Philosophy / Indian
Advaita Vedanta
The Indian school teaching that the true self and ultimate reality are one
- Began
- Roots in the Upanishads (many centuries earlier); early systematic works by Gaudapada (c. 6th–7th century CE); Shankara's commentaries (c. 8th century CE)Scholars: Tradition gives Shankara the dates c. 788–820 CE. Modern scholars usually place him in the 8th century, with some estimates earlier or later, and the dates are debated. Gaudapada is usually placed some generations before Shankara, and his dates are also uncertain.
- Where
- India. Tradition links Shankara with Kerala in the south and credits him with founding monasteries across the subcontinent, but these details are debated by historians.
- Key figures
- No single founder. Advaita draws on the Upanishads. Gaudapada wrote an early systematic work, and Shankara is its most influential teacher. Tradition places Shankara in a teaching line from Gaudapada through Govinda.
- Key works
- Upanishads; Brahma Sutras; Bhagavad Gita; Mandukya Karika (Gaudapada); Shankara's commentaries
At a glance
Advaita Vedanta is a school of Indian philosophy. Its name means "non-dual", or "not two". It teaches that the deepest self, called Atman, is not different from Brahman, the ultimate reality. Brahman here is not usually understood as a personal god, but as pure being and consciousness without parts.
It is a branch of Vedanta, which interprets the Upanishads, ancient Indian texts about the self and reality. Gaudapada wrote an early work on the Mandukya Upanishad. Shankara wrote influential commentaries. Tradition also credits him with founding or organising monasteries, though historians debate the details. Tradition holds that the teaching is far older than both men.
What makes it distinctive is its claim that the world of many separate things is not ultimately real in the way it appears. Freedom, called moksha, comes through knowledge that one's true self is Brahman, not through ritual alone.
Key concepts
- Brahman
- The ultimate reality, unchanging and without parts, described as being, consciousness and bliss.
- Atman
- The inner self or witness consciousness, taught to be identical with Brahman.
- Maya
- A term for the way the one reality appears as a world of many things, understood in somewhat different ways by different Advaita authors.
- Avidya
- Ignorance of one's true nature, seen as the cause of bondage, and explained in varying ways by later Advaita writers.
- Moksha
- Liberation from the cycle of rebirth, gained by knowing the self as Brahman.
- Jnana
- Knowledge of the self, taken as the direct means to liberation.
Core ideas
- Brahman alone is ultimately real, and it has no parts or divisions.
- The Atman, the true self, is the same as Brahman.
- The world of ordinary experience is not ultimately real as it appears, and is described as neither fully real nor simply unreal.
- Suffering and rebirth come from ignorance of one's true nature.
- Liberation comes through knowledge, supported by study of scripture, reflection and meditation.
- Ethical life and purification of the mind prepare a person for this knowledge.
Key arguments
The rope and the snake
In dim light a person sees a snake, but it is only a rope. The fear is real, yet the snake was never there. Advaita uses this to say that the world is a misreading of Brahman, which is corrected by knowledge.
That thou art
The Chandogya Upanishad says "tat tvam asi", often translated "you are that". Advaita reads this as stating that the individual self is Brahman.
The three states
Waking, dreaming and deep sleep each have different contents. Advaita argues that one unchanging awareness underlies all three, and that this witness is the true self. Other schools do not accept this argument.
Two levels of truth
Everyday life is accepted as valid at the practical level. From the highest standpoint, only non-dual Brahman is real. This lets the school allow ritual, ethics and worship while placing knowledge above them.
Philosophers
- Gaudapada c. 6th–7th century CE (debated)Author of the Mandukya Karika, an early systematic statement of non-dual teaching.
- Shankara 8th century CE (traditionally c. 788–820)The most influential Advaita thinker, who wrote commentaries on the Upanishads, Brahma Sutras and Gita.
- Mandana Mishra c. 8th century CEAuthor of the Brahmasiddhi, an important work of non-dual thought. Tradition makes him a contemporary of Shankara, but that link and his exact position are disputed.
- Vachaspati Mishra c. 9th–10th century CE (uncertain)Wrote the Bhamati, a major commentary on Shankara's Brahma Sutra work, from which a line of Advaita interpretation takes its name.
- Vidyaranya 14th centuryScholar and monastic leader, traditionally credited with the Panchadashi, a popular Advaita guide, though its authorship has been questioned.
- Ramana Maharshi 1879–1950Modern teacher strongly associated with Advaita, who taught self-inquiry rather than working within the scholastic tradition of Shankara's followers.
Main criticisms
Is the world an illusion?
Critics, including other Vedanta schools, argue that calling the world unreal denies the evidence of experience. Advaita thinkers reply that they do not call the world nonexistent. They say it is dependent on Brahman and not ultimately real, like a dream that is valid only until waking.
How can ignorance arise?
Ramanuja and later critics argued that Advaita cannot coherently explain where ignorance belongs or how it could affect a Brahman that is pure consciousness. Advaita authors answer in different ways. Many say ignorance cannot be neatly explained in terms of the highest reality, which is part of why it is called maya.
Is knowledge alone enough?
Devotional Vedanta schools differ among themselves, but many give a large place to devotion and divine grace alongside knowledge. Advaita defenders reply that devotion is a valuable preparation and that final liberation is the recognition of identity with Brahman.
Hidden Buddhism?
Some Vedanta critics, such as Ramanuja and later theistic writers, accused Advaita of being Buddhism in disguise, because of its talk of illusion. Advaita thinkers reply that their teaching rests on the Upanishads and affirms Atman and Brahman, which most Buddhist traditions reject in the form Advaita gives them.
Sources
- "Advaita Vedanta." In Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Overview of the school's history and main doctrines.
- "Vedanta." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.Short account of Vedanta and its schools.
- Deutsch, Eliot. Advaita Vedanta: A Philosophical Reconstruction. Honolulu: University Press of Hawaii, 1969.A clear philosophical introduction to the school.
- Fort, Andrew O., and Patricia Y. Mumme, eds. Living Liberation in Hindu Thought. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1996.Essays on liberation, including Advaita views.