyclopaedia Britannica. "Vedanta." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.Overview of Vedanta and its schools.
  2. Radhakrishnan, Sarvepalli. Indian Philosophy. London: George Allen and Unwin, 1923–1927.Classic survey that treats Vedanta at length.
  3. Deutsch, Eliot. Advaita Vedanta: A Philosophical Reconstruction. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 1969.Short account of the best known branch.
  4. Olivelle, Patrick, trans. The Early Upanishads: Annotated Text and Translation. New York: Oxford University Press, 1998.Standard translation of the main early Upanishads.