Politics / Anarchist

Anarcho-communism

A stateless society with shared property, built on free cooperation and distribution by need

Began
1870sScholars: Historians distinguish several stages. The word anarchism for a political movement dates from the mid-1800s. Carlo Cafiero, Errico Malatesta and others in Italy adopted communist anarchism in the late 1870s. Peter Kropotkin, who joined the movement in the 1870s, set out his fuller case in the 1880s and 1890s.
Where
Europe, mainly Italy, Switzerland, France and Russia, later Spain, Ukraine and Latin America
Key figures
No single founder. Early figures include Carlo Cafiero, Élisée Reclus, Errico Malatesta and Peter Kropotkin
Key works
The Conquest of Bread; Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution; Fields, Factories and Workshops; Anarchy and Communism; God and the State

At a glance

Anarcho-communism is a form of anarchism. It aims for a society with no state, no police force or government, and no private ownership of land, factories or other means of production. Goods and work would be shared through voluntary groups.

It developed in the 1870s among anti-authoritarian socialists, especially in Italy, after the First International, a workers' association, split in 1872. Followers of Mikhail Bakunin had favoured collective ownership but pay based on work done. Carlo Cafiero and others, and later Peter Kropotkin, argued that distribution should follow need instead.

Its supporters often use the slogan 'from each according to ability, to each according to needs'. The phrase comes from Karl Marx's 1875 Critique of the Gotha Programme, and anarchist communists later adopted it. They believe that people can organise themselves through free agreement, local councils, unions and federations, without rulers.

Key concepts

Anarchism
The view that society can and should run without rulers or compulsory government.
Mutual aid
Kropotkin's term for reciprocal cooperation and assistance, which he argued was an important factor in the evolution and social life of animals and humans, alongside competition.
Libertarian communism
Common ownership and sharing of goods, organised from below through voluntary association and shared decisions, not by a state.
Federation
A network of self-governing groups, such as communes and unions, that link up by agreement.
Propaganda of the deed
The idea, held by some anarchists in the 1870s to 1890s, that bold acts, sometimes violent, could inspire revolt.
Social revolution
A fundamental transformation of society's property and power relations, which anarchists hoped would abolish the state and capitalism.

Core positions

  • The state is a tool of domination and should be abolished, not captured.
  • Land, factories and other productive resources should be owned in common.
  • Goods should be shared by need, without wages or money, according to most advocates.
  • Society should be organised by voluntary federations of communes, workplaces and unions.
  • Means and ends should match, so a free society cannot be built by a new ruling authority.
  • Humans have strong capacities for cooperation, Kropotkin argued, and these grow when coercion and inequality are removed.

Policies and positions

Economy

Production would be run by workers and communities, and goods given out freely or by agreed need. Kropotkin argued that modern industry and farming could supply everyone's basic needs.

The state and law

Governments, armies, prisons and police would be abolished. Disputes would be settled by community agreement and local bodies.

Work

Anarcho-communists wanted to blend manual and intellectual work and to make jobs more varied. Unpleasant work would be reduced or shared, and communities would coordinate who does what by agreement.

Foreign affairs

They generally oppose war between states and favour international solidarity among workers and free federations across borders. Anarchists have disagreed about how to relate to national liberation movements.

Thinkers and leaders

  • Peter Kropotkin 1842–1921Russian geographer and one of the most influential theorists of anarcho-communism, author of The Conquest of Bread.
  • Carlo Cafiero 1846–1892Italian anarchist who helped establish the communist case within the Italian anarchist movement in the 1870s.
  • Élisée Reclus 1830–1905French geographer who wrote and campaigned for anarchist communism.
  • Errico Malatesta 1853–1932Italian organiser and writer who spread anarcho-communist ideas in Europe, Argentina and elsewhere.
  • Emma Goldman 1869–1940Lithuanian-born American anarchist speaker and writer who promoted anarchist communism.

Main criticisms

Is it realistic without coercion?

Critics argue that without a state, some people would shirk work or take more than their share, and that someone would have to enforce the rules. Defenders reply that small, voluntary groups use social pressure and shared purpose, and that Kropotkin found much cooperation in nature and history.

Can large economies be run this way?

Critics say that without prices or markets, a complex economy cannot coordinate production efficiently. Defenders propose decentralised planning, mutual adjustment between councils and communal accounting of needs and resources. Critics dispute whether these methods could work at scale.

Does abolishing the state leave power vacuums?

Critics say new elites or armed groups would fill the gap, as happened in revolutions. Defenders argue that spreading power through federations resists this. They point to the Spanish revolution of 1936, where anarchist collectivisation was curtailed in 1937 by conflict with other Republican forces, and the Republic itself was defeated in 1939.

Violence and means

Critics note that some anarchists in the 1880s to 1900s carried out assassinations and bombings. Defenders reply that most anarcho-communists did not, and that many, including Malatesta later in life, stressed organising and mass movements over terror.

Sources

  1. Encyclopaedia Britannica editors. "Anarchism." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.General overview of anarchism and its branches.
  2. McLaughlin, Paul. "Anarchism." In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Philosophical survey of anarchist thought.
  3. Kropotkin, Peter. The Conquest of Bread. London: Chapman and Hall, 1906.A major work of anarchist communism, first published in French in 1892.
  4. Kinna, Ruth. Anarchism: A Beginner's Guide. Oxford: Oneworld, 2005.Accessible introduction.
  5. Graham, Robert, ed. Anarchism: A Documentary History of Libertarian Ideas, Volume One: From Anarchy to Anarchism (300 CE to 1939). Montreal: Black Rose Books, 2004.Collected texts including Cafiero, Kropotkin and Malatesta.