Philosophy / Indian
Samkhya
An ancient Indian school that explains the world as conscious selves and an evolving nature
- Began
- Tradition places Kapila, its founder, in remote antiquity. Some scholars have proposed an early form of the school as far back as c. 4th century BC (debated).Scholars: The classical system is known from the Samkhyakarika, usually dated to about the 4th or 5th century AD. Earlier forms of Samkhya thought appear in texts such as the Upanishads, the Mahabharata and the Buddhacarita, and their dating is debated.
- Where
- India, in the Ganges plain and wider north India
- Key figures
- Tradition names the sage Kapila as the founder. Historians have no secure facts about him. The best-known systematiser is Ishvarakrishna.
- Key works
- Samkhyakarika; Tattvakaumudi (a commentary on the Karika by Vachaspati Mishra); Yuktidipika (a commentary on the Karika); Samkhya Sutras (a later work, generally dated to the late medieval period)
At a glance
Samkhya is one of the six classical schools of Indian philosophy. It says that everything that exists comes from two ultimate realities. One is purusha, the conscious self or spirit. The other is prakriti, matter and nature.
Tradition traces the school to the sage Kapila. Most historians see Samkhya ideas developing gradually over many centuries, with early forms appearing in the Upanishads and the Mahabharata. The classical system is set out in the Samkhyakarika, usually dated to about the 4th or 5th century AD.
Samkhya is distinctive for its sharp split between consciousness and matter. It treats the mind, the ego and the senses as parts of matter, not of the true self. Its goal is kaivalya, or isolation, the liberation of the self from suffering through right knowledge.
Key concepts
- Purusha
- The conscious self, which only witnesses and does not act, and of which there are many, each associated with embodied beings.
- Prakriti
- Primal nature, the single unconscious source from which the physical and mental world, including mind and ego, develops.
- Guna
- One of three strands of prakriti, called sattva (clarity), rajas (activity) and tamas (heaviness or inertia), whose balance shapes everything.
- Tattva
- A principle or category of reality, of which classical Samkhya counts twenty-five.
- Buddhi
- The intellect, the first product of prakriti, which makes judgements and is where knowledge and ignorance occur.
- Kaivalya
- Isolation or freedom, the state in which the self knows itself as separate from matter and is released from suffering.
Core ideas
- Reality has two kinds of ultimate principle, conscious purusha and unconscious prakriti.
- Prakriti is made of three gunas, and when they fall out of balance the world unfolds from it in stages.
- The mind, the ego and the senses belong to prakriti, so they are not the true self.
- Suffering arises because the self mistakes itself for the body and mind.
- Liberation comes through discriminating knowledge, which sees that purusha and prakriti are different.
- Effects already exist in their cause in a hidden form, a view called satkaryavada.
Key arguments
The effect exists in the cause
Samkhya says that nothing comes from nothing. Curd is already present in milk in a latent form, and so the world is already present in prakriti.
Why there must be a self apart from matter
The Samkhyakarika argues that material things exist for the sake of another, as a bed exists for someone to sleep on. So there must be a conscious being, purusha, for whom nature exists.
Many selves
Because people are born and die at different times and have different experiences, Samkhya concludes that there are many separate purushas, not one universal self.
The dancer and the audience
The Samkhyakarika compares prakriti to a dancer who performs for the self, and stops once the self has seen enough. Liberation is when nature has fulfilled its purpose for that self.
Philosophers
- Kapila Traditional founder, dates unknownThe sage to whom tradition ascribes the founding of Samkhya.
- Ishvarakrishna c. 4th to 5th century ADAuthor of the Samkhyakarika, the main surviving classical text of the school.
- Vachaspati Mishra c. 9th or 10th century AD (debated)Wrote the influential Tattvakaumudi commentary on the Samkhyakarika.
- Vijnanabhikshu c. 16th century ADCommentator who wrote on the Samkhya Sutras and sought to join Samkhya with Vedanta.
- Panchashikha Dates uncertainEarly teacher of Samkhya, known mainly from quotations and from the Mahabharata.
Main criticisms
How can spirit and matter relate?
Critics, including Vedanta thinkers, asked how a passive self and unconscious matter can ever interact. Samkhya replies that their mere proximity sets prakriti in motion, like a magnet moving iron without acting on it.
Why does matter act for a conscious self?
Critics ask how unconscious prakriti can work purposefully, and why it would unfold at all. Defenders answer that, like milk flowing to nourish a calf, nature acts naturally for the benefit of the self.
Many selves or one?
Advaita Vedanta holds that there is only one universal consciousness, and sees Samkhya's many selves as a mistake. Samkhya replies that the different experiences and fates of individuals show that selves are plural.
Is bondage real if the self never acts?
If purusha never changes, critics ask how it can be bound or freed. Samkhya answers that bondage and freedom belong to prakriti and appear only by misperception, so the self is never truly changed.
Sources
- Burley, Mikel. "Samkhya." In Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.A clear overview of the school's ideas and history.
- Larson, Gerald James. Classical Samkhya: An Interpretation of Its History and Meaning. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1969.A scholarly study of the classical system. Later editions exist.
- Larson, Gerald James, and Ram Shankar Bhattacharya, eds. Samkhya: A Dualist Tradition in Indian Philosophy. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1987.Covers the history and texts of the school. Volume 4 of the Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies.
- Dasgupta, Surendranath. A History of Indian Philosophy, Volume 1. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1922.A classic survey with a long chapter on Samkhya.