Philosophy / Chinese
Mohism
A school of impartial care, frugality and practical argument, founded by Mozi
- Began
- 5th century BCScholars: Mozi is usually placed in the 5th century BC. The received book Mozi was not written by him alone. Its chapters come from several layers, composed and edited by followers over roughly the next two centuries, and the text was transmitted and edited again in later periods.
- Where
- Ancient China, in the states of the Spring and Autumn and Warring States periods, with Mozi linked to the state of Lu and perhaps Song
- Key figures
- Mozi (Mo Di), with later followers known as the Later Mohists
- Key works
- Mozi; Canons and Explanations (the Later Mohist logical chapters of the Mozi); Impartial Care (chapters of the Mozi); Against Offensive War (chapters of the Mozi); Exalting the Worthy (chapters of the Mozi)
At a glance
Mohism was a Chinese school of thought founded by Mozi, a thinker of the 5th century BC. It taught that people should show impartial concern for everyone, so that the interests of strangers count as seriously as those of one's own family in how people act and how rulers govern. Mohists did not necessarily deny family affection, and scholars debate how best to translate and interpret their key idea, jian ai. The school judged ideas, customs and policies by whether they brought benefit to people and the state.
Mozi's followers formed a disciplined community. They argued against offensive war, wasteful ceremonies and luxury. Later tradition says Mozi and his followers helped smaller states defend themselves, and the Mozi contains chapters on defensive warfare. This is tradition rather than firmly established biography. Later Mohists developed work on logic, language, optics and mechanics.
Mohism was one of the influential schools of the Warring States period, and Han dynasty writers often named it alongside Confucianism as a major rival. It declined as an organised movement during the late Warring States period and the Qin and early Han transition, roughly the 3rd to 2nd centuries BC. Its texts and ideas kept circulating in a limited way, but it was little studied for many centuries. Scholars revived interest in it in the late Qing and modern periods.
Key concepts
- Jian ai
- Impartial or inclusive care, a concern that does not favour one's own family or state when it comes to conduct and benefit, though its exact meaning is debated.
- Li
- Benefit or advantage, the standard by which Mohists judged actions, policies and customs.
- Shang xian
- Exalting the worthy, the principle that officials should be chosen by ability and virtue, not by birth.
- Fei gong
- Condemnation of offensive war, which Mohists saw as large-scale killing and theft.
- Tian zhi
- The will of Heaven, which Mozi said favours impartial care and rewards or punishes people accordingly.
- Three standards (san biao)
- Tests for any doctrine: its basis in the precedents of the sage kings, its agreement with ordinary people's experience, and its usefulness when applied.
Core ideas
- People and rulers should act with impartial concern, giving the welfare of strangers real weight alongside that of their own family, though Mohists did not clearly claim that family ties have no special emotional meaning.
- Social disorder comes largely from partial concern, as people favour themselves, their families and their states over others.
- Any practice should be judged by whether it benefits the people, increasing wealth, population and order.
- Offensive war is wrong, because it causes great harm for the gain of a few, though defence is justified.
- Rulers should appoint officials by merit and should share the people's standards of right.
- Lavish funerals, long mourning and elaborate music waste resources, so they should be reduced.
Key arguments
The argument from partiality
Mozi argued that thieves, rebels and warring states all act from concern for their own side alone. If people showed others the concern they show themselves, he said, such harms would not arise.
The argument against offensive war
Mozi noted that people condemn a man who steals a peach or kills one person. He asked why they then praise a ruler who seizes a state and kills thousands, which he saw as the same wrong on a greater scale.
Against costly ritual
Mohists held that elaborate funerals and music drain the treasury and keep people from productive work. They asked what benefit these customs bring to the living.
The three standards
To test a claim, Mohists asked where it came from in the past, whether people's real experience supports it, and whether it benefits the state and people when put into practice. Later Mohists extended this into a study of argument and definition.
Philosophers
- Mozi (Mo Di) c. 470–391 BC, debatedFounder of the school, who taught impartial care and led a disciplined community of followers.
- Qin Guli 5th–4th century BCEarly disciple of Mozi named in the texts.
- Meng Sheng died c. 381 BCA Mohist leader who, in a later account in the Lüshi chunqiu, died with his followers defending the city of Yang for its lord; the episode and its date rest on that later source.
- Fu Dun 4th century BCA Mohist leader known from later accounts, in which he is said to have upheld the school's rule of punishment.
Main criticisms
Is impartial care realistic?
Confucians such as Mencius argued that care naturally begins in the family and that equal concern for all denies the special bond between parent and child. Mohists and their modern interpreters reply that impartial care concerns conduct and benefit, not the end of family affection, and argue that everyone is better off in a world where others also show concern.
Is usefulness too narrow a test?
Critics such as Xunzi said that judging everything by material benefit neglects ritual, music and the cultivation of character. Mohists answered that customs must justify themselves by their effects on the people's welfare.
Is the will of Heaven a sound basis?
Later critics, including Confucian thinkers who understood Heaven as less personal, doubted that a Heaven and spirits who reward and punish exist. Mohist texts treat Heaven and spirits as real and authoritative, and argue from tradition and reported experience that they watch human conduct. They also say belief in them encourages right action.
Does the school's discipline limit freedom?
Critics said that Mohist doctrine, with its call for agreement with superiors and its strict community, left little room for individual judgement. Defenders replied that shared standards were needed to end the disorder of the age.
Sources
- Fraser, Chris. "Mohism." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of Mozi's thought and the Later Mohists.
- Graham, A. C. Later Mohist Logic, Ethics and Science. Hong Kong: Chinese University Press, 1978.Study of the Canons and Explanations.
- Mozi. The Mozi: A Complete Translation. Translated by Ian Johnston. New York: Columbia University Press, 2010.Full English translation of the Mozi.
- Van Norden, Bryan W. Introduction to Classical Chinese Philosophy. Indianapolis: Hackett, 2011.Includes a chapter on Mozi and the Mohists.