Philosophy / 19th century to today

Post-structuralism

A loose label for French-influenced thinkers who question fixed meanings, stable identities and final truths

Began
1960sScholars: Debated. The label was coined later, mainly in English-language scholarship, from the 1970s. Most of the thinkers grouped under it did not call themselves post-structuralists, and some rejected the label.
Where
France, especially Paris, later spreading to the United States and elsewhere
Key figures
No single founder. Thinkers often grouped under the label include Jacques Derrida, Michel Foucault, Gilles Deleuze, Julia Kristeva and, in his later work, Roland Barthes.
Key works
Of Grammatology (Derrida, 1967); Writing and Difference (Derrida, 1967); The Order of Things (Foucault, 1966); Discipline and Punish (Foucault, 1975); Difference and Repetition (Deleuze, 1968)

At a glance

Post-structuralism is a label for a set of ways of thinking about language, meaning, power and the self. The thinkers grouped under it worked mainly in France from the 1960s. They asked how meanings are made, and why they so often seem fixed when they are not.

The label is retrospective and mostly English-language, and it covers writers with very different aims. Many of them disliked being grouped together. They drew on several sources, including Nietzsche, Heidegger, Freud, Marx, Saussure and, for Derrida, the phenomenology of Husserl.

They are often described as reacting to structuralism, which looked for stable underlying systems such as the rules of a language or the patterns in a myth. Most did not simply reject structures. They studied how structures are unstable, open to change and shaped by history and power. What many share is suspicion of final answers and fixed categories.

Key concepts

Différance
Derrida's coined word for the idea that meaning comes from differences between signs and is always deferred, never fully present.
Deconstruction
A way of reading that shows how a text's own oppositions, such as speech and writing, depend on each other and can unsettle each other.
Discourse
In Foucault's use, a historically specific system of statements and rules that shapes what objects and subjects can exist in a field and what can be said about them.
Power/knowledge
Foucault's phrase for the idea that power relations help produce knowledge, while knowledge works within power relations and can reinforce them.
Decentred subject
The view, held in different forms by different thinkers, that the self is not a sovereign, unified source of meaning.
Intertextuality
A term popularised by Kristeva for the idea that every text is built from, and responds to, other texts.

Core ideas

  • Meaning is not simply fixed by an author's intention or a closed structure, and many of these thinkers stress that it is produced through language and open to reinterpretation, though they differ on how language relates to reality.
  • Binary oppositions, such as nature and culture or reason and emotion, are not neutral and often rank one side above the other.
  • Knowledge and power are closely linked in Foucault's work, so what counts as truth is shaped by institutions and history.
  • Several thinkers question the idea of a stable, self-transparent subject, but Derrida, Deleuze and Foucault treat subjectivity in quite different ways.
  • Many of these thinkers are wary of totalising theories of history or human nature, a theme Lyotard made central in his separate account of the postmodern condition.
  • Careful reading and historical study can reveal the assumptions that make categories seem natural.

Key arguments

The sign has no final anchor

Following Saussure, signs gain meaning from their differences from other signs. Derrida argued that this means no sign ever delivers a final, self-standing meaning, since each points on to others.

The Panopticon

Foucault used Jeremy Bentham's prison design, where inmates may be watched at any time, as a picture of modern discipline. People come to police themselves, so power works through habits and institutions as well as through force.

The death of the author

Barthes argued in 1967 that a text's meaning should not be settled by asking what the author intended. Meaning arises in the act of reading.

Genealogy

Foucault, drawing on Nietzsche, traced how ideas such as madness, criminality and sexuality took their present forms. The aim was to show that they have histories and were not always as they appear now.

Philosophers

  • Jacques Derrida 1930–2004Developed deconstruction and the idea of différance, beginning from a close reading of Husserl and the philosophical tradition.
  • Michel Foucault 1926–1984Studied how institutions, discourses and power shape knowledge and the modern self.
  • Gilles Deleuze 1925–1995Wrote on difference, multiplicity and becoming, and worked with Félix Guattari on Capitalism and Schizophrenia.
  • Roland Barthes 1915–1980A varied critic whose early work was structuralist and whose later essays, such as The Death of the Author, are often grouped with post-structuralism.
  • Julia Kristeva born 1941Widely credited with popularising the term intertextuality, and often, though retrospectively, classed as post-structuralist.
  • Jean-François Lyotard 1924–1998Described the postmodern condition as distrust of grand narratives, and is often linked to post-structuralism.

Main criticisms

Does it end in relativism?

Critics say that if meaning and truth are shaped by power and language, there is no way to tell better claims from worse. Defenders reply that criticising universal foundations is not the same as saying all interpretations are equally good, and that careful reading and historical work still have standards.

Is it obscure?

Some critics, including analytic philosophers, argue that the writing is needlessly difficult and hides weak arguments. Defenders reply that the arguments are technically demanding and can be reconstructed, and that the standards of clarity used to judge them are themselves open to question.

Can it support political action?

Critics such as Jürgen Habermas argued that undermining universal norms leaves no basis for criticism or justice. Defenders reply that exposing how norms operate is itself critical, and that Foucault and others took part in concrete causes.

Is the self-reference a problem?

Critics say that arguing that all claims are unstable undermines the theory's own claims. Defenders reply that deconstruction openly works within the concepts it questions and does not claim a place outside them.

Sources

  1. Williams, James. "Poststructuralism." In Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Overview of the movement and its main thinkers.
  2. Gutting, Gary, and Johanna Oksala. "Michel Foucault." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Foucault's work on power, knowledge and the subject.
  3. Derrida, Jacques. Of Grammatology. Translated by Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1976.A founding text of deconstruction.
  4. Foucault, Michel. Discipline and Punish. Translated by Alan Sheridan. New York: Pantheon Books, 1977.A study of the rise of modern discipline and surveillance.