Politics / Anarchist

Anarchism

The view that society can and should be organised without a state or unjust rulers

Began
1840, the usual tree date, when Pierre-Joseph Proudhon published What Is Property? Anarchism as an organised movement emerged later, in the 1860s and 1870s.Scholars: Anarchist ideas are often traced to earlier thinkers such as William Godwin (1793), and some writers find anarchist themes in ancient Daoism or in religious dissenting movements. Most historians date anarchism as an organised movement to the 1860s and 1870s, after Proudhon and within the First International.
Where
Western Europe, especially France, then Russia, Spain, Italy and the Americas
Key figures
No single founder. Key early figures were Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, Mikhail Bakunin and Peter Kropotkin
Key works
What Is Property? (Proudhon); God and the State (Bakunin); The Conquest of Bread (Kropotkin); Mutual Aid (Kropotkin); An Enquiry Concerning Political Justice (Godwin)

At a glance

Anarchism is the belief that people can live together without a state, and that rule by force or by unjust hierarchy is not needed. Anarchists generally argue that order can come from free agreement, cooperation and voluntary groups. Different currents disagree about how this would work.

Proudhon called himself an anarchist in 1840, having also called himself a socialist. Organised anarchism took shape in the 1860s and 1870s. In the First International, a workers' association founded in 1864, anti-authoritarian socialists around Bakunin clashed with Marx and his supporters over political action, centralised organisation and strategy. In 1872 the Hague Congress expelled Bakunin and James Guillaume, and the anti-authoritarians went on to form the separate St Imier International.

Anarchism is distinctive because it questions all concentrated power, not only that of kings or capitalists. It has many branches, including individualist anarchism, anarcho-communism and anarcho-syndicalism. They disagree about property, markets and how to organise work.

Key concepts

Anarchy
From the Greek for 'without a ruler'. Anarchists use it to mean order without government, not disorder.
Hierarchy
A system in which some people hold power over others. Anarchists ask whether each hierarchy can justify itself, and reject those that cannot.
Mutual aid
Voluntary cooperation for shared benefit. Kropotkin argued that it is a major factor in the survival of both animals and humans.
Direct action
Pursuing a goal directly, without relying on representatives or the state, for example through strikes or by building cooperatives.
Federalism
A way of organising in which small self-governing groups join together by free agreement, with decisions made from the bottom up.
Prefiguration
The idea that the means used should reflect the society wanted, so a free society is built using free and equal methods.

Core positions

  • The state is a form of organised coercion and is not necessary for social order.
  • Authority must justify itself, and illegitimate hierarchy should be challenged and removed.
  • Freedom and equality support each other and should be pursued together.
  • People are able to cooperate and govern themselves through voluntary association.
  • The means used should match the ends sought, so a free society cannot be reached by building a new ruling power.
  • Most anarchists oppose both state power and the economic power of large private owners, though individualist anarchists stress property and personal liberty more.

Policies and positions

The economy

Most anarchists favour workers' control, cooperatives or common ownership in place of wage labour under bosses. Anarcho-communists want goods shared according to need. Individualist anarchists stress personal liberty and voluntary exchange, but many of them also reject capitalist property relations.

The state and law

Anarchists want the state replaced by voluntary arrangements, but they do not share one model. Collectivist and communist anarchists often propose local councils and federations, while mutualist, individualist and other currents propose different arrangements. Disputes might be settled by mediation, community rules or voluntary associations, not by a central government.

Rights and education

Anarchists defend free speech, free association and personal autonomy. Many support schools that rely on cooperation and curiosity, not on compulsion.

Foreign affairs

Anarchists commonly oppose nationalism and militarism and favour international solidarity among ordinary people. They have debated defensive war, national liberation struggles and joining anti-fascist armies, and have not agreed on these questions.

Branches

  • Individualist anarchismA family of anarchist views that put the individual first and reject rule by the state
  • Anarcho-communismA stateless society with shared property, built on free cooperation and distribution by need
  • Anarcho-syndicalismRevolutionary trade unionism that aims to replace the state and bosses with worker-run unions

Thinkers and leaders

  • Pierre-Joseph Proudhon 1809–1865French writer who first called himself an anarchist and argued for mutual exchange and federation.
  • William Godwin 1756–1836English philosopher whose Enquiry Concerning Political Justice (1793) is often seen as an early statement of anarchist ideas.
  • Mikhail Bakunin 1814–1876Russian revolutionary who opposed both state and church and clashed with Karl Marx in the First International.
  • Peter Kropotkin 1842–1921Russian geographer and thinker who developed anarcho-communism and wrote on mutual aid.
  • Emma Goldman 1869–1940Lithuanian-born writer and speaker who spread anarchist ideas in the United States and Europe.
  • Max Stirner 1806–1856German philosopher whose book The Ego and Its Own influenced individualist anarchism.

Main criticisms

Would society fall into disorder?

Critics argue that without a state, no body could stop violence or settle disputes, and the strong would dominate the weak. Anarchists reply that order can come from voluntary cooperation, community norms and federated bodies, and that states themselves often cause great violence.

Can it work at large scale?

Critics say that voluntary, local organisation cannot manage complex economies, large cities or infrastructure. Defenders point to federations, cooperatives and episodes such as parts of Spain in 1936 to 1939, while accepting that these were short-lived and fought under wartime pressure.

Would power simply return?

Critics argue that new informal leaders or armed groups would take control, so a state would reappear. Anarchists answer that this is why they stress decentralisation, rotating roles and constant checks on authority.

Is human nature suited to it?

Critics say people are too self-interested or too prone to conflict for a stateless society. Anarchists reply that people behave in both cooperative and selfish ways depending on institutions, and that the state does not remove selfishness but may reward it.

Sources

  1. Marshall, Peter. "Anarchism." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.Overview of anarchist ideas and history.
  2. Jun, Nathan. "Anarchism." In Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Philosophical overview of anarchist thought.
  3. Marshall, Peter H. Demanding the Impossible: A History of Anarchism. London: HarperCollins, 1992.A wide-ranging history from ancient times to the twentieth century.
  4. Graham, Robert, ed. Anarchism: A Documentary History of Libertarian Ideas, Volume One: From Anarchy to Anarchism (300 CE to 1939). Montreal: Black Rose Books, 2005.Collected primary texts from 300 CE to 1939.
  5. Kropotkin, Peter. Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution. London: William Heinemann, 1902.A founding text on cooperation in nature and society.