Politics / Monarchy and republic
Jacobinism
The radical republican politics of the French Revolution, rule by the people through a strong state
- Began
- 1789Scholars: The club began in 1789 as a society of Breton deputies at Versailles, then in Paris became the Society of the Friends of the Constitution, popularly called the Jacobin Club. Historians usually place the radical, republican phase of Jacobin influence in 1792 to 1794. Describing the Convention and Committee of Public Safety as a simple Jacobin government is a contested shorthand.
- Where
- France, mainly Paris, with affiliated clubs across the country
- Key figures
- No single founder. Maximilien Robespierre became its best-known leader.
- Key works
- Constitution of 1793 (never put into effect); Robespierre, Report on the Principles of Political Morality (1794); Law of Suspects (1793)
At a glance
Jacobinism was the politics associated with the Jacobin Club, a political society that met in Paris during the French Revolution, and with the radical republicans who rose to power through it. The club, the Montagnard group in the National Convention and Robespierre's allies overlapped but were not the same thing. Early members mostly backed a constitutional monarchy. The club became strongly republican after the fall of the monarchy in 1792.
The club began in 1789 and drew on Enlightenment ideas, including natural rights and Rousseau's idea of the general will. At first it was one of many debating clubs. In 1793 and 1794 the Committee of Public Safety, a collective executive body answerable to the Convention, led the government. Robespierre was its most influential member but did not control it alone. Its power also depended on other political groups and on popular movements in Paris.
Many Jacobins held that a virtuous republic needed a strong, unified state, especially in wartime. Some Jacobins and revolutionary authorities defended the Terror of 1793 to 1794 as an emergency measure. Others disagreed or were themselves among its victims. The Jacobin phase ended with Robespierre's fall in July 1794, and the club was closed in November 1794. The word later came to describe centralising, radical republicanism.
Key concepts
- Popular sovereignty
- The idea that political authority belongs to the people as a whole, not to a king or a church.
- General will
- Rousseau's idea of what the community as a whole wants for the common good, which many Jacobins held should outweigh private interests.
- Republic of virtue
- Robespierre's ideal of a state whose citizens put the public good before their own gain.
- The Terror
- The period of 1793 to 1794 when the government used special courts and executions against alleged enemies of the Revolution.
- One and indivisible
- The demand that France be a single united republic, opposed to federalism and regional separation.
- Sans-culottes
- Urban artisans, shopkeepers and other lower and middling Parisians who were active revolutionaries, and whose relations with the Jacobins were a mix of alliance and conflict.
Core positions
- Sovereignty belongs to the people, and in its radical phase the movement called for abolishing the monarchy and the old privileged orders.
- All citizens should be equal before the law, though Jacobin views on who counted as a citizen and who could vote changed over time, and the Constitution of 1793, which offered wide male suffrage, was never applied.
- The republic should be united and strongly directed from the centre, through the Convention, its committees and representatives sent to the provinces, with local authorities playing changing and disputed roles.
- Many Jacobin leaders held that in an emergency the state may use force and set aside normal legal limits to defend the Revolution.
- Robespierre and Saint-Just argued that citizens owe the republic civic duty and virtue, which the state could promote through education and public festivals.
- Many Jacobins held that property rights should serve the common good, and that the poor should have a claim to subsistence.
Policies and positions
Economy
In 1793 and 1794 the government set maximum prices for grain and other goods and requisitioned food for the cities and armies. Jacobin leaders did not aim to abolish private property.
The state
The Committee of Public Safety held major executive power but remained formally accountable to the National Convention. It sent representatives on mission to the provinces, and there was much conflict over central and local authority. Local resistance was often treated as a threat to the nation.
Rights and law
The Constitution of 1793 promised wide male suffrage and a right to public assistance, but it was never put into effect. The Law of Suspects and the Revolutionary Tribunal limited the rights of the accused.
War and religion
Jacobin leaders defended the revolutionary war against European monarchies and mass conscription. Some backed campaigns of de-Christianisation. Robespierre opposed atheism and the most radical of these campaigns, and promoted a state-backed civic cult of the Supreme Being.
Thinkers and leaders
- Maximilien Robespierre 1758–1794Lawyer and leading Jacobin who became the most influential member of the Committee of Public Safety until his arrest and execution.
- Louis Antoine de Saint-Just 1767–1794Young Jacobin ally of Robespierre who argued for the Terror and for republican virtue.
- Georges Danton 1759–1794Revolutionary orator and early Jacobin leader, executed after falling out with Robespierre.
- Jean-Paul Marat 1743–1793Journalist and Jacobin ally whose newspaper called for harsh action against the Revolution's enemies, killed by Charlotte Corday.
- Gracchus Babeuf 1760–1797Radical egalitarian shaped by the Revolution, though critical of the Jacobin government, who plotted for common ownership of goods and is seen as an early communist thinker.
Main criticisms
The Terror
Critics argue that the Terror, carried out under the Convention and its committees, brought many executions and deaths. Historians usually count about 16,000 to 17,000 formal death sentences, with many more deaths in prisons and in the civil war in the Vendée, and these figures measure different things. Defenders at the time argued that France faced foreign invasion and internal revolt, and that the emergency justified harsh measures. Historians debate how war, rebellion, institutional breakdown, political culture and revolutionary ideology combined to produce it.
Liberty versus the general will
Critics say that claiming to speak for the whole people allowed Jacobins to silence opponents and suppress dissent. Defenders replied that liberty could only be secured by a united republic, and that rights needed protection against aristocratic and foreign enemies.
Centralisation
Opponents, including the Girondins, argued that a Paris-dominated state overrode the provinces and local self-government. Jacobins answered that a divided France could not survive war and would let old privileges return.
Sources
- "Jacobin." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.Overview of the club and its role in the Revolution.
- Doyle, William. The Oxford History of the French Revolution. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989.Standard scholarly narrative history.
- Hunt, Lynn. Politics, Culture, and Class in the French Revolution. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1984.On revolutionary political culture.
- Burke, Edmund. Reflections on the Revolution in France. London: J. Dodsley, 1790.Classic conservative response to the early Revolution, written before the Terror.