Politics / Nationalist

Nationalism

The belief that the nation is a natural basis of political life and of the state

Began
Late 18th centuryScholars: Most historians date modern nationalism to the late 18th century, though some argue that national feelings existed in medieval or ancient times (debated)
Where
Europe and the Americas first, especially France, the German lands and British North America; later worldwide
Key figures
No single founder. Johann Gottfried Herder is an early influence on cultural nationalism. Rousseau and others are often seen as precursors through ideas of popular sovereignty, though this is contested
Key works
Ideas for the Philosophy of History of Mankind; Addresses to the German Nation; What Is a Nation?; Nations and Nationalism; Imagined Communities

At a glance

Nationalism is the idea that the nation should be central to political life. A nation is a large group that sees itself as united by things like a common history, language, culture, territory or citizenship. Nationalists hold that such a group should be able to govern itself, and that loyalty to the nation matters a great deal. Some seek a state of their own. Others seek self-rule, autonomy or recognition within a larger state.

Most historians trace modern nationalism to the late 18th century. The American and French Revolutions made popular sovereignty, the idea that power comes from the people, a leading political principle. Their national identities developed in different ways, and historians debate how closely popular sovereignty and nationalism are linked. In the 19th century nationalism shaped the unification of Italy and Germany, and the struggles of many peoples within larger empires. In the 20th century it was one important force in anticolonial movements in Asia and Africa, alongside wars, economic change and international politics.

Nationalism is unusual because it has no fixed economic programme. It has been joined with liberalism, socialism, conservatism and authoritarian rule. Scholars often distinguish civic nationalism, which stresses shared citizenship and laws, from ethnic nationalism, which stresses shared descent or culture. These are ideal types, and real nationalisms usually mix both. Fascism shared important nationalist elements, but it also drew on authoritarian, racial, anti-liberal and revolutionary currents, and is treated here as a separate tradition.

Key concepts

Nation
A large community whose members feel bound together by shared identity, history, culture or citizenship.
Self-determination
The principle, much invoked by nationalists, that a people should decide how it is governed, though its exact meaning and limits are disputed.
Sovereignty
The supreme authority of a state over its own territory and affairs.
Civic nationalism
A form that stresses shared citizenship, laws and political values, though it may still require language, cultural or other conditions for membership.
Ethnic nationalism
A form that stresses common ancestry, language or cultural heritage as the core of the nation.
Patriotism
Love of and loyalty to one's country, which some thinkers distinguish from nationalism and others treat as closely related.

Core positions

  • Nationalists commonly hold that humanity is naturally divided into nations, each with its own character and history, a claim many scholars dispute.
  • The nation is seen as the proper basis of political legitimacy.
  • Nations should be able to govern themselves, free from foreign rule.
  • Members of a nation owe each other special loyalty and obligations.
  • A shared culture, memory and symbols, such as flags and anthems, bind a people together.
  • Many nationalists want the borders of the state to match the nation, while others seek autonomy, federation or recognition within an existing state.

Policies and positions

The state

Nationalists generally favour a state or political order that expresses the nation's identity and protects its independence. Some want a unified state for a divided people. Others want to break away from a larger state or empire, or to gain autonomy within one.

Economy

There is no single nationalist economics. Some nationalists support tariffs and protection of national industry. Others support free markets or state-led welfare, as long as these serve the nation.

Citizenship and culture

Nationalists often support a shared national language, schooling and history. Civic nationalists stress citizenship under common laws, though they may expect newcomers to adopt certain cultural norms. Ethnic nationalists give more weight to descent or heritage, and often also define citizenship and its limits.

Foreign affairs

Nationalists tend to put national interest first and to value independence from outside control. They may be wary of international bodies that limit sovereignty. Nationalism has been linked both to anti-imperial struggles for self-rule and, in some cases, to expansionist wars, but these outcomes depend on the movements and circumstances involved.

Thinkers and leaders

  • Johann Gottfried Herder 1744–1803German thinker who argued that each people has its own language and culture, which shape how its members think.
  • Johann Gottlieb Fichte 1762–1814German philosopher whose Addresses to the German Nation called for national education and unity during the Napoleonic occupation.
  • Giuseppe Mazzini 1805–1872Italian campaigner for a unified republic who saw free nations as partners in a peaceful Europe.
  • Ernest Renan 1823–1892French scholar who described the nation as a shared past and a present will to live together, a 'daily plebiscite'.
  • Mahatma Gandhi 1869–1948Leader of the Indian independence movement, which sought an end to British rule through nonviolent action.
  • Sun Yat-sen 1866–1925Chinese revolutionary who made nationalism one of his Three Principles of the People.

Main criticisms

Does nationalism divide people?

Critics argue that stressing national identity can breed hostility to outsiders and minorities. They point to wars, expulsions and mass violence in which nationalist ideas played a part, alongside racial, imperial, fascist and state ideologies, as in the Armenian genocide and the Holocaust, where historians stress several causes. Defenders reply that these are abuses, and that nationalism has also united peoples, ended imperial rule and supported democracy.

Is the nation natural or constructed?

Scholars such as Benedict Anderson and Ernest Gellner explain how modern institutions such as print, schooling and industrial economies produced or consolidated national communities and nationalism. Others, such as Anthony D. Smith, stress older ethnic roots. Nationalists often reply that nations rest on older cultures and memories, and that a community can be real even if its institutions are recent. Scholars have not settled this question.

Who belongs to the nation?

Critics say that nations are rarely uniform, so any national state includes people who do not fit its definition. Defenders reply that civic nationalism answers this by basing membership on citizenship and shared law rather than descent. Critics respond that civic nationalism can also demand assimilation.

Universal rights or national loyalty?

Cosmopolitan critics argue that moral duties should not stop at borders and that national loyalty can override human rights. Defenders reply that democracy and welfare need a bounded community with shared trust, and that nations are a practical way to protect rights.

Sources

  1. Miscevic, Nenad. "Nationalism." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Philosophical overview of definitions and debates.
  2. Anderson, Benedict. Imagined Communities. London: Verso, 1983.Argues that nations are socially constructed communities.
  3. Gellner, Ernest. Nations and Nationalism. Oxford: Blackwell, 1983.Links nationalism to industrial society and modern education.
  4. Hobsbawm, E. J. Nations and Nationalism since 1780. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990.Historical survey from the late 18th century.
  5. Smith, Anthony D. The Ethnic Origins of Nations. Oxford: Blackwell, 1986.Argues that modern nations draw on older ethnic communities.