Philosophy / 19th century to today

Phenomenology

The careful study of how things appear in conscious experience

Began
Conventionally dated to 1900 to 1901, with Edmund Husserl's Logical InvestigationsScholars: Historians note earlier roots, including Franz Brentano's descriptive psychology, Carl Stumpf's work and earlier uses of the word "phenomenology"; the 1900 date is a convenient milestone
Where
Germany. Göttingen was an early centre of Husserl's circle, Munich had an important independent circle, and Freiburg became central after Husserl moved there in 1916. The movement later spread across Europe and beyond
Key figures
Edmund Husserl, with early circles of students at Göttingen and Munich
Key works
Logical Investigations; Ideas: General Introduction to Pure Phenomenology; Cartesian Meditations; Being and Time; Phenomenology of Perception

At a glance

Phenomenology is a school of philosophy that studies experience as it is lived. Its followers say we should begin by describing carefully how things show up to us. Questions about what things are made of, or whether our beliefs about them are true, are often postponed for method's sake, not rejected.

It is usually said to begin with the German philosopher Edmund Husserl, whose Logical Investigations appeared in 1900 and 1901. Husserl wanted philosophy to be a rigorous discipline with its own method, not a set of guesses. His students and followers took the method in many directions.

What makes it distinctive is its focus on the structures of experience, such as perception, memory, time, other people and the body. Phenomenologists hold that these can be described with disciplined reflection. They disagree among themselves about how that reflection works, how far its results are shared by everyone, and how they can be checked.

Key concepts

Intentionality
The idea that conscious states are directed at something, as when we see, fear, remember or desire something; thinkers differ on how this applies to every kind of state.
Epoché
In Husserl, the suspension of the natural attitude, our ordinary taken-for-granted belief that the world exists, so that we can study how the world is given in experience.
Phenomenological reduction
In Husserl, a shift from the world taken for granted to the experiences in which it has meaning for us, leading him to the study of how consciousness constitutes that meaning; later phenomenologists understood this differently.
Lifeworld
The everyday world of shared experience, which Husserl saw as the pre-theoretical setting in which scientific work is grounded.
Noema and noesis
In Husserl's later work, the noema is the object as it is meant in an experience, and the noesis is the mental act that means it.
Being-in-the-world
Heidegger's phrase for the idea that humans are always already involved in a world of tasks and meanings, not detached observers.

Core ideas

  • Philosophy should begin by describing experience as it actually appears, without importing theories.
  • Conscious states are intentional, meaning they are directed at something.
  • The method of epoché asks us to suspend our ordinary belief in the world's existence in order to see how things are given in experience.
  • Experience has structures, such as time, space, the body and other people, which phenomenologists try to describe, though they disagree about how fixed or theory-free these are.
  • The lifeworld is the pre-theoretical horizon of everyday experience in which scientific practices are grounded.
  • Later phenomenologists stressed that understanding is shaped by the body, language, history and our being with others.

Key arguments

Back to the things themselves

This was Husserl's famous maxim, taken up by many later phenomenologists. It means that philosophers should attend to what shows up in experience rather than argue from abstract systems.

Bracketing the natural attitude

Normally we assume the world simply exists out there. Husserl asked us to put that assumption in brackets, not to deny it, so that we can study how the world is given to us.

The experience of time

Husserl described hearing a melody. We hear each note while still holding the one just past and expecting the next, so the present has a structure that includes past and future.

The tool in use

Heidegger argued that we first meet a hammer not as an object we stare at but as something we use. Its meaning shows up in the activity of working.

Philosophers

  • Edmund Husserl 1859–1938German philosopher who founded phenomenology and developed its method.
  • Martin Heidegger 1889–1976Husserl's student, who turned phenomenology toward the question of the meaning of being, in Being and Time.
  • Maurice Merleau-Ponty 1908–1961French philosopher who stressed the lived body as the centre of perception.
  • Jean-Paul Sartre 1905–1980French philosopher who used phenomenological description in his existentialist works, such as Being and Nothingness.
  • Edith Stein 1891–1942Husserl's research assistant, who wrote on empathy and community, and later on the human person and Christian philosophy.
  • Simone de Beauvoir 1908–1986French thinker who drew on phenomenological and existentialist ideas, especially about the lived body, in The Second Sex.

Main criticisms

Is it just private self-report?

Critics say that describing one's own experience is subjective and cannot settle disputes, and that brain science and behavioural study are a better guide. Phenomenologists reply that their descriptions are not private introspective reports but aim at general structures that others can test against their own experience. Many also argue that science itself rests on experience, though this claim is itself debated.

Can we really set the world aside?

Some thinkers, including later phenomenologists such as Merleau-Ponty, doubted that a complete reduction is possible, because we are always situated in a body, a language and a history. Defenders of the method reply that it is a discipline of attention, and that even partial bracketing reveals useful structures.

Is it too obscure?

Some critics, including some analytic philosophers, have complained that phenomenological writing is hard to follow and hard to test. Phenomenologists answer that new ways of describing experience need new vocabulary, and that clear work exists in the tradition, including in recent dialogue between phenomenology and analytic philosophy and cognitive science.

Sources

  1. Smith, David Woodruff. "Phenomenology." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of the history, method and main themes.
  2. Moran, Dermot. Introduction to Phenomenology. London: Routledge, 1999.Detailed survey from Husserl to Merleau-Ponty.
  3. Zahavi, Dan. Husserl's Legacy: Phenomenology, Metaphysics, and Transcendental Philosophy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018.Discusses Husserl's ideas and their later development.
  4. Husserl, Edmund. Logical Investigations. Translated by J. N. Findlay. London: Routledge, 1970.