Religion / Abrahamic
Conservative Judaism
A branch of Judaism that honours Jewish law while allowing it to develop through historical study
- Began
- 1840s Germany (intellectual roots); organised in the United States from the 1880sScholars: Historians trace the movement's intellectual roots to the Positive-Historical School of Zacharias Frankel in the 1840s. In the United States, the Jewish Theological Seminary was founded in 1886, and the movement took clearer institutional shape later through bodies such as the United Synagogue of America (1913) and the Rabbinical Assembly (1900). Exactly when it became a distinct denomination is debated.
- Where
- Roots in Germany and central Europe; now strongest in North America, with communities in Israel, Latin America and Europe
- Founder or key figures
- No single founder. Zacharias Frankel gave it early intellectual roots in Germany. Sabato Morais helped found the Jewish Theological Seminary in 1886, and Solomon Schechter, its president from 1902, helped found the United Synagogue of America in 1913.
- Adherents
- No reliable worldwide figure exists. In the United States, about 17 percent of Jewish adults identified with the Conservative movement (Pew Research Center, 2020), out of a US Jewish adult population of roughly 5.8 million by that survey's estimate.
- Texts
- Hebrew Bible (Tanakh); Talmud; Mishneh Torah; Shulchan Aruch; Etz Hayim Torah commentary
At a glance
Conservative Judaism is a modern branch of Judaism. Its mainstream view is that Jewish law, called halakha, is binding. It also holds that the law has always changed over time and can still change in careful, reasoned ways.
Its intellectual roots lie in 19th-century Germany, where Rabbi Zacharias Frankel and others wanted to keep traditional practice while studying Jewish texts and history with modern methods. In the United States, the Jewish Theological Seminary was founded in 1886. The movement took firmer organised form over the following decades, with the Rabbinical Assembly and the United Synagogue.
In North America it is called Conservative. In Israel and much of the world it is called Masorti, meaning traditional. It is often compared to Orthodox Judaism on one side and Reform Judaism on the other, though this is only a rough comparison. Members usually keep the Sabbath and dietary laws to varying degrees, and worship mostly in Hebrew.
Key concepts
- Halakha
- Jewish law, the body of rules for worship and daily life, built up from the Torah and centuries of rabbinic discussion.
- Historical development
- The view that Jewish law and practice have always grown in response to new conditions, which can be studied historically.
- Klal Yisrael
- The collective Jewish people, or the community of Israel as a whole.
- Torah
- The five books of Moses, and in wider use all Jewish teaching, which is central to study and worship.
- Takkanah
- A rabbinic enactment that adds to, modifies or regulates existing law.
- Masorti
- Hebrew for traditional, the name the movement uses in Israel and in many countries outside North America.
Core beliefs
- Movement authorities generally teach that Jewish law is binding and that Jews are called to live by the commandments, though the movement has no single creed and individual observance varies widely.
- The Torah is regarded as sacred, and many in the movement see it as divinely inspired. Views differ on how, with some accepting that humans shaped its transmission and interpretation.
- Jewish law can change through the decisions of rabbis who act within the tradition and its methods.
- Modern scholarship, including the historical study of Jewish texts, is welcome and need not weaken faith.
- Hebrew, the synagogue and the Jewish people as a community hold lasting importance.
- The Jewish people has a special bond with the land of Israel, which is reflected in prayer and education.
Practices
Sabbath and festivals
Members rest on Shabbat from Friday evening to Saturday night, with prayer, meals and study. Practice varies. A controversial 1950 ruling of the movement's law committee allowed driving to synagogue under certain circumstances, but it was not a general permission to drive on Shabbat.
Dietary laws
The movement teaches keeping kashrut, the Jewish food rules, such as avoiding pork and not mixing meat and milk. Individual observance varies widely.
Worship
Services follow the traditional structure and are mostly in Hebrew, with some prayers in English. Beginning in the 1970s and 1980s, many North American congregations counted women in the prayer quorum and called them to the Torah, though practice differs by congregation.
Education and law
Children attend Hebrew schools and many go to movement summer camps. The Committee on Jewish Law and Standards issues rulings, and sometimes more than one is accepted as valid.
Notable people
- Zacharias Frankel 1801–1875German rabbi whose Positive-Historical approach, from the 1840s, became the movement's intellectual root.
- Sabato Morais 1823–1897Italian-born rabbi in Philadelphia who helped found the Jewish Theological Seminary in 1886.
- Solomon Schechter 1847–1915Scholar who led the Seminary from 1902 and helped organise the United Synagogue of America in 1913.
- Mordecai Kaplan 1881–1983Seminary teacher whose ideas of Judaism as an evolving civilization led to the later Reconstructionist movement.
- Abraham Joshua Heschel 1907–1972Philosopher and Seminary professor known for writing on prophecy, the Sabbath and spiritual life.
Debates
How far can the law change?
Some members and rabbis want a stricter approach, close to traditional halakhic reasoning. Others favour wider change when they believe ethics or modern life demand it. The law committee may approve more than one ruling on a question, but rabbis and congregations do not treat every ruling as equally authoritative.
Women's roles and inclusion
The movement began counting women in the prayer quorum in many congregations in the 1970s and 1980s, and ordained its first woman rabbi in 1985. The Union for Traditional Judaism formed in 1984, with disagreement over women's ordination one of several factors. In 2006 the law committee approved several competing rulings on gay and lesbian members, including one allowing gay and lesbian rabbis, which some members opposed and others welcomed.
Origins and identity
Some historians see the movement as a middle course between Orthodoxy and Reform. Adherents say it simply continues the tradition as it has always evolved. Orthodox critics say that accepting historical criticism undermines the Torah's divine origin.
Sources
- "Conservative Judaism." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.Overview of history and beliefs.
- Sklare, Marshall. Conservative Judaism: An American Religious Movement. Glencoe, IL: Free Press, 1955.Classic sociological study of the American movement.
- Gillman, Neil. Conservative Judaism: The New Century. West Orange: Behrman House, 1993.Introduction to the movement's ideas by a Conservative rabbi and scholar.
- Pew Research Center. "Jewish Americans in 2020." Washington, DC, 2021.Survey data on denominational identification.