Politics / Monarchy and republic
Republicanism
A tradition of public, self-governing states that aims to limit arbitrary power and serve the common good
- Began
- Ancient roots; Machiavelli, c. 1513Scholars: Practised in the Roman Republic, traditionally founded 509 BC. Renaissance republican thought, including Machiavelli's Discourses, is one major later stage. The Discourses are commonly dated to roughly 1513 to 1519 and were published in 1531, though the exact composition is debated
- Where
- Mediterranean world (Rome, Greek city-states), later Renaissance Italy, the Dutch Republic, England, North America and France
- Key figures
- No single founder. Key early figures include Polybius and Cicero, and later Machiavelli and Harrington
- Key works
- The Histories (Polybius); On the Republic (Cicero); Discourses on Livy (Machiavelli); The Commonwealth of Oceana (Harrington); The Spirit of the Laws (Montesquieu)
At a glance
Republicanism is the idea that a state is a shared public matter, not the property of a ruler. In its ideal form, citizens take part in government, directly or through representatives, and power serves the common good. Its central worry is domination: being at the mercy of someone else's will, even a kind one.
Its main ancient root is Rome, which called its system the res publica, Latin for the public affair or commonwealth. Roman government mixed elements of rule by one, a few and many, and in practice it was often dominated by an elite. Some Greek city-states also shaped later republican thought, though Greek regimes varied widely. Writers such as Polybius and Cicero praised mixed government, and Renaissance thinkers, especially Machiavelli, drew on them. Italian city-states such as Florence and Venice were important settings for these ideas.
Historically, many republics were narrow. Women, enslaved people and noncitizens were excluded, and some republics were run by small groups of wealthy families. Republican ideas shaped the Dutch Republic, the English Commonwealth of the 1650s, the American founding and the French Revolution. Republicanism says little about economics, so republicans have held many views on property and trade. Its branches include Jacobinism.
Key concepts
- Res publica
- A Latin phrase meaning the public affair or commonwealth, the shared business of a political community, which in Rome was governed by a mix of elite and popular institutions.
- Civic virtue
- The willingness of citizens to put the common good ahead of narrow private interest.
- Freedom as non-domination
- The idea, especially associated with neo-Roman and contemporary republicans such as Pettit, that a person is free only when no one holds arbitrary power over them, even if that power is not used.
- Mixed government
- A classical idea of a constitution that combines rule by one, by a few and by the many, often so as to give stability and some balance, and which differs from modern separation of powers.
- Rule of law
- The principle that laws bind everyone, including officials, and that no one rules by mere will.
- Corruption
- In republican writing, the decay of public spirit, when private gain or factions overwhelm the common good.
Core positions
- Republicans typically hold that political power is a public trust, though classical, civic, democratic and neo-Roman republicans understand this in different ways.
- Many republicans hold that freedom means not being subject to arbitrary power, which requires laws that are themselves accountable and fair.
- Citizens share in government, through voting, office-holding or serving on juries and in defence, though who counts as a citizen has varied greatly.
- Power should be divided or balanced so that no person or group can dominate.
- A free state depends on the habits and character of its citizens, as well as on its laws.
- Hereditary monarchy is usually rejected, though some republicans have accepted limited monarchy.
Policies and positions
Constitutions
Republicans favour written or settled rules that split power among branches, such as assemblies, magistrates and courts. Offices are often held for fixed terms.
Citizen participation
Many republican thinkers value public service, civic education and citizen militias. They see taking part in public life as part of freedom, not only a duty.
Property and economy
Republicans disagree. Some, like Harrington, held that widespread landholding supports independence. Others accepted commerce and large inequalities.
Foreign affairs
Some republics expanded by conquest, as Rome did. Others, like Venice and the Dutch Republic, stressed trade and defence. Thinkers have argued over whether size weakens liberty.
Branches
- JacobinismThe radical republican politics of the French Revolution, rule by the people through a strong state
Thinkers and leaders
- Polybius c. 200–c. 118 BCGreek historian who explained Rome's success through its mixed constitution.
- Cicero 106–43 BCRoman statesman and writer who defined the commonwealth as the affair of the people.
- Niccolò Machiavelli 1469–1527Florentine thinker whose Discourses on Livy defended a free, self-governing republic.
- James Harrington 1611–1677English writer whose Oceana proposed a republic balanced by land ownership.
- Montesquieu 1689–1755French thinker who admired Roman virtue and argued for the separation of powers.
- James Madison 1751–1836American founder who helped design the United States Constitution and defended a large republic.
Main criticisms
Is virtue too much to ask?
Critics say republics need a level of public spirit that ordinary people rarely show, and that demanding it can lead to pressure to conform. Defenders reply that good institutions can channel self-interest toward public ends, so heroic virtue is not required.
Can republics be large?
Montesquieu and others argued that republics work only in small states where citizens know each other. Defenders such as Madison replied that a large republic with representation and divided powers can better resist factions.
Does appeal to the public good risk tyranny?
Critics point to the Jacobin Terror in France, when appeals to virtue and the public good were used to justify executions, and note that some republicans have defended centralized or majoritarian power. Defenders reply that other republicans, such as Madison, designed institutions precisely to limit such concentration, so the Terror shows one strand of republicanism rather than all of it. Critics answer that the risk lies in the emphasis on virtue and unity itself.
Is it different from liberalism?
Some critics argue that republican stress on civic duty and shared purpose can press on private life. Liberals have their own accounts of freedom, including participation and protection from arbitrary power, and many hold that the two traditions overlap. Republicans answer that their focus on non-domination and shared institutions adds something distinct, and that it protects individuals too.
Sources
- Lovett, Frank, and Philip Pettit. "Republicanism." In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of republican theory, mainly non-domination.
- Pettit, Philip. Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997.Influential modern account of freedom as non-domination.
- Skinner, Quentin. Liberty before Liberalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998.History of the neo-Roman idea of liberty.
- Pocock, J. G. A. The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic Republican Tradition. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1975.Traces republican ideas from Florence to America.
- Machiavelli, Niccolò. Discourses on Livy. Translated by Harvey C. Mansfield and Nathan Tarcov. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996.