Philosophy / 19th century to today

Structuralism

A method that studies meaning as a product of systems of relations, not of things on their own

Began
Usually traced to Saussure's linguistics (lectures 1907 to 1911, published 1916). The named movement developed mainly from the 1940s.Scholars: Saussure did not use the word structuralism. His book was compiled from student notes after his death. Historians usually date structuralism as a wider movement to the 1940s to 1960s, especially in France.
Where
Switzerland and France, later across Europe and North America
Key figures
No single founder. Ferdinand de Saussure supplied foundational ideas in linguistics. Roman Jakobson and Claude Lévi-Strauss carried structural methods into other fields.
Key works
Course in General Linguistics; Structural Anthropology; The Elementary Structures of Kinship; Mythologies; Elements of Semiology

At a glance

Structuralism is better described as an interdisciplinary method or movement than as a single school with one doctrine. Its approaches in linguistics, anthropology, semiotics and literary theory are related but not fully unified. They share the idea that things such as words, rituals and stories get much of their meaning from how they relate to other items in a system.

It grew out of the work of the Swiss linguist Ferdinand de Saussure, who argued that language should be studied as a system of signs. Later thinkers applied similar ideas to myths, kinship, literature, fashion and the mind.

What makes it distinctive is its focus on structure. A structuralist often asks what rules make a pattern possible, not only what one speaker or author intended. Many structuralists study a system at one moment as a method, though this does not require denying that history or individual people matter.

Key concepts

Sign
In Saussure's account, a sign joins a signifier (a sound or mark) with a signified (a concept).
Arbitrariness
There is no natural reason why a particular sound goes with a particular concept, so the link is unmotivated and established by a community over time.
Langue and parole
Langue is the shared system of a language, and parole is the individual acts of speaking that use it.
Value
A sign's value depends on its place among other signs, as the sounds of 'cat' and 'bat' are distinguished by contrast and as words in a language limit one another's meanings.
Synchronic and diachronic
A synchronic study looks at a system at one moment, and a diachronic study follows its change over time.
Binary opposition
A pair of contrasting terms, such as raw and cooked, that some structuralists see as organising meaning in a culture.

Core ideas

  • Meaning depends heavily on relations within a system, not only on things in themselves.
  • Language is a system of signs, each linking a signifier to a signified concept, and that link is unmotivated by nature.
  • Individual acts of speech can be understood in light of the underlying rules that make them possible.
  • Some structuralists, notably Lévi-Strauss, hold that myth, kinship and food can be studied in ways modelled on language.
  • A system can be analysed at a single moment as a deliberate method, with change studied separately.
  • Many structuralists hold that the structures are largely unconscious, so people follow rules they cannot state.

Key arguments

The arbitrary sign

Different languages use different sounds for the same idea, such as 'dog', 'chien' and 'Hund'. Saussure took this to show that the link between sound and concept is not set by nature. It is established socially, not chosen by individual speakers.

Value within a system

Saussure argued that a sign's identity depends on its relations to other signs. In his well-known phrase, in language there are only differences without positive terms. He meant that value comes from position in the system, so the system matters as much as the single items.

The structure of myth

Lévi-Strauss argued that myths from many cultures can be compared as sets of related elements. He looked for repeated contrasts, such as nature and culture, beneath the varied stories.

Myth in everyday life

Roland Barthes read advertisements, wrestling and food as sign systems. He argued they carry cultural messages that seem natural.

Philosophers

  • Ferdinand de Saussure 1857–1913Swiss linguist whose lectures, published as Course in General Linguistics, gave structuralism its foundational ideas, though he did not use the term.
  • Roman Jakobson 1896–1982Russian-born linguist who linked the Prague school of linguistics to later structuralism.
  • Claude Lévi-Strauss 1908–2009French anthropologist who applied structural analysis to kinship and myth.
  • Roland Barthes 1915–1980French critic who used sign theory to study popular culture and literature.
  • Jean Piaget 1896–1980Swiss psychologist linked to structuralism in psychology, who described child development as changing mental structures.

Main criticisms

Is history left out?

Critics say that focusing on systems makes change and individual agency hard to explain. Defenders reply that the synchronic method was a deliberate choice of focus, and that studying structure can sit alongside studying change.

Is meaning ever fully stable?

Jacques Derrida, often but not always labelled post-structuralist, argued that claims to fixed or fully stable meaning fail, because signs always point to other signs. Structuralists could answer that stable patterns can still be described, even if systems are not perfectly closed.

Are the patterns found or imposed?

Some critics say the binary oppositions in Lévi-Strauss's work reflect the analyst's choices more than the material. Defenders reply that the method is tested by whether it explains many cases with few principles.

Sources

  1. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. "Structuralism in the Philosophy of Mathematics." Edited by Edward N. Zalta.Covers a separate use of the term, so read alongside the linguistic sources below.
  2. Saussure, Ferdinand de. Course in General Linguistics. Translated by Roy Harris. London: Duckworth, 1983.The founding text, compiled from student notes.
  3. Culler, Jonathan. Structuralist Poetics. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1975.A study of structuralism in literary theory.
  4. Lévi-Strauss, Claude. Structural Anthropology. Translated by Claire Jacobson and Brooke Grundfest Schoepf. New York: Basic Books, 1963 (French original 1958; other printings 1968).Key essays applying structural method to culture.