Philosophy / Indian
Yoga
The Indian discipline of mastering the mind to free the self, set out in the Yoga Sutras
- Began
- Yoga practices are far older than any single text. The classical school is defined by the Yoga Sutras, traditionally ascribed to Patanjali.Scholars: The date of the Yoga Sutras is highly disputed. Proposals range from about the 2nd century BC to about the 5th century AD, and some scholars think the text was compiled from older material. No single date has won general agreement.
- Where
- India
- Key figures
- Tradition names Patanjali as the author of the Yoga Sutras. Practices of yoga are older than his text and have no single founder.
- Key works
- Yoga Sutras; Yoga Bhashya (traditionally ascribed to Vyasa); Tattva Vaisharadi (Vachaspati Mishra); Bhagavad Gita (a related text, not part of the classical school); Hatha Yoga Pradipika (a later, related text on hatha yoga)
At a glance
Yoga is one of the six classical schools of Indian philosophy. In this sense it means a system of mental training, not only physical postures. Its aim is kaivalya, a state of freedom in which the true self is separate from the mind and from matter.
Its main text is the Yoga Sutras, a collection of short sayings. Tradition ascribes them to Patanjali. The sayings are brief, so commentaries have always been used to read them. The oldest surviving major commentary, the Yoga Bhashya, is traditionally ascribed to Vyasa, though its authorship and date are debated.
Yoga shares the worldview of Samkhya, which divides reality into conscious selves and nature. Yoga adds a practical method and a place for Ishvara, described as a special purusha, untouched by suffering, who is a focus of devotion. Schools and scholars differ on whether Ishvara amounts to a personal God. Its best-known teaching is the eight limbs of practice, from ethical rules to deep meditation.
Key concepts
- Purusha
- The conscious self or witness, which is unchanging and separate from matter; classical Yoga holds that there are many such selves.
- Prakriti
- Matter or nature, including body, mind and ego, which is always changing and unfolds into many categories.
- Chitta
- The mind, the part of nature that holds thoughts, memories and feelings.
- Chitta-vritti-nirodha
- The stilling of the mind's fluctuations, which the Yoga Sutras give as the definition of yoga.
- Samadhi
- A state of deep, steady absorption in which the mind rests fully on its object.
- Kaivalya
- Aloneness or liberation, in which the self stands apart from nature.
Core ideas
- In simple terms, reality has two kinds of things: conscious selves (purusha) and nature (prakriti).
- Suffering arises from ignorance, which leads us to mistake the self for the body and mind.
- Freedom comes when the mind's activity is quieted and the self is seen as separate.
- The path is the eight limbs: restraints, observances, posture, breath control, withdrawal of the senses, concentration, meditation and absorption.
- Steady practice and detachment are both needed.
- The Yoga Sutras accept Ishvara, a special self untouched by suffering, as an aid to practice.
Key arguments
The eight limbs
The Yoga Sutras set out a graded path. It begins with ethical restraints such as non-harm and truthfulness. It moves through posture, breath and sense control to concentration, meditation and samadhi.
The five afflictions
The text names ignorance, ego-sense, attraction, aversion and clinging to life as the roots of suffering. Practice aims to weaken each one in turn.
Practice and detachment
Abhyasa is steady effort over a long time. Vairagya is letting go of craving. Together they calm the mind.
The seer and the seen
The self is like a witness who looks at the mind's activity. Suffering comes when the witness identifies with what it sees. Liberation comes when it no longer does.
Philosophers
- Patanjali dates uncertainTraditional author of the Yoga Sutras.
- Vyasa c. 5th century AD (debated)Traditional author of the Yoga Bhashya, the oldest surviving major commentary on the Yoga Sutras; his identity and date are debated.
- Vachaspati Mishra c. 9th–10th century AD (debated)Scholar who wrote a respected sub-commentary on the Yoga Bhashya.
- Vijnanabhikshu c. 16th century ADPhilosopher who wrote a further commentary on the Yoga Sutras.
- Swami Vivekananda 1863–1902Teacher who presented Patanjali's Raja Yoga to Western audiences in the 1890s.
Main criticisms
Is the dualism coherent?
Critics, including Vedanta thinkers, ask how a changeless self can ever be bound to nature or freed from it. Classical Yoga defenders keep a realist dualism and explain bondage as a mistaken identification of the self with the mind, rooted in ignorance. They say the self is never changed, only wrongly taken to be what it is not.
Is liberation world-denying?
Some critics say that aiming at isolation from the world turns away from ordinary life. Defenders point to the ethical restraints and observances at the start of the eight limbs, and say the practice trains a calm, clear way of living. Other traditions, such as the Bhagavad Gita, teach action without attachment, but that is a related teaching rather than the Yoga school's own reply.
What is the role of God?
Scholars and schools differ on whether Ishvara is essential or only a helpful object of meditation. Samkhya critics say the idea is unnecessary. Yoga defenders treat devotion to Ishvara as one practical route among others.
Is modern yoga the same thing?
Historians note that modern postural yoga differs from the Sutras, which say little about postures. It has hatha yoga antecedents but also grew through substantial modern and cross-cultural developments. Many practitioners see it as continuing the older aim of disciplined awareness, while some scholars stress how much has changed.
Sources
- Bryant, Edwin F. and Maas, Philipp A. "Yoga." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.General overview of yoga as philosophy and practice.
- Bryant, Edwin F. The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali. New York: North Point Press, 2009.Translation with classical commentaries.
- Whicher, Ian. The Integrity of the Yoga Darsana. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1998.Study of classical Yoga as a philosophical system.
- Larson, Gerald James and Bhattacharya, Ram Shankar. Samkhya: A Dualist Tradition in Indian Philosophy. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1987.Covers Samkhya and Yoga in the Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies series.