Philosophy / Indian

Dvaita

The Vedanta school of Madhva, teaching that God, souls and matter are eternally distinct

Began
13th century AD, taught by Madhva (his dates are debated)
Where
South India, from Udupi in what is now Karnataka
Key figures
Madhva (also called Madhvacharya and Ananda Tirtha)
Key works
Brahma Sutras with Madhva's commentary; Bhagavad Gita with Madhva's commentary; Anuvyakhyana; Vishnu Tattva Vinirnaya; Mahabharata Tatparya Nirnaya

At a glance

Dvaita means "dualism". It is a school of Vedanta, the tradition that interprets the Upanishads, the Brahma Sutras and the Bhagavad Gita. Its main teacher was Madhva, who lived in the 13th century in coastal Karnataka.

Dvaita holds that God, individual souls and the material world are all real and are different from one another for ever. God is identified with Vishnu, who is the independent being. Souls and matter depend on him completely.

This sets Dvaita apart from Advaita Vedanta, which teaches that the soul and Brahman are ultimately one. Madhva held that the world is not an illusion and that the soul never becomes identical with God. Liberation means living in God's presence and enjoying him, not merging into him.

Key concepts

Bheda
Difference, the idea that five basic differences are real and eternal: God from soul, God from matter, soul from matter, one soul from another, and the material things in the world from one another.
Svatantra and paratantra
Independent and dependent reality; only God (Vishnu) is independent, and everything else depends on him.
Jiva
The individual soul, which is real, conscious and distinct from God and from other souls.
Bhakti
Loving devotion to God, which Dvaita treats as the central means to liberation.
Moksha
Liberation from rebirth, understood as reaching God's presence and sharing in joy, with each soul keeping its own identity.
Taratamya
The gradation of souls, the view that souls differ in their natures and in the degree of bliss they can have.

Core ideas

  • God, souls and matter are three real and eternally distinct kinds of being.
  • Vishnu is the supreme, independent Lord who creates, sustains and governs the world.
  • The world is real and is not an illusion.
  • Souls have real agency, but they depend wholly on God and are never identical with him.
  • Liberation comes through knowledge and devotion, and it is finally granted by God's grace.
  • Scripture is the main source of knowledge about God, alongside perception and inference.

Key arguments

The argument from difference

Madhva held that we directly experience difference, for example between a pot and a cloth. Dvaita argues that perception is a valid source of knowledge, so this difference is real. This is the school's objection to the Advaita view that difference is only apparent.

Against world-illusion

Dvaita thinkers argue that if the world were false, the knowledge that says so would be false too. They hold that the world is real, though it is dependent on God and God alone is independent.

Dependence on God

Every being other than God is said to exist and act only through his support. This is why Dvaita calls God the sole independent reality.

Inherent nature of souls

Souls are held to have fixed natures. Tradition describes some as destined for liberation, and this teaching on grades of souls is one of the school's most distinctive claims.

Philosophers

  • Madhva c. 1238–1317 (traditional dates; some scholars give c. 1199–1278)Founder of Dvaita Vedanta, who wrote commentaries on the Brahma Sutras and Gita and set up the Udupi tradition.
  • Jayatirtha c. 1345–1388Major commentator on Madhva's works, whose clear explanations were highly influential in the school.
  • Vyasatirtha 1460–1539Scholar and teacher at the Vijayanagara court, who wrote the Nyayamrita, a detailed defence of Dvaita against Advaita.
  • Purandara Dasa c. 1484–1564Devotional poet and composer associated with the Haridasa movement, which spread Madhva's ideas through song in Kannada.

Main criticisms

Is eternal difference the right reading of the texts?

Advaita thinkers point to Upanishadic statements such as "that you are" and say they teach the oneness of soul and Brahman. Dvaita thinkers reply that such passages must be read in a different sense, for example as teaching close dependence or likeness, since difference is shown by experience.

Does the world need an illusion to explain it?

Critics from other schools ask how a God wholly separate from souls and matter can be known or can act on them. Dvaita answers that God is known through scripture and grace, and that his supreme power needs no merging with the world to govern it.

The doctrine of graded souls

Some critics find the teaching that souls have fixed natures hard to reconcile with divine justice and with free effort. Defenders reply that this belongs to the nature each soul has from eternity, and that God's judgement and grace remain within a just order.

Sources

  1. Sarma, Deepak. "Madhva (1238–1317)." In Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Overview of Madhva's life and system
  2. Sharma, B. N. Krishnamurti. A History of the Dvaita School of Vedanta and Its Literature. Bombay: Booksellers' Publishing Co., 1960.Standard history of the school and its writings; later reprinted
  3. Sarma, Deepak. An Introduction to Madhva Vedanta. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2003.Accessible account of Dvaita doctrine
  4. Sharma, B. N. Krishnamurti. Philosophy of Sri Madhvacarya. Bombay: Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan, 1962.Systematic exposition of Madhva's thought; later reprinted