Politics / Anarchist
Individualist anarchism
A family of anarchist views that put the individual first and reject rule by the state
- Began
- 1844 (Stirner's The Ego and Its Own, published late in 1844 with an 1845 imprint); Tucker's journal Liberty began in 1881
- Where
- Germany (Stirner), the United States (Warren, Spooner, Tucker), with some followers in Europe
- Key figures
- No single founder. Key figures include Josiah Warren, Lysander Spooner and Benjamin Tucker in the United States, with Max Stirner as an influence and precursor
- Key works
- The Ego and Its Own; Instead of a Book; No Treason; Equitable Commerce; Individual Liberty
At a glance
Individualist anarchism is a branch of anarchism. Anarchists want a society without a state, meaning without a government that claims the right to rule everyone in a territory. Individualists start from the single person. Many of them, such as Spooner and Tucker, spoke of individual sovereignty, the idea that each person has the right to govern themselves. Stirner reached an anti-authority position by a different route, without appeal to rights.
The tradition has several roots. In the United States, Josiah Warren, Lysander Spooner and Benjamin Tucker drew on classical liberalism and its ideas of liberty and natural rights. Tucker also drew heavily on the French thinker Pierre-Joseph Proudhon and on Warren. In Germany, Max Stirner wrote a very different book in 1844 that rejected all fixed moral causes and put the unique self at the centre. Tucker later promoted Stirner's egoism, but Stirner was a separate thinker and not a founder of the American movement.
The tradition is not one school. Warren and Tucker favoured voluntary exchange, but within a labour-centred economics that opposed what Tucker called the four monopolies (money, land, tariffs and patents). They thought these let owners take income such as interest and rent that they had not earned. Spooner shared the focus on consent and law but did not hold identical economic views. Views on property therefore vary widely inside the tradition.
Key concepts
- Individual sovereignty
- The idea, held by Warren, Spooner and others, that each person has the right to govern themselves and cannot rightfully be ruled without consent.
- The Unique One (der Einzige)
- Stirner's term for the individual self, which he said cannot be fully captured by any label, ideal or group.
- Egoism
- Stirner's stance that the individual should not be bound by fixed ideas or abstract duties, such as God, the nation or humanity, and should treat them as their own to accept or reject.
- Cost the limit of price
- Warren's principle that goods should be priced by what they cost to produce, including the producer's effort and disagreeableness of the work, and not by what buyers can be made to pay.
- Mutualism
- An economic idea linked to Proudhon and taken up by Tucker, in which people exchange goods and credit by voluntary agreement, and in which forms of income from monopoly privilege are opposed.
- Voluntary association
- The principle that all cooperation, from trade to protection, should rest on free agreement and not on force.
Core positions
- The individual, not the group or the state, is the basic unit of moral and political life.
- The state is a coercive body, and its claim to rule people who never agreed to it has no sound basis.
- Social order can come from voluntary agreements, trade, and mutual help.
- Free speech, free thought and freedom over one's own body and lifestyle should be protected from interference.
- Tucker held that labour should receive its full product, and that state-backed monopolies unjustly shape the economy.
- Stirner went further and denied that any fixed moral principle, such as natural rights, binds the individual.
Policies and positions
The state
Individualist anarchists reject taxation and conscription as compulsion. Spooner argued in No Treason (1867 to 1870) that the US Constitution did not bind individuals, because none had personally consented to be governed by it, whatever the delegates who signed it did.
Economy and property
Tucker backed competition in markets but held that interest and rent arose from monopoly privilege, and he expected them to shrink once the privileges ended. He supported property based on occupancy and use. Later thinkers drew different conclusions about property.
Money and credit
Tucker favoured free banking, in which anyone could issue money backed by property. He believed this would push interest rates toward zero.
Rights and law
Spooner held that natural law should be applied by juries, who could also refuse to enforce unjust laws. Stirner did not treat rights as binding in themselves. He saw them as claims set up by society or the state, and stressed the individual's own power to act.
Thinkers and leaders
- Josiah Warren 1798–1874American thinker, sometimes called the first American anarchist in later accounts, who founded experimental communities based on equitable commerce.
- Max Stirner 1806–1856German philosopher whose book The Ego and Its Own became a key text of egoist thought.
- Lysander Spooner 1808–1887American lawyer and writer who argued against the legitimacy of the state and of laws not based on consent.
- Benjamin Tucker 1854–1939American editor of Liberty and the leading voice of the tradition in English.
- Voltairine de Cleyre 1866–1912American writer who began as an individualist and later moved toward forms of anarchism without fixed economic labels.
Main criticisms
Is a society without a state workable?
Critics say that without a government, courts and police, the strong would dominate the weak and disputes would turn to violence. Defenders reply that voluntary agencies, juries and reputation can settle disputes, and that states themselves cause much violence.
Does individualism ignore social bonds?
Critics, including many social anarchists, say people are shaped by communities and that a focus on the separate individual neglects shared life and inequality. Defenders reply that voluntary cooperation is welcome, and that only forced collectives are rejected.
Is it really anarchist if it allows markets and property?
Many socialist anarchists argue that private property and wage labour create their own hierarchies. Tucker and his followers reply that, once state monopolies are removed, competition would give labour its full reward and remove exploitation.
Its link to anarcho-capitalism
Murray Rothbard drew on Tucker and Spooner, and some see anarcho-capitalism as a descendant. Many anarchists dispute this, saying Tucker's opposition to interest and rent places him in the socialist tradition.
Sources
- Leopold, David. "Max Stirner." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Stirner's life and ideas.
- Stirner, Max. The Ego and Its Own. Edited by David Leopold. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995.
- Tucker, Benjamin R. Instead of a Book, by a Man Too Busy to Write One. New York: Benj. R. Tucker, 1893.
- Martin, James J. Men Against the State. DeKalb, IL: Adrian Allen Associates, 1953.A history of individualist anarchism in the United States.