Philosophy / Chinese
Legalism
Chinese ideas of rule by clear law, reward and punishment, and administrative method rather than moral example
- Began
- Shang Yang's reforms in Qin, 4th century BC, are the usual marker, though Shen Buhai and Shen Dao were active at about the same timeScholars: The name "Legalism" is later. Han dynasty writers grouped these thinkers as fajia, literally the "school" or "group" of fa (law, standards, methods). Historians debate whether they formed a unified school at all, and the Han grouping is itself debated.
- Where
- China, especially the state of Qin during the Warring States period
- Key figures
- No single founder. Key figures were Shang Yang, Shen Buhai, Shen Dao, Han Fei and Li Si
- Key works
- The Book of Lord Shang; Han Feizi; Shenzi (fragments only, preserved in later sources); Guanzi (a composite work; only some chapters are close to Legalist ideas)
At a glance
Legalism is the modern name for a group of Chinese ideas about how to govern a state. Its thinkers tended to hold that a ruler should rely on clear laws, firm rewards and harsh punishments, and on administrative method, rather than on the goodness of officials or the people. Han dynasty writers called them fajia, the school or group of fa, a word meaning law, standard or method.
These ideas grew in the Warring States period (475 to 221 BC), when seven major states fought for survival. Shang Yang, a minister in the state of Qin in the 4th century BC, put many of them into practice. Shen Buhai and Shen Dao were roughly contemporary, and Han Fei, writing in the 3rd century BC, drew on all three in an especially influential synthesis.
Legalist writers were distinctive in treating moral example as an unreliable basis for government. They argued against Confucian and other views that trusted virtue, ritual and tradition, though the Confucianism of the time was not one uniform position. They wanted a state that would work even under an ordinary ruler. Historians debate how far Legalism was a real school, since the label came later.
Key concepts
- fa (law)
- Public standards, including laws, rewards and penalties, set by the ruler so that officials and people know what is expected; how far the ruler himself was bound by fa is debated.
- shu (technique)
- The methods a ruler uses to control officials, such as testing whether their deeds match their words. Shen Buhai stressed this.
- shi (position or authority)
- The power that comes from holding the ruler's seat, which Shen Dao and Han Fei said works regardless of the ruler's personal talent.
- xingming (forms and names)
- The idea that an official's performance should match the duties he promised to carry out, and be rewarded or punished accordingly.
- Two handles
- Han Fei's term for reward and punishment, the two tools by which a ruler controls his ministers and people.
- Farming and war
- Shang Yang's aim, as presented in the Book of Lord Shang, of turning people toward agriculture and the army, seen as the sources of a state's wealth and strength.
Core ideas
- Many Legalist texts hold that people are mainly moved by desire for gain and fear of harm, so a state should steer them with rewards and punishments.
- Laws should be clear and public so that officials and people can know the standards they are held to.
- Some texts, especially the Book of Lord Shang, favour heavy penalties even for small offences, meant to prevent crime before it began.
- A strong state needs a productive farming population and a disciplined army.
- A ruler should keep control through position and method, so the state does not depend on rare wise men.
- Appeals to tradition and ritual should not block reforms that suit the times.
Key arguments
The stump-watcher
Han Fei told of a farmer who saw a hare run into a stump and die. He then waited by the stump for more hares. Legalists used this to argue that copying the ancient kings is as foolish as waiting for luck, because times change and so must rules.
Against waiting for sages
Han Fei argued that sage rulers like Yao and Shun appear only once in a thousand years. Most rulers are average, so a state must be built on laws that an average ruler can enforce.
Punishment to end punishment
The Book of Lord Shang argues that severe penalties make people afraid to offend, so that in the end few need to be punished. This is the text's own justification for strictness, not a result shown by evidence.
Reform in Qin
Shang Yang's reforms rewarded military merit with rank, tied people into mutual responsibility groups and encouraged farming. Many historians link them to Qin's later strength, but how much they contributed, compared with other developments in Qin, is a matter of interpretation.
Philosophers
- Shang Yang c. 390–338 BCMinister of Qin whose reforms became a model for Legalist government; the Book of Lord Shang is traditionally linked to him but is generally seen as a later compilation by several authors.
- Shen Buhai c. 400–337 BCMinister of Han who stressed administrative technique and the control of officials.
- Shen Dao c. 350–275 BCThinker who emphasised the power of the ruler's position over his personal virtue.
- Han Fei c. 280–233 BCPrince of Han who drew together law, technique and position in the Han Feizi; he died in Qin.
- Li Si c. 280–208 BCChief minister of the First Emperor of Qin, who helped build the imperial administration.
Main criticisms
Is rule by fear sustainable?
Critics, including Confucians and many Han writers, said harsh punishment bred resentment and that Qin fell quickly, in 206 BC, partly for this reason. Defenders say Qin's collapse followed the First Emperor's death and court struggles, and that its administrative methods lasted.
Does law replace virtue?
Confucians argued that people ruled only by fear avoid wrongdoing without feeling shame or developing character. Legalists answered that moral example cannot be relied on in large states, while clear rules work in practice.
Was it a real school?
Some historians say Legalism was a later label, made by Han writers, for thinkers who differed a good deal. Others point to shared themes of law, method and state power and find the label useful if used carefully.
Power without limits
Critics note that the ruler stood above the law in much Legalist writing and had no check on his power. Defenders say Legalist writers saw this as needed for order, and that their stress on public standards and official accountability was meant to restrain abuse below the throne.
Sources
- Pines, Yuri. "Legalism in Chinese Philosophy." In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Covers the thinkers, ideas and the debate over the label, including how Legalist ideas continued in later Chinese statecraft.
- Han Fei. Han Feizi: Basic Writings. Translated by Burton Watson. New York: Columbia University Press, 2003.Standard English selection of Han Fei's essays.
- Fu, Zhengyuan. China's Legalists: The Earliest Totalitarians and Their Art of Ruling. Armonk: M. E. Sharpe, 1996.Study of Legalist political thought.