Philosophy / Greek and Roman
Stoicism
The Greek and Roman school that taught virtue and reason as the path to a good life
- Began
- c. 300 BC
- Where
- Athens, Greece. Later widespread across the Roman world.
- Key figures
- Zeno of Citium, followed by Cleanthes and Chrysippus
- Key works
- Meditations by Marcus Aurelius; Discourses and Handbook (Enchiridion) by Epictetus, recorded by Arrian; Letters to Lucilius by Seneca; On Anger and On the Shortness of Life by Seneca; Fragments of the early Stoics, collected by later writers
At a glance
Stoicism is a school of philosophy that began in Athens. Its followers held that the best life is a life of virtue, lived in agreement with nature and reason. They taught that wisdom, courage, justice and self-control are the only true goods.
Zeno of Citium began teaching around 300 BC in a painted colonnade in Athens, the Stoa Poikile. The name Stoic comes from this place. Ancient writers say Zeno was influenced by the Cynic Crates, and Stoicism is usually seen as a separate school that grew out of Cynic ideas about virtue and simple living.
Stoics teach that we control our own judgements and choices, but not wealth, health, reputation or other people. They aim to meet events with a clear mind and to treat all humans as members of one community. The school lasted for about five hundred years in the Greek and Roman worlds, and its Roman writers are the best preserved.
Key concepts
- Virtue (arete)
- Excellence of character, which Stoics hold to be the only thing that is truly good.
- Logos
- The rational order that Stoics saw running through the universe and through human reason.
- Apatheia
- Freedom from destructive passions such as rage and fear, not a lack of all feeling.
- Indifferents (adiaphora)
- Things like health, wealth and fame, which are neither good nor bad in themselves, though some are preferable.
- Dichotomy of control
- A modern name for Epictetus's teaching that some things are up to us, such as our judgements and choices, while others, such as the body, property and reputation, are not or only partly so.
- Oikeiosis
- The Stoic account of how living things come to feel that something is their own, beginning with self-preservation and developing in humans into concern for others, which later Stoics such as Hierocles pictured as widening circles reaching all humanity.
Core ideas
- Virtue is sufficient for happiness, and it is the only true good.
- Living well means living in agreement with nature, including our own rational nature.
- Stoics held that passions such as fear and anger involve judgements we assent to, so examining our beliefs can change them, though they accepted that involuntary first reactions come before assent.
- We should focus on what is up to us and accept what is not.
- All humans share reason and belong to one world community.
- The universe is ordered and rational, and events follow a chain of causes often called fate or providence.
Key arguments
The dog and the cart
Stoics compared a person to a dog tied to a moving cart. The dog can resist and be dragged, or it can follow willingly. Either way the cart moves, so the choice is how to respond.
The inner citadel
Marcus Aurelius wrote that the mind can be like a fortress that outside troubles cannot enter. Pain and loss may happen, but our judgement about them is still ours.
Premeditation of evils
Stoics advised imagining possible losses or hardships in advance. This was meant to lessen shock and to help a person value what they have.
The view from above
Stoics practised picturing Earth and human affairs from a great height. This was meant to put worries into proportion.
Philosophers
- Zeno of Citium c. 334–262 BCFounded the school in Athens.
- Chrysippus c. 279–206 BCThird head of the school, who developed its logic and system in great detail.
- Seneca c. 4 BC–AD 65Roman statesman and writer whose letters and essays give practical Stoic advice.
- Epictetus c. AD 50–135Former slave and teacher whose lessons survive through his student Arrian.
- Marcus Aurelius AD 121–180Roman emperor who wrote private reflections now known as the Meditations.
Main criticisms
Is virtue enough for happiness?
Critics, including followers of Aristotle, said health, friends and prosperity also matter to a good life. Stoics reply that these are preferable but that character alone makes a life good, and they defend this as a claim about what truly counts.
Does it ask people to suppress emotion?
Some critics say Stoicism teaches coldness and detachment. Defenders reply that Stoics aimed to remove harmful passions while keeping good feelings such as joy and goodwill, and that they valued care for family and community.
Fate and freedom
Critics argued that if everything follows fixed causes, moral responsibility is hard to explain. Stoics such as Chrysippus replied that our choices are themselves part of the causal chain, so we are still responsible for them.
Sources
- Baltzly, Dirk. "Stoicism." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of Stoic history and doctrine.
- Sellars, John. Stoicism. Chesham: Acumen, 2006.Scholarly introduction to the school.
- Hadot, Pierre. The Inner Citadel: The Meditations of Marcus Aurelius. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1998.Study of Marcus Aurelius and Stoic practice.
- Marcus Aurelius. Meditations. Translated by Gregory Hays. New York: Modern Library, 2002.Personal reflections of a Stoic emperor.