Philosophy / Indian
Yogacara
The Buddhist school that studies how the mind shapes all we experience
- Began
- 4th century ADScholars: Its main texts and thinkers are usually placed between c. 300 and 500 AD. Some earlier roots are traced to sutras of the first centuries AD.
- Where
- India, in several regions and monastic settings. Nalanda became an important centre of study in later centuries.
- Key figures
- No single founder. Tradition names Maitreya (or Maitreyanatha), Asanga and Vasubandhu as the key early figures. Maitreya's identity is debated, and so are the exact relationship and works of the figures named Asanga and Vasubandhu.
- Key works
- Samdhinirmocana Sutra (Sutra Explaining the Hidden Meaning); Yogacarabhumi-sastra (Stages of Yoga Practice); Mahayanasamgraha (Summary of the Great Vehicle); Vimsatika (Twenty Verses); Trimsika (Thirty Verses)
At a glance
Yogacara is a school of Mahayana Buddhist philosophy. Its name means "yoga practice". It grew out of the work of monks who practised meditation and also studied the mind closely. It is also called Vijnanavada, the teaching of consciousness, and Cittamatra, "mind only". These labels are useful but debated, and scholars disagree about how far they mean a simple idealism.
The school took shape in India around the 4th century AD. Tradition holds that Asanga received teachings from the future Buddha Maitreya, and that his brother Vasubandhu set out the ideas in verse works. Historians debate the family link and which works belong to which Vasubandhu. Later thinkers such as Dignaga developed theories of knowledge within or alongside the school, and Dharmakirti's relation to it is complex.
Its most distinctive concern is how experience is shaped by consciousness. Ordinary experience splits into a knower and a known object. Yogacara teaches that this split is a habit of the mind, and that seeing through it is part of the path to liberation. The school spread to China, Tibet, Korea and Japan, where it shaped later Buddhist thought.
Key concepts
- Vijnaptimatra
- Often translated "representation-only" or "cognition-only", the idea that what we experience is given to us as mental appearance, whose exact meaning is debated.
- Alayavijnana
- The "storehouse consciousness", a deep level of mind that holds the seeds left by past actions and gives rise to later experience.
- Bija
- A "seed", a trace left in the storehouse consciousness that can later ripen into experience.
- Trisvabhava
- The three natures: the imagined, the dependent and the perfected, a scheme for describing how experience is constructed and how it can be seen without that construction.
- Asraya-paravrtti
- The "revolution of the basis", a deep change in the mind that marks awakening.
- Yogacara practice
- A varied set of meditative and study practices, often aimed at understanding and loosening the mind's habits of grasping.
Core ideas
- Our experience is always given through consciousness, and Yogacara thinkers use this to question our habitual belief in independent objects. Interpreters differ on whether the school denies external objects or only our knowledge of them.
- The split between subject and object is a construction of the mind, not the final nature of things.
- A deep storehouse consciousness carries the seeds of past actions and explains how karma continues over time.
- Reality is described through three natures: imagined, dependent and perfected, and wisdom means seeing how they relate.
- Suffering ends when the mind's habits of grasping are transformed, a change called the revolution of the basis.
- Yogacara holds that its teachings follow the Buddha's path and are consistent with the doctrine of emptiness.
Key arguments
The dream argument
In dreams we seem to see mountains and cities outside us, yet no such objects need be there. Vasubandhu uses this to show that the feeling of an external object does not prove that one exists, so we should not simply infer objects from appearances.
Seeing the same thing differently
A common Buddhist example says hungry ghosts may see a river as pus, humans as water and gods as nectar. Yogacara writers use such cases to show how much experience depends on the karma and mind of the viewer.
Why the storehouse is needed
Actions leave effects that ripen later, often after a gap in awareness. Yogacara proposes the storehouse consciousness as the continuous base that carries these seeds through time and between lives.
The three natures
The imagined nature is the false picture of a separate subject and object. The dependent nature is experience arising from causes and conditions. The perfected nature is that dependent experience as empty of the imagined split. Teachers use analogies such as a magic show, where the appearance exists but not as it seems.
Philosophers
- Asanga c. 4th century ADMonk and systematic author, traditionally credited with the Mahayanasamgraha and with organising Yogacara teaching.
- Vasubandhu c. 4th or 5th century ADTradition calls him Asanga's brother and author of the Twenty Verses and Thirty Verses; scholars debate the relationship, his dates and whether one or two authors are involved.
- Maitreya (Maitreyanatha) Dates uncertainIn tradition the future Buddha Maitreya is the source of key texts; some scholars instead posit a human teacher of that name, whose identity and dates are uncertain.
- Dignaga c. 480–540 ADThinker who built a system of logic and theory of knowledge with Yogacara leanings.
- Dharmakirti c. 6th or 7th century ADDeveloped Dignaga's work on knowledge and reasoning; his affiliation with Yogacara is debated.
- Xuanzang c. 602–664Chinese pilgrim who studied in India, translated major Yogacara works and helped establish the Faxiang (Weishi) tradition in China.
Main criticisms
Is it idealism?
Critics, both ancient and modern, say that Yogacara denies the outside world and reduces everything to mind. Many defenders reply that it only claims that we cannot know objects apart from experience, and that scholars still debate whether the school is really idealist.
The problem of other minds
Opponents asked how, if only consciousness exists, different people share a common world. Vasubandhu replied that the seeds in separate streams of consciousness ripen in similar ways, giving shared appearances.
Does it conflict with emptiness?
Madhyamaka thinkers argued that treating consciousness as ultimately real goes against the teaching that all things lack own-being. Some Yogacara thinkers replied that they accept emptiness, but positions within the school differ and the relation of consciousness to emptiness is still contested.
The storehouse and no-self
Some critics said the storehouse consciousness looks like a permanent self. Defenders answer that it is a stream of changing moments, not a lasting thing.
Sources
- Schmithausen, Lambert, and others. Entries on Yogacara in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.Overview of the school, its history and its main doctrines.
- Williams, Paul. Mahayana Buddhism: The Doctrinal Foundations. London: Routledge, 1989.Standard introduction with a chapter on Yogacara.
- Kochumuttom, Thomas A. A Buddhist Doctrine of Experience. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1982.A study and translation of Vasubandhu's works.
- Lusthaus, Dan. Buddhist Phenomenology. London: RoutledgeCurzon, 2002.Study of Yogacara and the Cheng weishi lun.