Philosophy / Indian

Nyaya

The Indian school of logic and knowledge, which asks how we can know anything reliably

Began
c. 2nd century BC–2nd century ADScholars: Tradition ascribes the Nyaya Sutra to the sage Gautama (also called Akshapada). Most historians think it took its present form over several centuries, roughly between the 2nd century BC and the 2nd century AD, with later additions.
Where
India, with its main centres of learning in the north, later also in Mithila and Bengal
Key figures
Traditionally Gautama (Akshapada); the school developed over time with no single founder in the modern sense
Key works
Nyaya Sutra; Nyaya Bhashya (Vatsyayana); Nyayavarttika (Uddyotakara); Nyayamanjari (Jayanta Bhatta); Tattvacintamani (Gangesa)

At a glance

Nyaya is one of the six classical schools of Indian philosophy that accept the authority of the Vedas. Its name means roughly "rules" or "method". It is best known for its study of logic, debate and the sources of knowledge.

Tradition traces the school to Gautama, author of the Nyaya Sutra. Historians think the text was composed and expanded by several hands over time. Commentators such as Vatsyayana, Uddyotakara and Udayana built a long tradition of argument on it.

Nyaya holds that people can gain reliable knowledge of the world through proper means, and that clear thinking helps free a person from suffering. It also developed arguments for the existence of God. From about the 13th century, a later form called Navya-Nyaya ("New Nyaya") used very precise technical language and shaped Indian scholarship in many fields.

Key concepts

Pramana
A means of gaining valid knowledge.
Pratyaksha
Perception, knowledge that comes through the senses and the mind.
Anumana
Inference, reaching a conclusion from a sign, such as smoke showing that there is fire.
Upamana and Shabda
Comparison, learning what a word names by likeness to a known thing, and reliable testimony from trustworthy speakers.
Atman
The self, an eternal substance distinct from the body and mind, in which cognition and other qualities arise.
Apavarga
Liberation, the end of suffering that comes from true knowledge.

Core ideas

  • There are four valid means of knowledge: perception, inference, comparison and testimony.
  • The world is real and exists independently of our minds, and it can be known.
  • Each person has a self that is distinct from the body, senses and mind.
  • Wrong ideas cause desire, aversion and action, which keep a person bound to rebirth.
  • Right knowledge of reality, reached by study and reasoning, leads to liberation.
  • Later Nyaya thinkers argued that God exists as the maker of the world.

Key arguments

Smoke and fire

Nyaya teaches that we can infer fire on a hill from seeing smoke. This depends on a universal link between smoke and fire, called vyapti. The link is established by repeated observation, by cases where both are absent, and by checking that no extra condition (upadhi) is really what produces the connection.

The five-step argument

Nyaya sets out a proof in five parts. The claim: the hill has fire. The reason: because it has smoke. The example: wherever there is smoke there is fire, as in a kitchen. The application: this hill has smoke of that kind. The conclusion: therefore the hill has fire. The method was meant for fair debate.

Argument for God from the world

Later Nyaya writers such as Udayana argued that the world is an effect, like a pot. Effects have makers, so the world must have an intelligent maker. They took this maker to be God.

Fallacies in reasoning

Nyaya lists ways that arguments go wrong, called hetvabhasa. One is giving a reason that proves the opposite of the claim. Another is giving a reason that is not reliably linked to it.

Philosophers

  • Gautama (Akshapada) traditionally dated; uncertainTraditional author of the Nyaya Sutra.
  • Vatsyayana c. 4th–5th century ADWrote the oldest surviving full commentary on the Nyaya Sutra.
  • Uddyotakara c. 6th–7th century ADDefended Nyaya against Buddhist criticism in his Nyayavarttika.
  • Udayana c. 10th–11th century ADWrote major works arguing for God's existence and answering Buddhist objections.
  • Gangesa c. 13th–14th century ADFounded Navya-Nyaya with his Tattvacintamani.

Main criticisms

Buddhist objection to a lasting self

Buddhist thinkers such as Dignaga and Dharmakirti denied that there is a permanent self and criticised Nyaya views of perception. Nyaya thinkers replied that memory and the unity of experience across time need a single subject who persists.

Is the argument for God sound?

Critics, including Buddhists and Mimamsa thinkers, said that the world is not clearly like a made object, and that a maker need not be a single God. Nyaya writers answered that the world's order and parts show design, and that one maker is the simplest explanation.

Can inference be trusted?

Carvaka materialists are reported by their opponents to have doubted inference, since we cannot observe every case of smoke and fire. Their own writings are mostly lost, so the exact position is debated. Nyaya thinkers replied that a reliable vyapti is established by repeated observation, by negative cases, and by excluding limiting conditions (upadhis), and that doubting inference altogether undermines everyday action and the doubter's own argument.

Sources

  1. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. "Nyaya." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman.Overview of the school, its history and its theory of knowledge.
  2. Matilal, Bimal Krishna. Perception: An Essay on Classical Indian Theories of Knowledge. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1986.Detailed study of Nyaya and rival views of perception.
  3. Ganeri, Jonardon. Philosophy in Classical India: The Proper Work of Reason. London: Routledge, 2001.Introduction to Indian philosophy with sections on Nyaya reasoning.
  4. Potter, Karl H., editor. Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1974.Multi-volume survey; the volume on Nyaya-Vaisesika covers Nyaya thinkers and texts.