Philosophy / Chinese
Cheng–Zhu school
The Neo-Confucian school that finds moral order in principle (li) and shapes the mind through study and reverence
- Began
- 12th century, systematised by Zhu Xi (1130–1200)Scholars: Its roots lie in the 11th-century thinkers Zhou Dunyi, Zhang Zai and the Cheng brothers. Zhu Xi gathered their ideas into one system in the 12th century.
- Where
- China, in the Song dynasty. It later spread to Korea, Japan and Vietnam.
- Key figures
- No single founder. Early figures include Zhou Dunyi, Zhang Zai, Cheng Hao and Cheng Yi. Zhu Xi consolidated their ideas into the school's full form.
- Key works
- The Four Books (Analects, Mencius, Great Learning, Doctrine of the Mean); Zhu Xi, Collected Commentaries on the Four Books; Reflections on Things at Hand (compiled by Zhu Xi and Lü Zuqian); Classified Conversations of Master Zhu (a later compilation of Zhu Xi's recorded sayings)
At a glance
The Cheng–Zhu school is a branch of Neo-Confucianism. It takes its name from Cheng Yi (1033–1107), his brother Cheng Hao (1032–1085) and Zhu Xi (1130–1200). Its followers believe that the world has a moral order, and that people can learn to live in line with it.
The school grew in the Song dynasty, when scholars wanted to renew Confucian teaching. Zhu Xi chose four texts, the Analects, Mencius, the Great Learning and the Doctrine of the Mean, as the base of education. These became known as the Four Books.
What makes the school distinctive is its pairing of principle (li) and material force (qi). It also stresses careful study of things and texts, joined with calm, respectful self-cultivation. From the early 14th century, its commentaries were used for the state civil service examinations in China. This made it very influential for centuries.
Key concepts
- li (principle)
- The pattern or order in each thing, including the moral order that makes up human nature.
- qi (material force)
- The physical and vital stuff of which all things are made, which gives each thing its particular shape and condition.
- taiji (Supreme Ultimate)
- The whole of principle, in which all the patterns of the world are united.
- gewu (investigation of things)
- Studying things and affairs in order to understand the principle in them.
- jing (reverent seriousness)
- A steady, attentive state of mind that supports moral growth.
- xing (human nature)
- Principle as it is found in a person, which the school holds to be good.
Core ideas
- Everything that exists is made of qi and ordered by li.
- Human nature is principle in a person, and it is basically good.
- People can fall short of goodness because their qi may be cloudy or unbalanced.
- Learning proceeds by investigating things and reading the classics, so that principle becomes clear.
- Reverent seriousness keeps the mind steady while a person studies.
- The aim is to become a sage, and ordinary people can work toward it.
Key arguments
Principle and material force
Li gives each thing its pattern, and qi gives it body. A person's goodness comes from li, while differences in character come from the clearness or cloudiness of their qi.
Investigation of things
Zhu Xi read the Great Learning as teaching that knowledge begins with investigating things. By studying many things and texts over time, a person comes to see principle, and one day understands it more fully.
Two sides of cultivation
Zhu Xi taught that people should both study and keep a reverent mind. Study without reverence is scattered, and reverence without study lacks direction.
The Four Books
Zhu Xi arranged the Four Books as a course of study. He held that they gave a path from basic learning to the highest moral understanding.
Philosophers
- Cheng Hao 1032–1085Song thinker who stressed the unity of humans with the world, and whose ideas were later drawn on by thinkers of the Lu–Wang tradition.
- Cheng Yi 1033–1107Younger brother of Cheng Hao, whose stress on principle and the investigation of things shaped Zhu Xi.
- Zhu Xi 1130–1200Scholar who brought earlier Neo-Confucian ideas into one system and wrote the standard commentaries on the Four Books.
- Yi Hwang (Toegye) 1501–1570Korean scholar who became a leading voice of the Cheng–Zhu tradition in Korea.
- Hayashi Razan 1583–1657Japanese scholar who promoted Zhu Xi's teaching in early Tokugawa Japan.
Main criticisms
Is the mind itself principle?
Wang Yangming (1472–1529) and his followers argued that Zhu Xi's outward study splits knowing from acting, and that moral knowledge is already in the mind. Defenders of Zhu Xi reply that the mind can be clouded, so careful study of things and texts is needed to guide it.
Too far from the early Confucians?
Some scholars of the Qing dynasty, though they differed among themselves, criticised Song learning. Some said it took on Buddhist or Daoist ideas, and others attacked Zhu Xi's readings on textual or method grounds. Followers reply that his ideas draw out meanings already implied in the Confucian texts.
Does the examination system narrow thought?
Critics say that making the school's commentaries the examination standard led to rote learning and limited new ideas. Defenders say that the commentaries gave a shared moral education across a very large empire.
Is principle prior to qi?
Thinkers in China and Korea argued about how li and qi relate, and whether li has any priority. Zhu Xi's followers held them to be distinct but never found apart, and this has remained a topic of interpretation.
Sources
- Bol, Peter K. "Zhu Xi." In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta.Overview of Zhu Xi's life and philosophy.
- "Zhu Xi." In Encyclopaedia Britannica.Short biography and summary of his teaching.
- Chan, Wing-tsit. A Source Book in Chinese Philosophy. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1963.Translated selections, including from Zhu Xi and the Cheng brothers.
- Gardner, Daniel K. Zhu Xi's Reading of the Analects. New York: Columbia University Press, 2003.Study of how Zhu Xi read and taught the classics.