Politics / Anarchist

Anarcho-capitalism

A stateless society in which private property and voluntary markets provide everything, including law

Began
c. 1970, a rough date for the modern system as set out in Rothbard's influential works. This is not an uncontested starting point.Scholars: Rothbard's use of the idea is commonly placed in the 1950s, and he developed the full system in the 1960s and 1970s. Historians debate where precursor ideas end and the label and developed theory begin. Gustave de Molinari's essay on the private supply of security dates from 1849 and is often cited as a forerunner.
Where
Chiefly developed in the United States in the modern period, with European precursors such as Molinari in Belgium and France
Key figures
Murray Rothbard is usually seen as the main founder of the modern theory. David Friedman and others developed other versions.
Key works
For a New Liberty; The Ethics of Liberty; Power and Market; The Machinery of Freedom; Man, Economy, and State

At a glance

Anarcho-capitalism is a political idea that says the state should be abolished and replaced by privately supplied institutions. Its supporters hold that private property and free markets can supply what people need, including courts, police, insurance and defence. Nobody would be forced to pay taxes or obey a government.

The idea took its modern form in the United States in the mid-twentieth century. The economist Murray Rothbard combined classical liberal ideas, Austrian School economics and a theory of natural rights. He took the libertarian case for a very small state and pushed it to the conclusion that no state should exist. He also selectively drew on earlier American individualist anarchists such as Lysander Spooner and Benjamin Tucker, a link that many anarchists dispute.

Its distinctive claim is that anarchy and capitalism belong together. Many other anarchists reject this. They say anarchism has always opposed hierarchy and private ownership of productive property, so they do not count anarcho-capitalism as anarchism. Its supporters reply that they oppose the state, which they define as a body that holds a monopoly on force and funds itself by compulsion.

Key concepts

Self-ownership
The idea that each person has rightful control over their own body and labour.
Non-aggression principle
The rule, central to Rothbard's version, that it is wrong to start force or threaten force against another person or their property.
Private property
Goods and land that individuals or groups own and may use, sell or give away as they choose.
Voluntary exchange
Trade and agreement that people enter freely, without being forced.
Private law
A proposed model, associated especially with Rothbard and David Friedman, in which competing firms and arbitrators, paid by customers, provide courts and security instead of the state.
Monopoly of force
The state's claim to be the only body allowed to use legitimate coercion in a territory, which supporters of the idea oppose.

Core positions

  • The state is seen as an institution that takes money by taxation, which supporters regard as theft, so it should be abolished.
  • Individuals own themselves and the things they create or acquire peacefully.
  • In Rothbard's rights-based version, force is justified only in defence against aggression or to enforce contracts and restitution. Consequentialist advocates such as David Friedman argue instead from the results of different legal arrangements.
  • Markets and voluntary agreements can supply all services, including law, police and defence.
  • Competition between providers would give them reasons to be fair and efficient.
  • Property rights are the basis of liberty. Some advocates, such as Rothbard, hold that rights are fixed by the nature of persons rather than made by governments.

Policies and positions

Economy

All goods and services would be traded on a free market, with no taxes or state-run industry. Many supporters, following Rothbard, favour private commodity money such as gold and no central bank, though this is not shared by every advocate.

Law and policing

Private security firms and arbitration agencies would compete for customers. Disputes between firms would go to agreed third-party arbitrators.

Defence and foreign affairs

Defence would be paid for voluntarily, by individuals, insurers or communities. Supporters generally oppose war fought by states and conscription.

Rights and social life

Supporters stress personal freedom in matters such as drug use and sexual conduct. Welfare would depend on charity, mutual aid and private insurance.

Thinkers and leaders

  • Murray Rothbard 1926–1995American economist who developed and named the modern theory of anarcho-capitalism.
  • David Friedman born 1945American economist who argued for private law on practical, consequence-based grounds in The Machinery of Freedom.
  • Gustave de Molinari 1819–1912Belgian economist who argued in 1849 that private firms could supply security, often cited as a forerunner.
  • Lysander Spooner 1808–1887American individualist anarchist and lawyer who attacked the legitimacy of government.
  • Benjamin Tucker 1854–1939American individualist anarchist and editor of Liberty whom Rothbard cited, though Tucker rejected capitalism in the usual sense, so the connection is selective and contested.
  • Hans-Hermann Hoppe born 1949German-American philosopher and economist who defended private-property anarchism with an argument from the ethics of argumentation.

Main criticisms

Is it really anarchism?

Many social anarchists say anarchism means opposing all unjust hierarchy, including that of employers and owners, so a society of private property would be rule by the wealthy. Supporters reply that anarchism means having no ruler, and that voluntary relations, even unequal ones, are not rule.

Power and inequality

Critics argue that rich people could buy the strongest security firms and so dominate courts and the poor. Defenders reply that competition, reputation and the cost of fighting would push firms toward peaceful arbitration, and they note that states also favour the wealthy.

Public goods and collective problems

Critics say markets may not supply things like clean air, roads or defence, because people can enjoy them without paying. Defenders answer that private solutions exist, such as contracts, ownership and voluntary funding, and that state provision has its own failures.

Property and its origins

Critics ask how land was first fairly acquired, since much property in history came from conquest or force. Defenders reply that rightful ownership comes from first use or voluntary transfer, and that disputed claims could be settled by courts and restitution.

Sources

  1. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. "Anarchism." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of anarchist thought, including the dispute over right-wing versions.
  2. Rothbard, Murray N. For a New Liberty: The Libertarian Manifesto. New York: Macmillan, 1973.Rothbard's popular account of a stateless society.
  3. Rothbard, Murray N. The Ethics of Liberty. Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities Press, 1982.The natural-rights case for property and against the state.
  4. Friedman, David. The Machinery of Freedom: Guide to a Radical Capitalism. New York: Harper and Row, 1973.A consequence-based case for private law.
  5. Miller, David. Anarchism. London: J. M. Dent, 1984.A philosophical survey of anarchist ideas.