Politics / Liberal
Neoliberalism
A market-centred outlook that favours competition, backed by a state that sets the rules
- Began
- Conventionally dated 1938–1947 (a scholarly shorthand, not a settled origin)Scholars: The Paris colloquium of 1938 and the founding of the Mont Pelerin Society in 1947 are the usual milestones, but related ideas and terms appear earlier. Reforms associated with the label began at different times in different places, for example in Chile in the 1970s, and became widespread from about 1980. Scholars debate how far the label describes one coherent movement.
- Where
- Europe and the United States, with early centres in Austria, Germany, France, Britain and Chicago
- Key figures
- No single founder. The thinkers usually grouped under the label include Friedrich Hayek, Ludwig von Mises, Wilhelm Röpke, Walter Eucken, Alexander Rüstow and Milton Friedman. Friedman attended the 1947 founding meeting of the Mont Pelerin Society. Which thinkers belong to the grouping is contested.
- Key works
- The Road to Serfdom; The Constitution of Liberty; Capitalism and Freedom; The Great Transformation (by Karl Polanyi, a critique of the self-regulating market); The Birth of Biopolitics (Michel Foucault's lecture course, an interpretation by an outside thinker)
At a glance
Neoliberalism is a set of ideas that say competitive markets are usually the best way to organise economic life. It grew out of classical liberalism, the older tradition of limited government and free trade. Its thinkers wanted to renew that tradition after the Great Depression and the rise of planned economies.
A meeting in Paris in 1938 is commonly cited as the institutional origin of the label. Earlier uses of related terms are documented, and the credit given to Alexander Rüstow for the word is debated. After the Second World War, economists and writers formed groups such as the Mont Pelerin Society, founded in 1947. Many were critical of central planning. Their attitudes to Keynesian economics, which supports government spending to manage the economy, and to the post-war welfare state varied by thinker and country. Some wanted a regulated market order with social protections.
From the 1970s, and widely from about 1980, governments in several countries put some of these ideas into practice, in different mixtures rather than as a single programme. Today the word is mostly used by critics. Few people call themselves neoliberals. Supporters usually describe their views as classical liberal, free-market or simply liberal. Scholars disagree about whether the label names a single doctrine.
Key concepts
- Competition
- The idea that rivalry between sellers, and between buyers, shapes prices and pushes producers towards better quality, new ideas and wider choice.
- Price system
- Hayek's view that prices carry scattered knowledge that no central planner could collect.
- Privatisation
- Moving businesses or services from public ownership into private hands.
- Deregulation
- Removing or reducing government rules on business and trade.
- Monetarism
- A distinct school, linked to Milton Friedman, that stresses the relationship between growth in the money supply, inflation and economic activity; many neoliberals were influenced by it, but not all.
- Ordoliberalism
- A German school that wants a strong state to protect competition and prevent monopolies.
Core positions
- Markets, guided by prices and competition, usually allocate resources better than central planning.
- The state should set and enforce clear rules, such as property rights, contracts and competition law.
- Many, though not all, stress sound money and low inflation; thinkers differed on whether public spending should be used to manage the economy.
- Most favour open trade; free movement of capital was backed by some strands and policy programmes, while others accepted limits or regulation.
- Individual economic freedom is closely linked to wider political freedom.
- Government should limit its role in running industries and offering services, or use market-like methods where it does act.
Policies and positions
Economy
Supporters tend to favour lower and simpler taxes, stable prices and central banks with a price-stability aim. Many oppose price controls and wide state ownership, though positions vary between thinkers.
The state
The state is not abolished. It is expected to guard competition and enforce contracts. Some policies bring market methods into public services, such as vouchers or contracting out.
Labour and welfare
Many advocates favour more flexible labour markets, and some favour limits on union power, though others do not. Some prefer targeted benefits to broad programmes. Hayek and Friedman each discussed a minimum income in some form, but this was not a position shared by the whole tradition.
Trade and foreign affairs
Advocates generally support lower tariffs and international trade agreements. Institutions such as the World Trade Organization are often linked to this approach, though scholars debate how far they reflect it.
Thinkers and leaders
- Friedrich Hayek 1899–1992Austrian-British economist who argued that prices spread knowledge and that central planning endangers liberty.
- Ludwig von Mises 1881–1973Austrian economist who argued that socialist economies cannot calculate costs rationally.
- Milton Friedman 1912–2006American economist of the Chicago school who promoted monetarism and free-market policy.
- Wilhelm Röpke 1899–1966German economist who shaped ordoliberal thinking and argued for a market order with strong social foundations.
- Walter Eucken 1891–1950German economist and founder of the Freiburg school of ordoliberalism.
- Alexander Rüstow 1885–1963German sociologist often credited with introducing or popularising the term at the 1938 Paris colloquium, though the attribution is disputed.
Main criticisms
Inequality and insecurity
Critics argue that market-oriented reforms since about 1980 widened income gaps and left workers less secure. Defenders reply that open markets coincided with global growth and falling poverty, though they and their critics disagree on how much reforms caused this, since technology, state policy and very different national paths also mattered.
Is the state really limited?
Critics, including followers of Karl Polanyi and some historians, say markets need constant state action to exist, so the claim of small government is misleading. Many neoliberal thinkers agree that markets need a strong legal framework, and they say their aim is a different role for the state, not its absence.
Democracy and accountability
Critics argue that putting decisions in the hands of central banks, courts or trade bodies removes economic choices from voters. Defenders reply that rules and independent institutions protect against short-term political pressure and protect minorities from majorities.
Does the label mean anything?
Some scholars say neoliberalism is too vague, covering very different thinkers and policies, and is used mainly as a term of criticism. Others reply that the thinkers did form real networks and shared aims, which makes the term a useful historical label.
Sources
- Harvey, David. A Brief History of Neoliberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005.A critical account of the spread of neoliberal policy.
- Slobodian, Quinn. Globalists: The End of Empire and the Birth of Neoliberalism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2018.A history of neoliberal thinkers and their ideas on world order.
- Mirowski, Philip, and Dieter Plehwe, eds. The Road from Mont Pèlerin: The Making of the Neoliberal Thought Collective. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2009.Essays on the intellectual networks behind the movement.
- Hayek, Friedrich A. The Road to Serfdom. London: Routledge, 1944.A founding argument against central economic planning.
- Britannica Editors. "Neoliberalism." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.Short overview of the term and its history.