Philosophy / Indian

Vishishtadvaita

The Vedanta of qualified non-duality, taught by Ramanuja, with souls and matter as dependent modes of God

Began
11th–12th century, with RamanujaScholars: Tradition dates Ramanuja to c. 1017–1137. Many historians prefer a somewhat shorter life and place his work in the late 11th and early 12th centuries.
Where
South India, centred on Srirangam and the Tamil country, later spreading across India
Key figures
Ramanuja was the main systematiser of the school. He built on earlier Sri Vaishnava teachers such as Nathamuni and Yamunacharya, and on the Tamil Alvar poets.
Key works
Sri Bhashya (Ramanuja's commentary on the Brahma Sutras); Vedartha Sangraha (Ramanuja); Bhagavad Gita Bhashya (Ramanuja); Upanishads and Brahma Sutras (the shared Vedanta scriptures the school interprets); Nalayira Divya Prabandham (Tamil devotional hymns of the Alvars, revered by Sri Vaishnavas)

At a glance

Vishishtadvaita means "non-duality of the qualified". It is a school of Vedanta, the tradition of thought based on the Upanishads, the Brahma Sutras and the Bhagavad Gita. Its main teacher and systematiser was Ramanuja, who lived in South India.

The school teaches that there is one ultimate reality, Brahman, who is the personal God Vishnu, also called Narayana. Individual souls and the material world are real, not illusions. They are, however, wholly dependent on God and inseparable from him, and are described as his modes or his body. So reality is one, but it is qualified by these real dependent forms.

It is closely linked with Sri Vaishnavism, a devotional community that honours Vishnu and his consort Lakshmi (Sri). Ramanuja drew on teachers and hymns that existed before him. Followers value bhakti, loving devotion, and surrender to God as ways to liberation. The school is often contrasted with the Advaita Vedanta of Shankara.

Key concepts

Brahman
The supreme reality, understood in this school as the personal God Vishnu, who has good qualities and is the cause of everything.
Vishishtadvaita
The view that reality is one, but qualified by souls and matter, which are real and dependent on God.
Chit and achit
Conscious beings (souls) and unconscious matter, which are real and are described as God's body.
Sharira-shariri bhava
A technical relation in which souls and matter depend on God, are controlled by him and exist for his purposes, so that he is their inner self.
Bhakti
Loving devotion to God, a central part of the path to liberation in the tradition.
Prapatti
Complete surrender to God, in which the soul trusts God to save it; its exact relation to bhakti is understood differently in different Sri Vaishnava lines.

Core ideas

  • There is one ultimate reality, Brahman, who is the personal God Vishnu.
  • Individual souls are real and eternal, and matter is real too. The material world goes through cycles of creation and dissolution, while its underlying material principle is eternal.
  • Souls and matter are the body of God, and God is their inner controller and self.
  • Liberation (moksha) is not merging into God but living in loving service and fellowship with him.
  • Devotion and surrender to God, with his grace, are the means to freedom.
  • Ramanuja and his followers read the Upanishads as teaching this qualified unity, and not an unqualified one.

Key arguments

The body and the self

The school reads the Upanishadic statements of unity through the relation of a body to its self, taken in a technical sense. Souls and matter depend on God, are controlled by him and serve his purposes. So texts that say "all this is Brahman" are taken to be true, because everything is God's body.

Objection to the doctrine of illusion

Ramanuja argued that the world cannot be an illusion removed by knowledge, since ordinary experience shows real differences. He also argued that ignorance cannot properly belong either to Brahman or to the individual soul in the way the Advaita view needs.

Statements of identity

Passages such as "That you are" are read as saying that the soul has God as its inner self, not that the soul is identical to God without remainder. Difference and unity are both kept.

Grace and surrender

The tradition teaches that a soul cannot win freedom by effort alone, and that God's grace is needed. Later Sri Vaishnava theology gives special emphasis to surrender (prapatti) and to Lakshmi as a compassionate mediator, though presentations differ on how far this goes.

Philosophers

  • Ramanuja traditionally c. 1017–1137Systematised the school in his commentaries, especially the Sri Bhashya.
  • Yamunacharya traditionally c. 10th–11th centuryEarlier Sri Vaishnava teacher whose works prepared the ground for Ramanuja.
  • Nathamuni traditionally c. 823–951, uncertainTraditionally credited with gathering the hymns of the Alvars and beginning the line of teachers.
  • Vedanta Desika 1268–1369Major later thinker who defended and refined the school in Sanskrit and Tamil.
  • Pillai Lokacharya c. 13th–14th centuryLeading teacher of the Tenkalai branch, which stresses divine grace and surrender.

Main criticisms

Advaita Vedanta: is difference ultimately real?

Advaita thinkers hold that Brahman is nirguna, meaning without limiting or material attributes, and that difference is not ultimately real. Vishishtadvaita thinkers reply that the Upanishads speak of both unity and difference, and read them as describing a God with real qualities and real dependents.

Dvaita Vedanta: is the unity too strong?

Madhva's Dvaita school holds that God and souls are fully and eternally separate. It criticises the idea that souls are God's body as blurring that line. Followers of Ramanuja reply that dependence and being the body of God do not remove real difference.

Can a perfect God have a body of imperfect souls?

Critics ask how God can remain untouched by the faults and suffering of souls and matter that form his body. Defenders reply that the self is not harmed by changes in its body, so God stays perfect. Critics may reject this analogy or say that divine embodiment is not adequately explained.

Historical questions about origins

Ramanuja cites earlier teachers, such as Bodhayana, whose commentary has not survived. Scholars debate who these figures were and what they taught, so how far earlier sources can be reconstructed is uncertain. Followers hold that Ramanuja recovered the true meaning of the texts, while historians also stress his own creative work.

Sources

  1. Carman, John Braisted. The Theology of Ramanuja: An Essay in Interreligious Understanding. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1974.Study of Ramanuja's view of God and world.
  2. Lipner, Julius. The Face of Truth: A Study of Meaning and Metaphysics in the Vedantic Theology of Ramanuja. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1986.Detailed study of his metaphysics.
  3. Ramanuja. The Vedarthasangraha of Sri Ramanujacarya. Translated by S. S. Raghavachar. Mysore: Sri Ramakrishna Ashrama, 1956.Ramanuja's summary of the teaching of the Vedanta.